MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews

FOGHORN Classics

Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews

All HDTT reviews

Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World

all Nimbus reviews

all tudor reviews

Follow us on Twitter

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Chandos recordings
All Chandos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews

all Bridge reviews

all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All Eloquence reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews


Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing



May 2011/1 Download Roundup

Brian Wilson

Download of the Month

The Queen’s Music: Italian Vocal Duets and Trios

Anonymous Parlate per me [2:02]
Luigi ROSSI (c.1597-1653) Tu sarai sempre [2:24]
Antonio CESTI (1623-1669) Gia son morto [3:05]
Dite o Cieli [1:34]
Anonymous Pian piano mio core [2:43]
Girolamo Alessandro FRESCOBALDI (1583-1643) Toccate e partite d’intavolatura di cimbalo et organo, libro primo: Toccata ottava [4:04]
Giacomo CARISSIMI (1605-74) Sciolto havean dall’alte sponde (I naviganti) [12:56]
Girolamo Alessandro FRESCOBALDI In partitura il primo libro delle canzoni: Canzona settima detta la Superba (o Tuccina) (arr. for cello and harpsichord) [3:36]
Luigi ROSSI O Cieli pietà [3:38]
Lasso benche mi fugga [4:40]
Girolamo Alessandro FRESCOBALDI Toccate e partite d’intavolatura di cimbalo et organo, libro primo: Toccata nona [5:27]
Luigi ROSSI Pene che volete [2:06]
Pietà, spietati lumi [2:49]
Anonymous Partitevi da me [2:13]
Luigi ROSSI Vorrei scoprirti [2:42]
Anonymous Occhi Belli [2:14]
Girolamo Alessandro FRESCOBALDI Toccate e partite d’intavolatura di cimbalo et organo, libro secondo: Toccata seconda [3:41]
Anonymous E’ di ragion [4:18]
Emma Kirkby, Susanne Rydén (sopranos); Peter Harvey (baritone); Mikarl Bellini (counter-tenor); Mime Yamahiro Brinkmann (cello); Lars Ulrik Mortensen (harpsichord)
rec. Länna Church, Sweden, May 2008. DDD.
Booklet included with texts and translations.
BIS BIS-CD-1715 [68:16] – from (mp3, lossless and 24-bit) or stream from Naxos Music Library

[A version of this review also appears on the main MusicWeb International pages - here]

All that Emma Kirkby’s many fans – I’m a long-standing member – need to know is that her voice is still holding up extremely well at an age which I’m too gallant to mention, but when many sopranos have fizzled out. She receives fine support from Susanne Rydén, whose voice is just different enough to be distinguishable from and to blend with Kirkby’s in duets and ensembles. There’s also predictably first-rate support from the other performers, excellent recording and short but informative notes and texts with idiomatic translations. You may purchase The Queen’s Music with confidence.

The programme, derived from a manuscript in the library of Christ Church, Oxford, and connected with the court of the Swedish Queen Christina prior to her abdication in 1654, is ideal for Kirkby and her collaborators. The music is all attractive: it’s interesting to speculate to what extent Christina’s love of this kind of Italian music led her to Rome. The most familiar name among the composers of the vocal items, and the one most frequently represented on this recording, is that of Luigi Rossi, closely followed by that of Carissimi, who contributes the longest item here, I Naviganti, the Sailors.

Most of the music is for two sopranos, but there are other combinations to provide a variety, including duets for soprano and baritone, on some of which Kirkby features, with Rydén on others. The variety is further strengthened by the inclusion of four keyboard works by Frescobaldi, one of them rearranged for cello and harpsichord for even greater variety. Lars Ulrik Mortensen performs these in a manner likely to make you want more – in which case, you can’t do better than to turn to Richard Lester’s ongoing series on Nimbus – see review.

Rossi and Carissimi were connected with the early development of opera and much of their music has an operatic intensity. I Naviganti in particular, for two sopranos and baritone, is reminiscent of the semi-operatic Florentine Intermedii of 1589. The splendid EMI recording of this piece, directed by Andrew Parrott, seems unfortunately to have fallen out of the catalogue, though a later version directed by Skip Sempé is still available as a download from and on CD from in the US. I Naviganti is not only the longest work in the collection; it’s also the highlight as far as I’m concerned.

The Queen’s Music offers 68 minutes of sheer delight, but I can report an even longer and equally delectable programme. Emma Kirkby also appears with Jakob Lindberg (lute) on a recent BIS CD of earlier music, equally divided between Purcell and Dowland, Orpheus in England, BIS-CD-1725 – also from in mp3, lossless and 24-bit. As on The Queen’s Music, instrumental tracks are interspersed among the vocal items – nobody does them better or proves a superior accompanist in the songs than Lindberg.

You may already have some of Kirkby’s earlier recordings of this repertoire, for example with Anthony Rooley on a most inexpensive Virgin Veritas 2-CD set (5624102, around £7.50), but the partnership with Lindberg is – predictably – at least as fruitful. Essential listening, both.

Bargain of the Month

William WALTON (1902-1983) Violin Concerto (rev.1945)* [26:53]
Camille SAINT-SAËNS (1835-1921) Havanaise, Op. 83** [9:19]
Christian SINDING (1856-1941) Suite im alten Stil, Op. 10^ [11:46]
Mario CASTELNUOVO-TEDESCO (1895-1968) Violin Concerto No. 2 ‘The Prophets’ (1931)^^ [29:27]
Jascha Heifetz (violin)
Philharmonia Orchestra/William Walton*
RCA Victor Symphony Orchestra/William Steinberg**
Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra/Alfred Wallenstein^/^^
rec. EMI Studio No.1, Abbey Road, London, 26-27 July, 1950*; Sound Stage 9, Republic Pictures Studio, Hollywood, 18 June 1951**, 9 December 1953^ and 28-29 October 1954^^. ADD/mono.
NAXOS HISTORICAL 8.111367 [77:25] – from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

[A version of this review will also appear on the main MusicWeb International pages]

It’s hardly surprising that the Naxos Historical Great Violinists series already contains several Jascha Heifetz recordings, including his 1949 recording of the original score of the Walton Violin Concerto, coupled with his 1941 version of the Elgar Violin Concerto on 8.110939 – see review. Now we have his 1950 recording of the revised version of the Walton, in re-mastered sound as bright as a button and coupled with three other recordings from the early LP era. The back cover of the CD refers to Heifetz’s polished elegance, but there’s more to it than that. Some of Paganini’s contemporaries thought that he’d sold his soul to the Devil to obtain such mastery of the violin: they might well have thought the same of Heifetz, when everything here seems grist to his mill.

The Walton concerto was composed for Heifetz and, while it’s good also to have more recent versions, notably from Nigel Kennedy, with the Viola Concerto (not currently available?), Kurt Nikkanen (Nimbus NI6119 – see October 2010 Download Roundup), and Naxos’s own digital recording with Dong Suk-Kang, a splendid bargain coupled with the Cello Concerto (8.554325 – see review and November 2008 Download Roundup), Heifetz still reigns supreme, with Walton and the Philharmonia providing excellent support and Mark Obert-Thorn excelling himself with a transfer which makes the recording sound almost as if it were made yesterday. Even the limitations of mono hardly seem to matter.

After the Walton, the Saint-Saëns Havanaise inevitably sounds somewhat trite. Naxos have chosen to present these recordings in the chronological order of their setting down, but I could have wished the Walton to have been left until last. Nevertheless, it’s churlish to complain when Heifetz weaves his magic here, too, ably abetted by the RCA Orchestra and William Steinberg.

The Sinding Suite is more substantial and it, too, receives a performance that makes me wonder why we don’t hear this work as often as the composer’s Violin Concerto. This recording is rightly regarded as a Heifetz special.

The final work, Castelnuovo-Tedesco’s ‘Prophets’ Concerto was also composed for Heifetz. As the notes observe, though it pre-dates his time in Hollywood, it does have a Technicolor quality not unlike Respighi or Korngold. Once more the music presents no problems for Heifetz and the LAPO under Wallenstein. Beecham used to have the knack of making good second-rate music sound first-rate and that’s exactly what all concerned do here.

