One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews

FOGHORN Classics

Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews

All HDTT reviews

Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World

all Nimbus reviews

all tudor reviews

Follow us on Twitter

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Chandos recordings
All Chandos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews

all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All APR reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews


Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount



Tavener We shall see him as he is CHAN 241-42
Frank Bridge Orchestral works CHAN 10729(6) X - review
RVW Cotswold Romance CHAN 10728 X - review
Howells Hymnus Paradisi CHAN 10727 X - review review
Elgar The Light of Life CHAN 10726 X – not previously reviewed here
Dyson The Canterbury Pilgrims CHAN 241-43 – not previously reviewed here
Holst Wandering Scholar CHAN 10725 X - review
Holst The Cloud Messenger CHAN 241-6 – review
Full contents and artist listings at end of review

[Image supplied by Chandos © Gregg Barrett]

Experience Classicsonline

Richard Hickox was lost to us at the early age of sixty (obituary). After launching as a choral conductor with EMI (some fine Delius and Rubbra), Decca (also Delius) and RCA (Rubbra masses) in the mid/late 1970s he worked with Chandos for many years. It was that label that remained his recording alma mater. He made numerous recordings with them - many but not all of them of English music. There was Prokofiev’s War and Peace, some opulent Menotti (review) and plenty of early music.
If not incomparable, Hickox’s musical range of coverage and empathy was and remains breathtaking. His Chandos legacy vies with those who died at a much later age with a longer recording career including Boult, Thomson and Handley. He had his blind spots – who does not? There was no Foulds or Bantock from him and the Bax symphonies appear to have been a closed book. Mind you, listening again to one of his broadcasts of Bax’s Overture to a Picaresque Comedy his heart was clearly not in the Baxian idiom. These composers were in any event well catered for by others. His coverage was stupendous and Chandos have it all. On song, which he was with so many composers including Bridge, Elgar, RVW, Howells, Holst and Dyson, his recordings live and breathe the freshness of personal discovery. I hope that most of his sessions will appear in this typically handsomely done Chandos series.
All the CDs in the Legacy series are to a standard livery. This sets the original sleeve in the milieu of the Legacy medallion and a sombre ground. The Dyson is the exception though the medallion is still there.
Let’s now turn to these discs:-
This was the first in the Hickox Legacy series from Chandos and was an outlier issued in splendid isolation in May 2012.
Here we find three works of spiritual moment and numinous atmosphere – qualities that are a given with Tavener.
There are thirteen sections making up We Shall See Him As He Is. The work was commissioned in 1990 by the now-dismembered Cheshire County Council for the 900th anniversary of Chester Cathedral. Reverential mystery is the key with oriental ornamentation much in play in the voices. The music is unhurried, slow and avidly devotional. Ikons III and IX defy this sweeping generalisation with dervish wildness and Hovhaness-style heavenly dancing. In Ikon X a majestic stance is struck by the brass while the choir are borne aloft as if on some great upward-combing wave. There’s an ululating muezzin tone to the solo and choral singing; it feels North African - Berber even. The cello assumes a cantorial role and this can be sampled in Ikon X. The text was compiled by Tavener's spiritual mentor, Mother Thekla of the Orthodox Monastery, Normanby, North Yorkshire. The piece ends with those whisper-sweeping violin figures reminiscent of Hovhaness's writing in Fra Angelico.
Eis Thanaton (Ode to Death) opens in a growlingly minatory mood. This work was borne out of the death of Tavener's mother. His musical voice was stilled by bereavement for two months when he read the eponymous poem by Andreas Kalvos musical ideas began to float free. North African melisma is again engaged across a three movement trajectory that spans some 39 minutes. The journey is from darkness to life. Cathedral spaces are evoked and blended with the sort of vocalise one finds in RVW's Sinfonia Antartica. A more vigorous and grimly joyous atmosphere settles over the last movement with the growlingly passionate voice of Stephen Richardson memorably grainy and grippingly Old Testament.
Theophany is for pre-recorded tape and orchestra. It's in two meaty segments. The music hums and rumbles with deeply intoned bass voices. The effect is rather like a sort of exoticised Tallis Fantasia combined with the lowest plumbing depths of Rachmaninov's Vespers. Various instruments are added to the standard orchestral forces: apart from the bass voice and Chinese wind-gong there’s the pre-recorded tape continuously playing, alto flute and Bandor drum. This was written for the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra's centenary.

