Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
ings CD 1 Ann SOUTHAM (b 1937)
Glass Houses (1981) [8:44] Gavin BRYARS (b 1943)
After Handel’s “Vesper” (1995) [13:15] Olivier MESSIAEN (1908–1992)
Première communion de la Vierge (Vingt regards sur l'enfant-Jésus,
no.11) (1944) [7:29] Pierre BOULEZ (b 1925)
Première Sonate (1946) [10:27] David JAEGER (b 1947)
Quivi Sospiri (1979) [10:15] Alexina LOUIE (b 1949)
Star Filled Night (1987) [7:02] Tōru TAKEMITSU (1930–1996)
Les yeux clos (1990) [4:42] Lowell LIEBERMANN (b 1961)
Apparitions, op.17 (1985) [11:48] CD 2 Henry COWELL (1897–1961)
Six Ings (c 1922) [8:41] David del TREDICI (b 1937)
Fantasy Pieces (1960) [8:52] Frederic RZEWSKI (b 1938)
Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues (North American Ballads,
no.4) (1978/1979) [9:02] Masamitsu TAKAHASHI
Capriccio for piano [6:05] Bill WESTCOTT
Suite (2004) [16:10] Art TATUM (1909–1956)
I’ll Never be the Same [1:36]
Don’t Get Around Much Anymore [1:18] Omar DANIEL (b 1960)
Surfacing (1991) [10:46]
Christina
Petrowska Quilico (piano)
rec. Glenn Gould Studio, CBC Toronto; Merkin Hall, New
York; live, 18 January 2007, Tribute Communities Recital
Hall, York University, Toronto (Takahashi and Westcott
only) DDD WELSPRINGE
PRODUCTIONS WEL0008 [73:04 + 62:33]
Ottawa–born Christina Petrowska Quilico, she’s
the widow of Metropolitan Opera baritone, Louis Quilico,
studied
with Boris Berlin at the Royal Conservatory of Music,
Toronto, making her orchestral debut aged 10. At the
Juilliard School she studied with Rosina Lhévinne, Jeaneane
Dowis and Irwin Freundlich, where she acquired her formidable
technique. At 14, as a co-winner with Murray Perahia
of the High School of the Performing Arts Concerto Competition,
she made her New York concert debut at Town Hall. Thereafter
she studied at the Sorbonne, and in Darmstadt and Berlin
with Karlheinz Stockhausen and György Ligeti. She has
toured extensively through North America, Europe, The
Middle East and Asia and recorded some 20 CDs of classical,
romantic, new and world music.
This
wide ranging recital includes five works by Canadian
composers as well as a representative selection of fairly
recent music from Europe and Japan. Starting with a pleasantly
minimal piece by Ann Southam, Glass Houses is
the kind of easy–going, dare I say laid–back, piece we
used to hear so often twenty years ago, before most of
those, better known, composers went on to bigger, but
not necessarily better things. It’s a lovely start to
a challenging recital.
Gavin
Bryars’s work was written for harpsichord, and it received
its première by Maggie Cole on that instrument, and its
strong chordal writing works well for the piano for the
long held sounds resonate in a way that is impossible
on the earlier instrument. However, the harpsichord is
the perfect instrument for this piece for it is precisely
the elements which make it easier on the piano which
make it more interesting on the harpsichord. It’s a bit
too “perfect” here, no sounds of the action clattering,
the sonorities are richer and fuller, and it’s very comfortable.
It’s like sitting in a comfy arm–chair as opposed to
on an hard backed chair. After Handel’s “Vesper” is
a fine piece and it’s good to have a recording of it
in any form.
Première communion de la Vierge appears
at the mid–point of Messiaen’s vast piano cycle Vingt
regards sur l'enfant-Jésus. Written in the midst
of the German occupation of France, it is a tribute to
the tenacity of the composer that he managed not just
to write the piece but that he could compose over 2 and
an half hours of music for his home, in the north–east
of Paris, was surrounded by constant outbreaks of fighting!
This Virgin's First Communion
shows the Virgin kneeling, worshipping the unborn Jesus
within her. Despite a couple of outbursts this is a delicate
meditation and Petrowska Quilico displays a restrained and calm poise throughout.
The natural force which is Pierre Boulez hit the
music scene with this Première
Sonate, his second work, after the original version
of Notations. This is a cogently argued and dramatically
demanding work which is ultimately a strong example of
music coming from a generation stifled by the war. Thank
goodness we can hear the work again and again for it
deserves repeated hearings and it does repay the time
spent studying it.