I’ve already praised the quality of the Walton transfer but the whole of the rest of the programme has received equally fine re-mastering. I’ve heard some fine transfers recently from Beulah and High Definition Tape Transfers, but nothing to excel what I hear on this CD. There were just a few moments in the Castelnuovo-Tedesco when I felt that the treble needed to be tamed a little, but it’s not a serious problem.

Naxos already have the superb 1955 Heifetz/Reiner recording of the Brahms Violin Concerto in their download-only series (9.80081, available in the UK for £1.99). Perhaps they would consider adding that to the Great Violinists series. For my money, Heifetz is the exponent of the Brahms, taking the opening movement at the only speed that makes sense unless you want to have a work with two slow movements. Only one other recording, from Szeryng, again with Reiner as conductor, also from RCA, came close – and that’s deleted.

This fine tribute to Jascha Heifetz is not available in the USA and in several other countries, for copyright reasons. Fortunately, the same recording of the Walton is available inexpensively* on RCA (2 CDs, 74321925752). See reviews by John Quinn – here – and Rob Barnett – here. Soon recordings of this vintage may not be available in the EU, either, so snap it up while you can.

* It’s on offer so inexpensively that it’s hardly worth considering downloading it.

Discovery of the Month

John GARDNER (b.1917)

Flourish for a Wedding, Op. 162 (1983) [2:57]
Easter Fantasy, Op. 232 (1997) [6:41]
Theme and Variations for Brass Quartet, Op. 7 (1952) [11:11]
Five Dances for Organ, Op. 179 (1988) [17:16]
Sonata da Chiesa sopra un thema di Claudio Monteverdi, Op. 136 (1976) [13:44]
Sonata Secolare, Op. 117 (1973) [15:21]
Paul Archibald (trumpet); Cosmopolitan Brass (Helen Sanger, Stephen Pemberton (trumpets), Kate Hainsworth, Alex Hambleton (horns), Craig Beattie, Fabian Schmidt (trombones), Yao Cong Tan (tuba)); Stephen King (organ); Chris Gardner (conductor):
rec. Brentwood Cathedral, 29-30 January, 12 February, 25 June 2010
TOCCATA CLASSICS TOCC0048 [67:10] – from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

If you’d asked me what I thought of the tune of the Advent chorale Wachet auf! as the basis of a work entitled Flourish for a Wedding before I heard this recording I’d have said ‘not much’. In the event, it’s a wonderful introduction to a most enjoyable programme by a composer whom I’d have said that I’d never heard of before, though I must have – his music appears on several recordings of choral music for Christmas. As I write, a week before the Royal Wedding and a few days before Easter, the first two items are wonderfully topical.

John Sheppard made this a well-deserved Recording of the Month in CD form – here – and there’s an article by Paul Conway on the composer here.

A glitch in my review access to Toccata led me to listen via the Naxos Music Library. They also have the Naxos recording of Gardner’s Midsummer Ale Overture, First Piano Concerto and First Symphony (8.570406) which John Quinn thought well worth investigating – see review – and which deeply impressed Dominy Clements – see review. That’s also available in mp3 from (mp3) and (mp3 and lossless).

Heinrich SCHÜTZ (1585-1672) Symphoniæ Sacræ, Book II (1647)
Es steh Gott auf [6:02]
Was betrübst du dich? [5:36]
Singet dem Herrn ein neues Lied [4:28]
Drei schöne Dinge seind [8:18]
Herr unser Herrscher [5:09]
Lobet den Herrn [4:30]
Von Gott will ich nicht lassen [7:43]
Verleih uns Frieden [3:37]
Gib unsern Fürsten [3:56]
Herr, nun lässest Du Deinen Diener im Friede fahren [3:42]
Freuet euch des Herren [5:10]
Chapelle Rhénane/Benoît Haller – rec. no details supplied
Booklet with notes in French, English and German, together with German texts and French translations available from K617 – here – click on ‘télécharger le livret’
K617 K617163 [58:32] – from (mp3)

This is a welcome supplement to the earlier Schütz recording by these same forces which I reviewed in the December 2009 Roundup. If you found the Schütz passion settings which I reviewed last month rather astringent, this is Schütz in a very different vein: mostly celebratory texts set in an uplifting style derived from Monteverdi and his Venetian contemporaries. With sound direction and singing and good recording – albeit at a range of bit-rates from 180kb/s to 320kb/s, mostly at 192kb/s – this is well worth £4.62 or less from eMusic. also have this recording, presumably at a higher bit-rate, for £7.49.

Pierre ROBERT (1625-1699) Grands Motets (1684)
De profundis [16:01]
Requiem æternam [5:46]
Quare fremuerunt gentes [8:29]
Reges eos in virga ferrea [6:07]
Te decet hymnus [10:40]
Præparans montes [5:50]
Rivos ejus inebria [6:49]
Nisi Dominus [9:11]
Olivier Cesarini, Dagmar Saskova, Damien Guillon, Robert Getchell, Jean-François Novelli, Alain Buet, Arnaud Richard (soloists)
Les Pages et les Chantres du Centre de Musique Baroque de Versailles; Musica Florea/Olivier Schneebeli
K617 K617215 [68:53] – from (mp3)

Pierre Robert has given his name to a distinguished ensemble who record for the Alpha label. So far as I’m aware, they have left it to another French label, K617, to record their namesake. In fact, I can’t find any rival recordings of Robert’s music in the catalogue, which is surprising when these Grands Motets are so good.

No texts this time, even from the K617 homepage, but most of the words are readily available online. Only Rivos ejus inebria (fill the rivers [of the land] to overflowing) is unfamiliar – it’s a text associated with the harvest festivities formerly celebrated in the Tridentine Rite on the Feast of the Assumption. The singing is slightly less accomplished than that of the Chapelle Rhénane in the K617 recording of Schütz (above), but not so that you would be disappointed.

All the tracks are at a bit-rate higher than 192kb/s – two are at the maximum 320kb/s – and the sound is good.

John BLOW (1649-1708) Chloe found Amintas lying (A Song for Three Voices) [6:20];
Ground in g minor for violin and continuo [3:56]
Michel LAMBERT (1610-1696) Vos mépris chaque jour [3:41]
Robert de VISÉE (c.1655-1732/2) Chaconne [5:12]
John BLOW Venus and Adonis (1683) [55:37]
Sophie Daneman (soprano, Venus), Roderick Williams (baritone, Adonis), Elin Manahan Thomas (soprano, Cupid), Helen Neeves (soprano, shepherdess), Caroline Sartin (alto, shepherd), Jason Darnell (tenor, huntsman), Frederick Long (bass, shepherd), Cupids, from Salisbury Cathedral School: Grace Beverley, Flora Davies, Kelly Frost, Hermione Leitch, Rebecca Lyles, Helena Mackie, Georgiana Roxburgh, Rosanna Wicks
Theatre of the Ayre (Rachel Podger, Clare Salaman (violins), Galina Zinchenko (viola), Alison McGillivray (bass violin and viol), Pamela Thorby, Kate Latham, Merlin Harrison (recorders), David Miller (theorbos/guitars), James Johnstone (harpsichord)/Elizabeth Kenny (director/theorbo/guitar))
rec. live, Wigmore Hall, London, 3 May 2010. DDD
Booklet with texts included.
WIGMORE HALL LIVE WHL0043 (75:14) – from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

Unless you have an aversion to baroque pastoral, you should be charmed by this recording. The Wigmore Hall is my favourite classical music venue and I wish I’d been there last May when this concert was given. John Blow rather unfairly plays second fiddle to his contemporary Purcell; though I’m a great fan of Purcell, Blow’s Venus and Adonis can look Dido and Æneas squarely in the eye. The few recordings that have been made of this work have all been good – an old, long-deleted SEON version, Philip Pickett on Decca Oiseau-Lyre 478 0019 and René Jacobs on Harmonia Mundi HMG 501684, the latter two still available at mid-price. This live recording steals the field, not least for the short works with which the main dish is seasoned. The recording places the performers a little more distantly than I’d have liked, but that’s a minor reservation. The download comes at the attractive price of £4.99 – and that includes the booklet with the texts.

Georg Philipp TELEMANN (1681-1727) Trios and Quartets
Quadro in D for 2 Transverse Flutes and 2 Bassoons, TWV43:D2 [8:06]
Trio in d minor for Transverse Flute, Oboe and basso continuo, TWV42:d4 [8:04]
Quadro in F for Oboe, 2 Bassoons and basso continuo (from Sonata a 3 TWV42:F16, reconstructed by Sergio AZZOLINI) [10:16]
Quadro in A for 2 Transverse Flutes and 2 Violoncellos, TWV43:A2 [7:10]
Trio in G for Transverse Flute, Oboe and basso continuo, TWV 42:G13 [6:27]
Sonata in g minor for Oboe and Bassoon, TWV41:g12 [9:46]
Trio in e minor for Transverse Flute, Oboe and basso continuo, TWV42:e9 [6:53]
Quadro in E for 2 Transverse Flutes and 2 Violoncellos, TWV43:E1 [8:31]
Epoca Barocca (Marcello Gatti, Elisa Cozzini (transverse flutes); Alessandro Piqué (oboe); Sergio Azzolini, Al Ikeda (bassoons); Ilze Grudule, Stephanie Meyer (cellos); Matthias Spaeter (archlute); Christophe Lehmann (harpsichord and organ))
rec. Deutschlandfunk Kammersaal, 30 November-3 December, 2006. DDD.
CPO 777 441-2 [65:57] – from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

Tastes of Europe: Telemann Trios and Quartets
Quartet in G, TWV 43:G6 [7:24]
Trio in e minor for two dessus (top voices) and basso continuo, TWV 42:e11 [12:42]
Trio 3 in g minor for oboe, violin and continuo (42:g5) [10:56]
Trio 7 in F for recorder, viola da gamba and basso continuo, TWV 42:F3 [6:48]
Concerto in a minor for recorder, violin, oboe and basso continuo, TWV 43:a3 [10:19]
Trio in b minor for violin, viola da gamba and basso continuo, TWV 42:h620 [3:10]
Trio in d minor for recorder, violin and basso continuo, TWV 42:d10 [8:57]
Ensemble Meridiana
LINN RECORDS CKD368 [60:00] – from (SACD, mp3, lossless and 24-bit)

[A version of this review will also appear on the main MusicWeb International pages]

Though I hadn’t encountered them before, Epoca Barocca have made a number of recordings – one for Chandos and five for CPO. Johan van Veen praised their Chandos Hasse recording for refusing to ‘pump up’ the music to sound more than it is (CHAN0711 – see review), and I found their playing here in Telemann to have exactly that same quality . If that’s what you are looking for, go and buy with confidence.

On this new recording I hear all of the technical skill which Johan van Veen mentions in that Chandos review and, again, in his review of Epoca Barocca in Trios and Sonatas by Christoph Schaffrath (CPO 777 116-2 – see review). What I don’t hear is the power to rise above the ordinary which I find almost universally in Telemann’s other music and I’m inclined to blame the composer rather than the performers. Though I note that rival recordings of individual sonatas on the Lyrichord and Accent labels are a little faster than here – Melomanie take just 7:33 for the Quadro in D, on LEMS8028, against Epoca’s 8:06 – I don’t think that’s the major problem.

All the music here is urbane and charming, with sprightly outer movements and pensive slow movements, and there is variety of instrumentation between the works, but there isn’t much more to it. Maybe on this occasion it might have been better if the Epoca players had done a little pumping to make it sound a little less ephemeral. Actually, they do try to give the music a lift, though not quite as much as Melomanie, who succeed slightly more in catching my interest on that Lyrichord recording. Whatever the case, this CPO CD or download may be just the thing for playing softly in the background when guests come round.

There is, however, a better option. The Linn recording was made in York in March 2010 by Ensemble Meridiana, here making an auspicious recording debut. The music is a cut above that on the CPO disc, for all that it’s also drawn from TWV42 and TWV43 – either that, or the Meridiana performers make more of it. 60 minutes of sheer delight.

Even better is the fact that there is no overlap between these two recordings. The Linn also includes a Trio now known to have been composed not by Telemann but by Pierre Prowo.

Both the Linn and CPO discs are well recorded and come with a helpful programme booklet – not available, unfortunately, with the download in the case of Linn, despite what I’ve written to the contrary elsewhere, though the notes can be copied and pasted from the Linn web-page.

Neither of these new recordings would be my chosen entry-point for Telemann. A good place to start would be with the various recordings which Collegium Musicum 90 have made for Chandos – try CHAN0661 and CHAN0547 for starters – or the budget-price Hyperion Helios reissue of the a minor Recorder Suite and other works on CDH55091 (Peter Holstlag and Peter Holman – see my May 2010 Download Roundup). The Chandos recordings are best downloaded from their own and the Hyperion again from the home site,

Those who already know some of Telemann’s larger-scale suites and concertos, and who wish to investigate the Trios and Quartets could do much worse than the Linn recording. To investigate this area of Telemann’s output further, I recommend another CPO recording, Paris Quartets, Volume 1 (777 375-2, with Messrs Holloway, Mortensen, etc. – see review by Glyn Pursglove). There’s no overlap with either of the new recordings, but I’d recommend the new CPO recording only after trying the other two. Subscribers can try all the recordings which I’ve mentioned, from the Naxos Music Library, where you’ll also find the CPO booklet and the other Epoca Barocca recordings for that label. NML also have rival recordings of some of the individual works on the new CPO CD.

George Frideric HANDEL (1685-1759)
Eight Great Suites for Solo Harpsichord HWV426-433 (1720)
CD 1
Suite No. 1 in A, HWV 426 [11:26]
Suite No. 2 in F, HWV 427 [8:54]
Suite No. 3 in d minor, HWV428 [23:16]*
Suite No. 4 in e minor, HWV 429 [12:46]
CD 2
Suite No. 5 in E, HWV 430 [13:44]
Suite No. 6 in f# minor, HWV 431[9:02]
Suite No. 7 in g minor, HWV 432 [19:49]
Suite No. 8 in f minor, HWV 433 [12:05]
Laurence Cummings (harpsichord)
rec. Handel House London, 4-6 and 9 November 2008. DDD.
Recorded in collaboration with BBC Radio 3 and Handel House Museum in celebration of Handel’s 250th Anniversary.
* Not 3:16 as stated on rear insert.
SOMM CÉLESTE SOMMCD 095-2 [57:42 + 55:00] – from (mp3 and lossless)

Suites for harpsichord: Volume 1
CD 1
Suite in d minor, HWV428 [24:52]**
Suite in A, HWV454 [14:35]
Suite in e minor, HWV438 [8:07]
Suite in C, HWV443 [27:12]
CD 2
Suite in g minor, HWV439 [17:15]
Suite in G, HWV441 [21:49]
Suite in e minor, HWV429 [16:30]
Suite in E, HWV430 [14:50]
Gilbert Rowland (harpsichord)
** Not 42:52 as stated on rear insert.
DIVINE ART DDA2129 [74:54 + 71:34] – from (mp3 and lossless) or (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

[A version of this review will also appear on the main MusicWeb International pages]

By what turns out in some ways to have been a fortunate oversight, the Somm recording got stuck at the bottom of a pile of CDs for review, with my review half written, until the Divine Art arrived and reminded me of its existence. As both are available in download form from, and the Divine Art recording also from, the quickest way to repair the omission and partially make amends to Somm was to include them in this Roundup, with a more detailed review to follow on the main MusicWeb International pages.

Actually, the two are not direct rivals, since Rowland’s programme includes only three of the ‘Great’ Suites from ‘Set 1’ HWV428, 429 and 430 – presumably, the others will appear in subsequent volumes. They do, however, share some sloppy booklet and insert proof-reading which makes HWV428 three minutes long from Cummings and an equally unlikely 43 minutes from Rowland. I’ve given the correct, much closer, figures above.

I can’t pretend that the new CDs are the most exciting product of the Handel anniversary year and its aftermath, but they represent a welcome addition to the catalogue. Apart from the chief competitor, Paul Nicholson on a 2-for-1 Hyperion Dyad reissue of HWV426-433 plus eight fugues (CDD22045 – download from Hyperion in mp3 and lossless), and the few other recordings listed below, these Suites are not over-represented in the catalogue. Unfortunately for his rivals, however, Nicholson’s playing is mostly of very high quality and the Hyperion price highly attractive: stiff competition for the new releases.