David Jaeger is probably best known as the producer of CBC Radio 2’s
lamented, and now shut down, Two New Hours – a weekly
showcase for contemporary music. In 1971 he co-founded
the Canadian Electronic Ensemble and has remained an
active member of the group. Quivi Sospiri, which
apart from the piano, has significant parts for synthesizers,
represents part of the third Canto from Dante’s Inferno,
where, according to the composer, “there is total darkness…Dante
describes the sounds he hears.” This is a very dark,
brooding, nocturne, where nothing is quite what it seems
to be, musically, and the electronics slide through and
round the piano. It’s a fascinating and fabulous nocturne
of murky intensity.
Alexina Louie is one of Canada’s best kept secrets, as far as we,
in this country, are concerned. She is a prodigious composer
who has worked in all media and created a solid and varied
catalogue. The beautiful and ethereal Star Filled
Night was written for this pianist and she plays
it with such authority, obviously relishing the many
colours and moods within the light, fantastic, work.
In a foreword to a book of Takemitsu’s writings, conductor Seiji Ozawa
wrote, "I am very proud of my friend Tōru Takemitsu.
He is the first Japanese composer to write for a world
audience and achieve international recognition." For
many in the west, Takemitsu is modern Japanese classical music and his reputation
is well established. His death,
in 1996, from pneumonia whilst undergoing treatment for
cancer of the bladder was a loss of huge proportions.
He called himself an adagio composer, feeling that he
could best convey his ideas in slow, quiet and thoughtful
music whether on a large scale, such as Orion and
Pleiades and How slow the Wind or in miniatures
like the exquisite Les yeux clos recorded here.
Ten years later he wrote Les yeux clos II and
it is regrettable that this could not have been included
on this disk.
Lowell Liebermann is a prolific composer who made his concert debut
at Carnegie Hall, playing his Piano Sonata, op.1,
when only 16 years of age. In
an interview with newscaster Sam Donaldson, Van Cliburn
described Liebermann as “a wonderful pianist and a fabulous
composer.” Apparitions is an early work comprising
four pieces which are elusive, mysterious and quicksilver
in inspiration. It’s a fine little suite and brings the
first disk to a dreamy close.
Writing about Henry Cowell, in the early 1950s, Virgil Thomson said, “…Cowell's
music covers a wider range in both expression and technique
than that of any other living composer…No other composer
of our time has produced a body of works so radical and
so normal, so penetrating and so comprehensive. Add to
this massive production his long and influential career
as a pedagogue, and Henry Cowell's achievement becomes
impressive indeed. There is no other quite like it. To
be both fecund and right is given to few.” John Cage
called Cowell, "the open sesame for new music in
America." The Six Ings (Floating, Frisking etc)
is an early work, and as it pre–dates Aeolian Harp there’s
no playing on the strings of the instrument. Instead
here are six strong miniatures, full of humour, pathos
and dark shadows.
Del Tredici’s Fantasy Pieces is a student work. Like many young
composers of this time he took to dodecaphonic composition
before discovering tonality once more. These four pieces
show the influence of Schoenberg, being spikey, angular
and dissonant. They are also very approachable and enjoyable.
Many of Rzewski's works display a deep political conscience and the North
American Ballads are all based on traditional American
work and protest songs. The composer has written that
the pieces “…represent…the things I believe in.” The
last of the set, Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues,
has won popularity for itself and it’s easy to see,
and hear, why. It’s a relentless toccata, with the
slow blues in the middle, which evokes the sound of
machines and the de–humanizing effect of the monotonous
nature of the work. It’s based on an anonymous 1930s
blues from North Carolina. What starts as a truly barn–storming
performance seems to loose its way after the middle
section and never really re–creates the excitement
of the opening until the very end.
Masamitsu Takahashi’s Capriccio for piano is an unashamed blues, while Bill Westcott’s Suite is a jazz–infused
composition, but this is serious jazz, not one of those
awful pieces knocked up by composers who should know
better. A fine piece and a very pleasant surprise in
the midst of all the earnestness. The two Art Tatum pieces
are well enough known, I think, to avoid any description.
Suffice it to say they follow the Jazz Suite very
nicely.
Omar Daniel’s Surfacing returns to the minimalist idea of building
music through cumulative repetition and the four sections
seem to embrace a manic blues, a disjointed toccata and
night music. Indeed, it seems to be a summation of everything
which we’ve heard on these two disks.
This is one of the most fascinating selections of music I’ve ever
come across. As a concert of fairly contemporary music,
to be listened to in one sitting, it could hardly be
bettered for the programme, the order of the pieces,
with the lighter pieces at the end, make for a most satisfying
whole. I imagine that all the tracks were recorded live
because just occasionally you can hear the odd noise
from an audience, but in general it is very quiet and
attentive throughout.
I am always hoping that contemporary music can reach a wider audience
and with issues such as this, where the music is strong
but attractive and easily approachable, I hope that a
few more converts will scale the heights of modernism
and accept the composers of our time as well worth the
time we give to them. There’s something here for everybody
so no–one who buys these well produced disks will be
disappointed.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.