John France regarded the Hyperion set as his benchmark, though he also thought that Ottavio Dantone’s performances on Arts 47698-2 and 47699-2, which also contain several extra pieces, compared favourably – see review. Mark Sealey thought that Sophie Yates’ recording on Chandos had much to commend it (Chandos CHAN0644, 0669 and 0688), though preferring the Arkiv CDR reissue of Trevor Pinnock’s recording of some of the Suites (410 656-2 – see review). That Arkiv CD offers rather short value, though the price, currently $14.99, partially redresses the balance. (Download from passionato – here – in mp3 or flac, on special offer for £3.99/£4.99 at the time of writing).

In the main Laurence Cummings is slower than the opposition, but some of his tempi are decidedly fast: the presto finale of Suite No.3, HWV428, so familiar from the organ concertos – Handel’s typical re-use of his own material – is a case in point. He dashes this off in 4:35, at which speed it sounds ever so slightly a scramble, as against Nicholson’s more sedate 5:04 and Rowland’s slightly too deliberate 5:22. Martin Souter (The Gift of Music CCLCD009, Suites 1-5) is even faster at 4:28, yet contrives to sound deliberate rather than rushed. Isolde Ahlgrimm (Corona Classic Collection 001952CCC, Suites 1-4 and Chaconne in G) and Alan Cuckston (Naxos 8.550415, Suites 1-5) cut the repeat and shorten the movement to 3:00 and 2:38 respectively, thereby almost editing it out of existence, which is a shame because Ahlgrimm, one of the pioneers of modern harpsichord playing, gives a very personal interpretation.

We’ve already seen that Rowland is a little more deliberate than Cummings in the finale of HWV428 and that’s true in most of the movements of that work. Where Rowland is slightly faster, the difference is hardly perceptible in practice, but where he is slower, it’s often by quite a margin:

Air and Doubles

I had noted Rowland’s slightly deliberate manner even before I compared the timings, especially in the Allemande.

Rowland’s version of HWV429 takes 16:30 overall against Cummings’ 13:46: this time it’s the fourth movement Sarabande that accounts for most of the difference, with honours about even in the other sections. A sarabande is a slow and stately dance, so there’s a good case to be made for Rowland’s decision to take almost half as long again as Cummings, yet ultimately I come down on Cummings’ side.

As a final comparison, I’ll take the famous ‘Harmonious Blacksmith’, the final Air and Variations from HWV430. Here, for once, Rowland is slightly faster than Cummings – 4:25 against 4:47 – and both are in line with the view which most performers take for the tempo here: Cuckston, at 4:39, and Nicholson, at 4:35, split the difference almost exactly. More to the point, I found none of the over-deliberation in Rowland’s free-wheeling performance that I noted elsewhere. I thought his account preferable to the slower tempo adopted by Cummings and by Blandine Verlet in a recording of the Eight Suites for Auvidis Astrée (E8655) – on paper, she seems much faster by dint of omitting some repeats. On the other hand, if you want this movement played in a lighter, more pastoral style on a softer-voiced instrument, the gentle touch and more distant recording of Cummings on Somm will be your preferred choice. He evokes, as it were, the village blacksmith whose name has come to be attached to this piece; all the more so when it’s played on its own.

It’s swings and roundabouts, then, in terms of performance from Cummings, Rowland and Nicholson. That all three are Handelians through and through is never in doubt: Laurence Cummings in particular is the director of the London Handel Festival and has participated in a number of admirable recordings of the composer for Somm, as conductor (Joshua, SOMMCD240-2; Esther, SOMMCD238) and as a member of the London Handel Players (Flute Concerto and others, SOMMCD055; Violin Sonatas, SOMMCD068), all available for download from Until I started making direct comparisons, my feeling was that I could be happy with any one of these three sets and that remains true.

With two CDs for the price of one, the Hyperion is the least expensive and the lossless download comes at the same price as the mp3, £7.99, with the booklet as part of the deal. Classicsonline offer the 2-CD Divine Art set for £9.98, but there’s no booklet. charge £11.99 or £14.99 for the Somm (mp3/lossless respectively).

The difference between the two recordings and instruments which I noted in the finale of HWV430 is true throughout, with Rowland recorded closer and at a higher volume than Cummings. The closeness of the Divine Art recording is likely to become more tiring than the Somm, though I think you’re hardly likely to want to play both CDs in one go.

The Somm notes are brief but generally to the point, though nowhere will you find reference to that well-known nickname for the finale of HWV430. No booklet is offered with either set from either of the download sites.

From Somm, two CDs, each playing for less than an hour, are poor value by today’s standards, when Hyperion offer several extra works on Paul Nicholson’s recording. Divine Art also give you more music for your money and spread their net more widely than just the works of Set 1. I’d love to leave it at that and sit on the fence, but I know that you want me to plump, so, for overall satisfaction with tempo and performance, availability of booklet for download, and with both lossless sound and mp3 at a very reasonable price, it has to be Paul Nicholson on Hyperion.

Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750)
Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring (from Cantata No.147)
Myra Hess (piano) – rec. 1940. ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 4BX175 [3:08] – from Beulah (mp3)

A brief and enjoyable reminder of those recitals which Myra Hess gave at the National Gallery as her contribution to morale and the war effort, from an HMV recording which originally coupled a Scarlatti Sonata. A contemporary review uses just about every glowing epithet that its writer could think of, concluding ‘No lovelier, more entirely satisfactory record has come my way for many a long day. Everyone must get it.’ Now Beulah offer it for a fraction of the equivalent of the original price on 78. I’d expected Hess to lay on the emotion rather too thickly, but she lets the music speak for itself. For once, I’m not going to disparage the concert grand in Bach – the music wasn’t written for the keyboard, so a harpsichord or fortepiano would be no more authentic – and the recording is good enough not to hinder the modern listener’s enjoyment.

Johannes-passion (St John Passion), BWV 245
Markus Schäfer (tenor) – Evangelist; Thomas Oliemans (baritone) – Jesus
Carolyn Sampson (soprano); Michael Chance (alto); Marcel Beekman (tenor); Peter Kooij (bass)
Cappella Amsterdam
Orchestra of the Eighteenth Century/Frans Brüggen – rec. live, March/April 2010. DDD.
GLOSSA GCD92113 [2CDs 72:50 + 38:25] – from (mp3 and lossless) or (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library.

I’m listening to this recording and writing this review of the latest recording of my favourite of the Bach passions on Good Friday, so I’m afraid that you’ll be reading about it rather late for this year, but you may wish to store it in your wish-list for next year.

A rather subdued opening Herr, unser Herrscher did not bode well, but I soon began to warm to this performance. It’s less intense than John Eliot Gardiner’s recording on a similar scale, but the Johannes-passion lends itself well to more meditative treatment. Vocally the only small fly in the ointment is the singing of Michael Chance – not a voice for which I have much affection, but you may well think otherwise. Check it out via the Naxos Music Library if you can. Alternatively, Passionato have the Gardiner version at a discount for £6.49 at the time of writing – here.

I didn’t have time to request a review download, so I listened via the Naxos Music Library. The sound is adequate but the 320kb/s download from classicsonline will undoubtedly be better – and the lossless version from eclassical, at just $13.95, better still. There are no texts, but these are readily available online.

Easter Oratorio, BWV249 [41:18]
Ascension Oratorio (Cantata No.11), BWV11 [29:05]
Carolyn Sampson (soprano); Iestyn Davies (counter-tenor); James Gilchrist (tenor); Peter Harvey (bass); Retrospect Ensemble/ Matthew Halls
rec. 22- 25 February 2010, St Jude’s Church, London, UK. DDD
pitch: A = 415 Hz
Texts and translations included
LINN RECORDS CKD373 [70:26] – from (SACD, mp3, lossless and 24-bit downloads)

This, too, has just missed the Easter boat. Unfortunately, my reviewer’s code for Linn was refreshed on the very day that I’d just closed the April/2 Roundup, but it should still be Eastertide when you read this review, with the second half of the recording in time for Ascension. The Ascension Oratorio is actually a Cantata (No.11), but it’s no less a miniature masterpiece for all that. Both works have been recorded many times, often coupled as here: the new recording joins the best of them.

Matthew Halls has produced some wonderful recordings for Hyperion and Linn with performers from the former King’s Consort, so I had high expectations of this recording, especially when I saw the very impressive line-up of soloists. At first I was a little disappointed by the opening Sinfonia of the Easter Oratorio and the joyous Kommt eilet und laufet – just a little lacking in exuberance and perhaps a shade slow, I thought, but the surprise is that in both sections Halls is actually marginally faster than Paul McCreesh (DG) and Andrew Parrott (Virgin). On my second hearing, everything fell into place: this is a performance that grows on you.

I’m not going to dispose of Parrott’s version of the Easter Oratorio on a Virgin twofer (5616472), coupled with a version of the Ascension Oratorio just as fine as on the new Linn recording, plus the Magnificat and Cantatas 4 and 50 – it’s not just a superb bargain at less than £8, the performances and recording hold up well. Don’t download it, however – you may well end by paying more than the very inexpensive CDs.

You’re unlikely to regret buying the Linn in one form or another – and those who must have SACD or a 24-bit download, or must have the texts and translations, will find that there’s no contest: for them the Linn recording is a must.

Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)
Piano Concerto No.20 in d minor, K466 (Cadenzas by Beethoven)
Annie Fischer (piano); Philharmonia Orchestra/Sir Adrian Boult – rec.1960. ADD/stereo.
BEULAH EXTRA 1-3BX130 [31:16] – from Beulah (mp3)

Violin Concerto No.3 in G, K216 (Cadenzas by David Oistrakh)
David Oistrakh (violin); Philharmonia Orchestra – rec.1958. ADD/stereo.
BEULAH EXTRA 5-8BX71 [23:46] – from Beulah (mp3)

Symphony No.29 in A, K201
Sinfonia of London/Sir Colin Davis – rec.1958. ADD/stereo
BEULAH EXTRA 1-4BX129 [23:36] – from Beulah (mp3)

Symphony No.39 in E-flat, K543
Sinfonia of London/Sir Colin Davis – rec.1958. ADD/stereo
BEULAH EXTRA 5-8BX129 [28:47] – from Beulah (mp3)

Ideally, there should always be some Bach and some Mozart in this Roundup and I must thank Beulah for providing it – evidently May is Mozart month this year with four classic recordings restored.

The virtues of Annie Fischer’s Mozart remain undiminished by the passage of years – indeed, I think what was described in 1960 as a somewhat masculine style is closer to what we expect now, and it’s offset by some really delicate playing in the slow movement. With well judged accompaniment from Boult and the Phiharmonia – I hardly noticed the off-tune woodwind in the first movement – the recording still sounds well. It captures the divided strings which Boult rightly insisted on and all that’s missing is the art-work which Columbia used to lavish on their recordings.

The Oistrakh recording appeared in harness with Prokofiev. His Mozart is still as much a delight as it was then; it’s no longer yoked to an unlikely fellow and the recording still sounds fresh. The soloist acting as conductor is no longer such a novelty, but I don’t remember anyone doing the double act better. Oistrakh opened my ears to the magic of the Beethoven Violin Concerto at the Festival Hall in the early 1960s and he’s equally persuasive with Mozart. Two feathers in Beulah’s cap, then. Can the other two recordings match?

The two symphony recordings come from early in Colin Davis’s career when EMI were still not prepared to let him loose on the market at full price. His now vintage Beethoven Seventh Symphony appeared on the lower-price HMV Concert Classics label and his Mozart on World Record Club. These two symphonies came out together and Symphony No.34 with Leon Goossens in the Oboe Concerto. I wore out my copy of the latter, until Classics for Pleasure came to my rescue and reissued it.

The view at the time, however, was that his version of No.29 was too sluggish and that of No.39 not much faster. Certainly he seemed to have rethought it by the time he recorded it again with the LSO four years later, with No.40 on Philips. This was an LP which remained a staple of my library for many years. No.29 opens rather slowly, though the delicacy of the playing from the Sinfonia of London and Davis’s pointing of the music compensate, apart from some rather off-form wind playing in the third movement. Karl Böhm, recorded ten years later with the Berlin Philharmonic for DG, is slightly slower than Davis: that was about the going rate then.

Davis’s Mozart is certainly not the only show in town but his recordings of it with the Sinfonia of London, later the LSO and later still the Dresden Staatskapelle rank among the best. Even now the recording sounds well, nicely capturing the lightweight performance of No.29 and the rather heavier one of No.39.

Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
Symphony No.3 in E-flat, Op.55
London Philharmonic Orchestra/Sir Adrian Boult – rec.1957. ADD/stereo
BEULAH EXTRA 26-29BX12 [46:57] – from Beulah (mp3)

Beulah have already given us Kleiber’s recording of the Eroica (5-8BX6 – see February 2011 Roundup). Boult’s reading is rather less individual – good middle of the road, lighter than Kleiber – but the recording requires a great deal of tolerance even though Beulah have tidied up the reverberation which was originally a problem, at the expense of making the sound rather dry now. I prefer the Kleiber, but the recording there, too, is mono only and far from ripe.

Gioachino ROSSINI (1792-1868) La Gazza Ladra Overture
Concertgebouw Orchestra Amsterdam/Eduard van Beinum – rec.1952. ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 7BX37 [9:49] – from Beulah (mp3)

I’m slightly confused here. The track information says ‘The Art of van Beinum #1’ and there is, indeed, a Beulah album with that name, the first track of which is a Rossini Overture – but it’s La Scala di Seta, not La Gazza Ladra. Puzzles apart, this is an enjoyable performance and the recording is reasonably good for its early-LP date, if a little more muffled than you might expect; indeed, when it first appeared on LXT2733, this was the one overture to be excepted from the adjective ‘brilliant’. For all my reservations about the sound, I hope that Beulah will give us the rest of that LP – and, perhaps, Pierino Gamba’s slightly later Decca recordings of this repertoire.

Joseph LANNER (1801-1843) Pesther Waltz, Op.93
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra/Hans Pfitzner – rec. 1932 ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 1BX126 [6:34] – from Beulah (mp3)

Many of Lanner’s waltzes are of such high quality that it’s easy to see why he was such a rival for the Strauss family. I don’t think I’d heard this one before – presumably written for the Hungarian city of Pesth before its union with Buda across the river. It’s no rival to the hegemony of the Strausses, but it’s pleasant music, idiomatically performed. The recording is a trifle thin, but good for its age – more than acceptable – and well worth the modest price.

Robert SCHUMANN (1810-1856) The Classical Guide to Schumann
Includes complete performances of:
Piano Concerto in a minor, Op.54* [29:34]
Symphony No.1 (‘Spring’)** [31:38]
Kinderscenen*** [20:27]
Abegg Variations^ [7:13]
Symphony No.4 in d minor, Op.120 (movements iii and iv)**** [15:15]
Waldscenen (substantial extracts)*** [9:10]
Liederkreis (substantial extracts)^^ [13:34]
Dichterliebe (substantial extracts)^^^ [6:09]
and other shorter extracts
Martha Argerich*; Maria-João Pires***; Michel D’Alberto^ (piano); Chamber Orchestra of Europe/Nikolaus Harnoncourt*/****; Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra/Kurt Masur**; Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau^^
WARNER CLASSICS AND JAZZ [152:33] – from iTunes (mp3)
Also available on a budget-price 2-CD set, The Schumann Experience, 2564684921

After a very shaky start, with some dodgy orchestral playing in the opening bars – or is it the recording, or the CD burner built into Warner’s MPE player? – the Piano Concerto turns into a decent performance; though not one of Martha Argerich’s greatest, it makes a fine opening for this super-budget price set. The rest of the programme, too, is well worth considering for those exploring Schumann for the first time. With complete performances of the wonderfully buoyant ‘Spring’ Symphony – a bracing performance, but hardly effacing memories of Sawallisch (EMI) or the 10" Decca LP with Josef Krips from which I learned to love this work – plus Kinderscenen and substantial extracts from Waldscenen, Liederkreis and Dichterliebe, the programme is less bitty than on many of these Warner Classics introductory sets. Apart from that opening, the recording is good.

Richard WAGNER (1813-1883) Albumblatt in E (Lied ohne Worte)
Robert Zailer (violin); Berlin State Opera Orchestra/Clemens Schmalstich – rec. 1930. ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 1BX127 [4:13] – from Beulah (mp3)

Unusual Wagner – not what you’d expect at all. The recording is rather thin and tonally insecure but this is currently one of only two ways to obtain this arrangement of a pleasant little work originally for the piano. The other is on a CD of recordings by David Oistrakh – with the Beethoven Triple Concerto and the Brahms Double Concerto (Monopole MONO16). If you want the Wagner on its own, here it is for a very modest sum. The piano original seems not to be available.

Antonín DVOŘÁK (1841-1904) Symphony No.8 in G, Op.88
National Symphony Orchestra/Basil Cameron – rec. 1946 ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 3-6BX27 [36:03] – from Beulah (mp3)
[Listen to excerpts from this performance on YouTube – here]

Many years ago, when I was an undergraduate, a friend bought the George Szell Ace of Clubs recording of the Eighth Symphony – still then known as No.8 (4) – and we listened together to that and the Ninth, the New World Symphony (Karel Ančerl on Supraphon). We agreed that the New World totally eclipsed its predecessor, but over the years I’ve come to regard the Eighth as almost its equal, largely because of a number of excellent recordings, none more convincing than Rafaël Kubelík, now at mid price on DG The Originals 447 4122 or Iván Fischer on Channel Classics CCSSA90110, both coupling Nos. 8 and 9, so you can make the comparison for yourself. See my review of the passionato download of the latter in its earlier incarnation on the Philips label in the July 2010 Download Roundup.

This 1945 recording is no match for Kubelík or Fischer sonically – there’s even a touch of surface noise, unusual for Beulah – though the ear soon adjusts to the lack of the higher frequencies. The performance, which opens very winsomely, is one of the best, Kubelík and Fischer included: if my friend and I had been comparing this Cameron version with the New World back then, I don’t think that we’d have dismissed it so lightly.

Emmanuel CHABRIER (1841-1894)

España, Rhapsody for orchestra (1883) [6:30]
Joaquín TURINA (1882-1949)
Danzas Fantásticas, Op. 22 (1920) [15:13]
Joaquin RODRIGO (1901-1999)
Concierto de Aranjuez for guitar and orchestra (1939)* [23:37]
Maurice RAVEL (1875-1937)
Alborada del gracioso (1905/1918) [7:49]
Manuel DE FALLA (1876-1946)
Three dances from the ballet El sombrero de tres picos [12:00] (1919)
Arturo MÁRQUEZ (b. 1950)
Danzón No. 2 (1994) [9:43]
*Marlon Titre (guitar)
Anhaltische Philharmonie Dessau/Antony Hermus
rec. 1-2 July 2010, Anhaltisches Theater, Dessau. DDD
ACOUSENCE 21610 [75:00] from (mp3, 16-bit/44.1kHz flac/wma, 24-bit/96kHz flac/wma, 24-bit/192kHz flac)

This is a double first for me: a download from Linn’s online catalogue and a 24-bit/192kHz Studio Master, too. Thus far I’ve auditioned some of Chandos’ 24/96 downloads and found them very good indeed, although they don’t all justify the hefty premium over the equivalent CD. Linn’s pricing is broadly in line with the existing business model, with prices ranging from £8 for 320kbps mp3s to £20 for 24/192 Studio Masters. Individual tracks are available and artwork/liner-notes are downloadable from what is a fairly user-friendly site. Linn offer their own recordings for download, as well as those of other labels such as Channel Classics and Acousence. I’ve certainly admired Channel’s fine SACDs, one of which was among my picks for 2010, but Acousence is new to me.

Also unfamiliar are the Anhaltische Philharmonie Dessau and their Dutch conductor Antony Hermus, heard here in a selection of Spanish/South American music. This is natural territory for Ernest Ansermet and the Suisse Romande orchestra, whose indispensable performance of the Chabrier is reissued as part of a 2-CD set from Decca Eloquence (review). This has a freshness and spontaneity that’s hard to beat; not only that, the sound is exceptionally full and vivid, proof, if it were needed, that vintage recordings can challenge the best on offer today.

With Ansermet’s España still fresh in my mind, I was keen to hear how this Dessau account – and the sonics – would compare. Not very well, is the short answer. True, the dynamic range of this Acousence release is almost uncomfortably wide, and will surely appeal to those looking for an out-and-out hi-fi experience. That said, while the playing is suitably febrile, it lacks the last ounce of rhythmic flair, that essential elasticity, that Ansermet brings to the piece. It’s not always easy to judge these things, but I’d say the Dessau acoustic is somewhat lively and a tad excitable, so the tuttis aren’t as tidy as they might be. The bass drum and brass playing are fabulous, though.

The three Danzas Fantásticas are well played, but again rhythms aren’t as supple as I’d like. Even so, instrumental detail is quite remarkable, helped no doubt by the close, high-level recording; indeed, I had to lower the volume considerably before I felt comfortable, especially in the orgiastic third dance. Definitely one to loosen the roof tiles and/or alarm the neighbours.

The Concierto de Aranjuez is also recorded up-close-and-personal, which means the soloist sounds far too prominent. The jumbo-sized guitar aside, the orchestral playing just isn’t very idiomatic; Titre’s performance doesn’t strike me as particularly distinguished either, although there’s some lovely playing in the Adagio. The abiding impression, though, is that despite the promise of a more realistic listening experience – the USP of high-cost, high-res releases – this recording sounds strangely contrived and synthetic. That’s certainly true of Alborada del gracioso; although the performance is superficially exciting. Bass-drum junkies won’t be disappointed; it just isn’t very believable.

Goodness, what a disappointment this is turning out to be. Regrettably, the dances from El sombrero de tres picos aren’t very inspired either; oh, how one longs for the flamboyance of Ansermet in these pieces. In mitigation, the final dance (Jota) has formidable range and bite. After that orchestral machismo the gentle, almost feminine, start to Arturo Márquez’s Danzón No. 2 comes as a welcome relief; it’s short-lived though, with a return to that thumping bass. Incidentally, if you want to hear a thoroughly idiomatic version of this, try Gustavo Dudamel and his young Venezuelans (review). It may not have the hi-fi credentials of this Acousence release, but as a performance it’s infinitely more satisfying.

Listening fatigue is always a risk with high-octane collections such as this, and I have to say it sets in rather early here. There are far, far better performances of these works elsewhere – no doubt many are available in downloadable form – so I’d spend that twenty quid elsewhere. And despite any allusions – intended or otherwise – to Mercury’s famous ‘Living Presence’ or RCA’s ‘Living Stereo’ releases, this ‘Living Concert’ fails to deliver. As for the download process, it’s a doddle, although these large files take a while to transfer, even with a reasonably fast broadband connection.

Dan Morgan

Vincent d’INDY (1851-1931) Orchestral Works Vol. 4
Poème des rivages – Suite symphonique en quatre tableaux (ed. Cyril Bongers) (1919-1921) [39:37]
I. Calme et lumière. Agay (Méditerranée) [11:32]
II. La joie du bleu profond. Miramar de Mallorca (Méditerranée) [5:33]
III. Horizons verts. Falconara (Adriatique) [8:22]
IV. Le mystère de l’Océan. La Grande Côte (Golfe de Gascogne) [13:53]
Symphonie italienne (1870-1872) [37:01]
Iceland Symphony Orchestra/Rumon Gamba
rec. 27-30 September 2010, Háskólabió, Iceland. DDD
CHANDOS CHAN10660 [76:53] from (mp3, lossless and Studio 24bit/96kHz) or stream from Naxos Music Library

I much enjoyed the fourth volume of Gamba’s d’Indy cycle on CD – review – and as I had the Studio 24bit/96kHz download to hand I was keen to see how they compared. There was no doubt when I did something similar with the Noseda/BBC Philharmonic recording of Casella’s Second Symphony; the high-res download made an already fine performance seem even more vital and involving (review). That said, buyers will need to decide for themselves whether any such improvement justifies the hefty premium Chandos charge for these files.

The d’Indy series is beautifully played and recorded, the shifting colours and supple rhythms of these painterly pieces well caught by the Chandos team. The atmospheric start to the first part of Poème des rivages, with its falling string figures, is a case in point, the music emerging as if from a morning mist. The playing of the Iceland orchestra is as refined and nuanced as one could wish, and the grateful acoustic certainly helps. Switching to the download – piped through the same Xonar Essence sound-card – reveals a touch more air around the notes, the overall sound much more keenly focused. Perversely, that’s not necessarily an improvement in a score that majors in soft edges; and, if anything, the added clarity makes the tuttis seem a little fierce.

So, not a chalk-and-cheese situation at all, although the pointillist elements of La joie du bleu profond and the dynamic swings of Horizons verts do benefit from the more upfront presentation of the download. Generally, though, there’s not that much of a difference, although the bass drum and cymbals in Horizons verts do sound more visceral in the download; that said, many listeners might well prefer the softer, more seductive sound of the disc.

It’s only in the deep-tugging riptide of Le mystère de l’Océan – with its Stygian bass and blazing brass – that one really begins to appreciate the added weight, range and thrust of these high-res files. There’s some gorgeous, almost holographic woodwind playing too, the opening of d’Indy’s youthful Symphonie italienne simply startling in its presence and power. And that holds for the rest of this work, whose blend of extrovert gestures and intimate interludes has seldom sounded so beguiling.

On its own terms this download is very impressive indeed; but, as I’ve suggested, choosing between this and the CD isn’t as straightforward as you might think. Either way these are fabulous performances, fully deserving of a place on your shelf or hard drive.

Dan Morgan

[There’s not much to add, except that the ‘ordinary’ lossless version sounds well, too, though the opening of Poème des Rivages is so soft as to be barely audible, even with the volume turned up – not one to listen to in the car, I fear. BW.]

Sir Edward ELGAR (1857-1934)
Falstaff, Symphonc Study, Op.68
London Philharmonic Orchestra/Sir Adrian Boult – rec. 1956. ADD/stereo
BEULAH EXTRA 25BX12 [33:43] – from Beulah (mp3)

With Elgar’s own historical version* and Sir Andrew Davis’s highly-praised digital recording on a super-budget Warner Apex CD – see review – it might seem that this particular musical larder is fully stocked. But there’s always room for Boult’s interpretation, characterised at the time of its first release on a 10" Nixa mono LP as riper, more genial and expressive than its Decca rival from Anthony Collins. I concur with all those adjectives – I’d even say that they applied to this version even more than to Davis – and the recording still sounds well, though it’s no match for the Warner version in that respect. Like the original LP, the transfer benefits from a boost in volume.

As a welcome pendant to their recent reissue of Campoli’s recording of Elgar’s Violin Concerto, Beulah have now added his 1931 version of La Capricieuse, Op.17, with Harold Pedlar at the piano (10BX10 [3:21]).

* Amazon offer this as a download for a mere £0.79 – here – and subscribers to eMusic can obtain it for £0.42 or less – here – but I can’t vouch for the quality.

Frederick DELIUS (1862-1934) On hearing the first Cuckoo in Spring* [6:53]
Léo DELIBES (1836-1891) Le Roi s’amuse – ballet music* [14:07]
Jules MASSENET (1842-1912) La Vierge: The last Sleep of the Virgin** [5:10]
Hector BERLIOZ (1803-1869) Les Troyens – Overture*** [5:38]
Royal Philharmonic Orchestra/Sir Thomas Beecham – rec 1956 ADD/stereo*; 1953 ADD/mono**; 1954 ADD/mono***
BEULAH EXTRA 1BX43, 2BX43, 3BX43, 4BX43 [timings as listed above] – from Beulah (mp3)

If I wanted to choose four pieces by which to represent Beecham at his best, my choice would have included at least three of these. The First Cuckoo comes from his classic stereo Delius recordings, recently reissued on a super-budget 6-CD set (EMI 9099152, with music by Bax, Berners, Bantock and German) – see review. The only problem with this inexpensive Beulah download is that it will almost inevitably make you want to buy that set – it’s a real bargain at around £17.50, less than £3 per CD – or download the earlier Beecham/Delius Great Recordings of the Century album from

Similarly, the ballet music from le Roi s’amuse – another Beecham speciality – may tempt you to purchase the whole album from which it comes, on CD or from passionato. Both these recordings are in good stereo, though the Delibes sounds a little subfusc by comparison with my CD copy.

The Massenet Last Sleep is the Beecham ‘lollipop’ par excellence; though others have performed it, they have never achieved quite the success of Beecham, who neither underplays nor over-emphasises the pathos. The mono sound is more than acceptable.

After these essentials, the Berlioz is a welcome extra.

Frederick DELIUS (1862-1934)

On hearing the first Cuckoo in Spring
London Symphony Orchestra/Geoffrey Toye – rec.1928. ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 1BX128 [6:16] – from Beulah (mp3)

A Village Romeo and Juliet: The Walk to the Paradise Garden
London Symphony Orchestra/Geoffrey Toye – rec.1930. ADD/mono
BEULAH EXTRA 2BX128 [8:12] – from Beulah (mp3)

The Dutton CD transfer of these and other ‘classic’ Toye recordings of Delius is no longer available, so these Beulah releases are timely. Delius is reported to have admired Toye’s recordings of his music, though he’s better known today as the composer of the ballet The Haunted Ballroom.

Beulah have already given us Beecham’s Cuckoo (above) – the version par excellence, though Vernon Handley (Classics for Pleasure) and Sir Andrew Davis (Warner Apex) run him close. These performances by Toye are nothing like as special, nor is the recording in the same league though it’s very good for its age and Beulah have done a really fine job of keeping the surface noise down while maintaining the quality of the sound.

Olivier MESSIAEN (1908-1992)
Turangalîla-symphonie (1946, rev. 1990)
Howard Shelley (piano)
Valérie Hartmann-Claverie (ondes-martenot)
BBC Philharmonic Orchestra/Yan Pascal Tortelier
rec. 8-9 January 1998, New Broadcasting House, Manchester, UK. DDD
CHANDOS CHAN 9678 [75:12] from (mp3 and lossless)

We all have at least one – a recording we ‘imprinted’ upon and which, to us at least, can never be bettered. André Previn’s classic Turangalîla is mine. I wore out the LPs, never tiring of those exotic harmonies and hypnotic rhythms. EMI’s 1977 recording is pretty spectacular too, Messiaen’s sister-in-law Jeanne Loriod splendid on the all-important ondes. I’ve heard a number of performances since then, live and on record, although I seem to have missed the Tortelier CD along the way; at least this lossless download is a good opportunity to rectify that oversight.

Tortelier’s Turangalîla gets off to an arresting start, brass and percussion well caught, the piano very much to the fore. It’s a purposeful, less flowing performance than Previn’s, but what it lacks in momentum and cumulative power it makes up for in detail. It’s more spikily ‘modern’ in its presentation, especially at the start of Chant d'amour I. Here, Loriod’s ondes is the more voluptuous, Previn’s sense of cosmic rapture replaced by Tortelier’s almost forensic desire to unearth all the nuances of this extraordinary score.

Make no mistake, this is a gripping performance, and the BBC Philharmonic play very well indeed. In Turangalîla I, the contrast between contemplation and ecstasy is starker than ever, the clarinet solos in both versions winningly played; as for Chant d’amour II, there’s also a Ravelian glitter to the music that one doesn’t hear with Previn. That may have something to do with the more forward placing of the piano, Howard Shelley eliciting a tingle or two with his ethereal playing at the close of this movement. That said, Previn triumphs in those mystic plosions, the LSO percussion – cymbals in particular – superbly rendered. Honours are more evenly divided in Joie du sang des étoiles; if anything, Tortelier’s sense of urgency and his painterly attention to each daub of colour is even more persuasive than Previn’s broad-brush approach at this point.

The profoundly beautiful music of Jardin du sommeil d’amour is one of the high points of Previn’s recording, and while Tortelier isn’t as radiant there’s a heady scent in this darkened garden that’s just intoxicating. Not only that, the sense of a deep communion, of a shared epiphany, is remarkable. In Turangalîla II, the piano part and chamber-like cello passages remind one of just how natural the Chandos recording is in terms of sound and balance. Ditto Tortelier’s percussion in Développement de l’amour which, although not quite as showy as Previn’s, has a subtle but no less powerful presence. It’s only in those orchestral supernovae – Previn is peerless here – that Tortelier’s leaner, more controlled reading is found ever so slightly wanting.

The reach-out-and-touch-it tangibility of this Chandos recording is most impressive, notably in the quieter moments of Turangalîla III, where Messiaen’s score has a multi-faceted sparkle that I’ve not heard before. Predictably, Previn’s Finale has all the grande joie one could hope for, but then Tortelier’s brighter, more analytical reading is every bit as overwhelming. There can be few more spectacular consummations in all music, and both conductors do Messiaen proud.

Perfect? No, not quite, but if you want a revealing, top-notch Turangalîla to add to your collection of downloads then this must be the one. Those who don’t already own the Previn – either on CD or as a pricey DVD-A/DVD-V – should seek it out; in a discography stuffed with bona-fide classics this is simply indispensable. Tortelier’s Turangalîla is very different – perhaps complementary is a better description – and I’m delighted to have heard it at last. As usual, the Chandos download process was straightforward; sound and supporting paperwork are up to the standards of the house as well.

Go for it.

Dan Morgan

[It’s getting to be a habit, but, having listened to this recording, I agree with Dan’s review without wanting to add much. I’ve been trying without success to learn Sanskrit, but I do know that lîla means ‘play’, ‘sport’, ‘amusement’ or ‘pastime’ and that’s an element which I’m pleased to find in good measure in this performance, albeit that I shan’t be getting rid of my recording by Riccardo Chailly (Decca 436 6262 – download from in mp3, reduced to £3.99 at the time of writing). Passionato also have the Previn version to which Dan refers, but it’s one of those ridiculous cases where the lossless download costs more than twice as much as the CD set (EMI Century Classics 2068672 or Gemini 5865152, both at around £8). BW]

Astor PIAZZOLLA (1921-1992) Tango Distinto
Michelangelo 70 [2:54]
Histoire du Tango: II. Café, 1930 [7:02]; III. Nightclub, 1960 [6:02]
Soledad [8:44]
Le Grand Tango [1:28]
Oblivion [3:52]
Escualo [3:57]
Serie del Angel (arr. Gabriel SENANES)
I. La muerte del angel [3:57]
II. Milonga del angel [7:10]
III. Resurreccion del angel [6:54]
Tanti anni prima, ’Ave Maria’ [4:35]
Achille Liarmakopoulos (trombone); Hector del Curto (bandoneón); Octavio Brunetti (piano); Pedro Giraudo (double-bass); Simon Powis (guitar); Ian Rosenbaum (marimba); Robert Thompson (piano); Edson Scheid, Jiyun Han (violin); Raul Garcia (viola); Arnold Choi (cello); Maura Venti (harp)
NAXOS 8.572596 [66:35] – download only, from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

Piazzolla’s music appears in a variety of arrangements, but this is claimed as the first recording with a trombone as the constant element. I don’t recall having encountered the young Greek trombonist Achille Liarmakopoulos before, but he’s a fine exponent of the music, in combination with a variety of other instruments. You probably already know if you like Piazzolla’s music – and it’s very hard to dislike. If you don’t, this is as good a way as any to get to know it, perhaps alongside the Naxos recording of the Sinfonía Buenos Aires and Estaciones Porteñas which I reviewed in the February 2011 Roundup (8.572271).

Because this is, for the moment at least, download only, there is no booklet, but you’ll find a tab which leads you to ‘about the music’.

(b. 1945)
Gloria (1974) [17:21]
Magnificat (1990) [39:15]
Te Deum (1988) [7:54]
Elizabeth Cragg (soprano)
Tom Winpenny (organ)
The Choirs of St Albans Cathedral
Ensemble DeChorum/Andrew Lucas
rec. Cathedral and Abbey Church of St Alban, St Albans, Hertfordshire, UK, 13-14 July, 2010 (Magnificat) and 16-17 July, 2010 (Gloria and Te Deum). DDD
Texts included
NAXOS 8.572653 [64:40] – from (mp3) or stream from Naxos Music Library

Not surprisingly – and most certainly not without merit – Naxos and Classicsonline are making a feature of this recording. I know that there are some church-music traditionalists who dislike Rutter’s music, but I’m not among them. Certainly he gives a lift to the music, but his settings are in a direct line of descent from those of his predecessors in a way that ad hoc guitar strumming at Mass can never be. A cathedral or collegiate choir like that of St Alban’s who perform here could use these three settings at the principal Sunday services alongside plainsong or renaissance polyphony for the other items without a sense of dichotomy. Yes, some part of the Gloria are (gloriously) brash but there are some really wonderful quiet and contemplative moments, too, especially in the Magnificat.

There are several fine recordings in the catalogue, not least that of Gloria, Te Deum and shorter works on Hyperion CDA67259. Classicsonline already offer Rutter’s own recording of the Gloria on his own Collegium label (COLCD100 or CSCD515) but the new recording, alert to all aspects of Rutter’s music, can look these predecessors in the eye. Strongly recommended: any recording that could keep me listening intently while the neighbours noisily power-hosed their patio for most of its duration must be beyond praise.

Witchcraft: music by Cy Coleman, Joseph Allen McCarthy, Carolyn Leigh, Michael Mike Stewart, Dorothy Fields, Peggy Lee, James Lipton and David Joel Zippel
I’m Gonna Laugh You Right out of My Life [4.01]
The Best is Yet to Come [2.54]
The Rules of the Road [1.57]
On Second Thought [3.16]
Ev’rybody Today is Turning On [2.43]
Sometime When You’re Lonely [2.49]
Let Me Down Easy [3.48]
Nobody Does It Like Me [3.27]
That’s My Style [4.18]
When in Rome (I Do as the Romans) [2.47]
Witchcraft [2.21]
With Every Breath I Take [2.50]
On the Other Side of the Tracks [2.23]
Would You Believe [3.17]
Claire Martin (vocals); Richard Rodney Bennett (vocal and piano) – rec. December 2009. DDD.
LINN RECORDS AKD359 [42:51] – from (SACD, mp3, lossless and 24-bit)

I can’t pretend to be clued up about jazz, but I do know what I like and I specially like to listen to it late at night. I know only a small repertoire – my equivalent of the ‘little bit of ivory’ to which Jane Austen limited the world of her novels – with the likes of Dave Brubeck and Stéphane Grappelli at its heart. It needs to be expanded – after all, Jane Austen bores me to tears precisely because her world is so limited – and this is just the sort of album to do it.

The collaboration between Claire Martin and Richard Rodney Bennett works superbly; though there’s no question who provides the greater vocals, Bennett’s accompaniment underpins the whole project superbly. Very good recording and a decent booklet of notes set the seal on a recording to which I shall be returning regularly. The only reservation that I need express concerns the short playing-time.



Making a Donation to MusicWeb

Writing CD reviews for MWI

About MWI
Who we are, where we have come from and how we do it.

Site Map

How to find a review

How to find articles on MusicWeb
Listed in date order

Review Indexes
   By Label
      Select a label and all reviews are listed in Catalogue order
   By Masterwork
            Links from composer names (eg Sibelius) are to resource pages with links to the review indexes for the individual works as well as other resources.

Themed Review pages

Jazz reviews


      Composer surveys
      Unique to MusicWeb -
a comprehensive listing of all LP and CD recordings of given works
Prepared by Michael Herman

The Collector’s Guide to Gramophone Company Record Labels 1898 - 1925
Howard Friedman

Book Reviews

Complete Books
We have a number of out of print complete books on-line

With Composers, Conductors, Singers, Instumentalists and others
Includes those on the Seen and Heard site


Nostalgia CD reviews

Records Of The Year
Each reviewer is given the opportunity to select the best of the releases

Monthly Best Buys
Recordings of the Month and Bargains of the Month

Arthur Butterworth Writes

An occasional column

Phil Scowcroft's Garlands
British Light Music articles

Classical blogs
A listing of Classical Music Blogs external to MusicWeb International

Reviewers Logs
What they have been listening to for pleasure



Bulletin Board

Give your opinions or seek answers

Past and present

Helpers invited!

How Did I Miss That?

Currently suspended but there are a lot there with sound clips

Composer Resources

British Composers

British Light Music Composers

Other composers

Film Music (Archive)
Film Music on the Web (Closed in December 2006)

Programme Notes
For concert organizers

External sites
British Music Society
The BBC Proms
Orchestra Sites
Recording Companies & Retailers
Online Music
Agents & Marketing
Other links
Web News sites etc

A pot-pourri of articles

MW Listening Room
MW Office

Advice to Windows Vista users  
Site History  
What they say about us
What we say about us!
Where to get help on the Internet
CD orders By Special Request
Graphics archive
Currency Converter
Web Ring
Translation Service

Rules for potential reviewers :-)
Do Not Go Here!
April Fools

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.