These two discs - here complete with words printed in the booklet - were first issued separately in the first half of the 1990s. They complement a more recent Chandos disc, again Hickox conducting, of Tavener's Fall and Resurrection on CHAN 9800.
  BRIDGE boxed set
The six Frank Bridge discs appeared one at a time in an unhurried way. We can now encounter all six in this single superbly finished box: the single Bridge collection.
It includes an elementally remorseless Enter Spring confident, transparent and wondrously recorded. The luxuriant Jefferies Poems are superb and terribly undervalued. The early Mid of the Night is an extended tone-poem in the same Tchaikovskian mould as Bridge’s Isabella. The Dance Rhapsody is an eruptive and dionysiac extravaganza while the Dance Poem stands closer to the chill of There is a Willow though broadly contemporaneous with the idyllic Summer. The Sea, a work that, with Enter Spring, bowled over the young Britten, is lucidly textured yet avoids the wash and swell of impressionism. Bridge paints in broad swathes of melody. This is a remarkably fine performance.
We also hear the snappy pomp of the Coronation March alongside the George Butterworth and Ravel of Summer. Then come the first stirrings of Continental accents in There is a Willow until we move onwards into the masterly ambivalence and mildewed expressionist complexity of Phantasm.
From his uncompromising older age comes Oration: Alban Gerhardt’s cello basks in a recording perspective that is spectacular, probably the best it has ever had. The solo is given a microphone eminence which is extremely commanding, exciting, flamboyant and gratingly moving. That epilogue is deeply affecting, tender through the soloist's voice, yet bleakly haunted like the second movement of Havergal Brian's Gothic. The 1940-41 Allegro moderato for string orchestra is all that remains of a projected symphony for strings. It is classically clean and very romantic when you compare it with the bustle and elfin dissonance of Rebus. The 1915 Lament is warm but there are harmonic eddies and depths that look forward by at least a decade. A Prayer, to words by Thomas à Kempis takes us down a road Bridge did not go down again except, to some extent, in the opera A Christmas Rose (on Pearl). It is Bridge's only work for chorus and orchestra and is an invocation to peace. Rebus: Apart from some inimical shadows and an occasionally ruthless tread this is a bustling, determined and romantic little concert overture with Elgarian and even Waltonian moments.
The Suite for Strings is an early work and very much of the same stamp as Sir Roger de Coverley. Wit, excitement and beguiling enchantment are all there. How did Bridge remain so many years in the outer darkness? From 1902, The Hag is a macabre nightmare - a howling gale, reeking of brimstone. The two songs of Robert Bridges were recorded first by Pearl in their occasional SHE series. This is luxuriant writing with a Delian temperament. The orchestra returns for the Delian Two Intermezzi from Threads. The Valse Intermezzo is an early piece. It is smoothly contoured: sweet and light. To end Hickox unleashes the wit and rapier flicker of Sir Roger.
We also hear premiere recordings of nine songs for solo voice with orchestra. Five are for tenor (Langridge) and four for mezzo (Connolly). These are superbly orchestrated – bejewelled in their detailing. They stand little chance of any concert life - at least not in this format; this despite often having a big Mahlerian heart and a gentle gift. Berceuse is a heart-open genre piece. The Pageant of London is for wind band: not of his best: something of a pot-boiler.
The exemplary Bridge notes are by Paul Hindmarsh.
Links to reviews of original releases:
Link to Bridge biography:
A Cotswold Romance
A Cotswold Romance (first reviewed here in 1999) gives some of the finest music in RVW's opera Hugh The Drover an opportunity to thrive as a concert work. Its constituency remains that of the choral society. It runs to about the length of a symphony. It was a clever move for composer Maurice Jacobson - how long before we have a recording of his grievously missed Hound of Heaven - to collaborate with composer. A parallel can be found in the work the composer put into In Windsor Forest which served the same purpose for the opera Sir John in Love (EMI). These secular cantatas fit rather well with the much larger Dyson Canterbury Pilgrims, RVW's own Five Tudor Portraits and Hadley's The Hills. As a group they form a counterpart to RVW's religiously-inclined works such as Benedicite, Dona Nobis Pacem and Hodie.
The Romance is in ten separately tracked segments starting with The Men of Cotsall which, with its market cries, pre-echoes Pilgrim's Vanity Fair. The ardent song by Hugh is nicely taken by Thomas Randle with passionate, almost Delian, interplay with the choir in Hugh's Song of the Road. A Stanfordian stamp can be discerned here - echoes of the Songs of the Sea and also of the vigorous songs from RVW’s own Stevenson Songs of Travel. After a vigorous boxing bout song, continued in track 7, comes a romantic strain in Alone and friendless. This was a mood and idiom further developed in total mastery in the green leaf ardour of Sir John in Love. Much the same applies to Mary's solo in Mary's escape on tr. 9. I might fault Randle for sounding the same in lovelorn mood and in misery in Hugh in the stocks but it’s a small quibble. Randle and Mannion duet in Freedom at Last where - with the chorus - happy endings are swooningly celebrated. This is indeed an easily digestible epitome of the full opera. You can hear the whole thing on EMI Classics and on Hyperion. The composer revised Hugh from the original of 1910-14 in 1933 and 1956 but the full work lacks the grip of Sir John not to mention the epic span of Pilgrim's Progress. It even struggles beside the much derided but deeply entertaining Poisoned Kiss (another Chandos Hickox set) – a sort of echo of Holst's own irresistible parody opera The Perfect Fool and a tradition which continues to this day in Sondheim's Into the Woods.
The seven orchestral movements of RVW's incidental music to Maeterlinck's play The Death of Tintagiles date from 1914. Some of these are fey little vignettes, well worth hearing and often coloured with melancholic pallor. They are totally characteristic of the composer. Listen to the solo viola on tr. 13 and the Norfolk morning mists of tr. 14. By contrast there’s a ruthless anxiety about the music on tr. 16.
The words are printed in full and the notes by Stephen Connock of the RVW Society are solidly informative.

HOLST Wandering Scholar
This disc always had a shortish playing time but compensation comes in the shape of a clever mix of rare Holst. What we get is a snappy light orchestral suite in four movements, a scena for violin and orchestra and a single act opera forming a medieval counterbalance to the Spartan Indian opera Savitri.
The Suite is a deft example of its type: good but not fully characteristic Holst. It is jolly, suave in the second movement, peacefully smiling in the third. There Bradley Creswick's seamlessly engaging violin solo is not a big step away from the Dvorákian contentment of Coleridge Taylor's violin concerto as stunningly recorded by Lorraine McAslan on Lyrita. The finale wakes up the sleeper with some muscular yet light-footed writing for the brass benches. If it is more German and Ketèlbey than the Holst we know it remains a delightful discovery. There's even an oompah-galumphing dash of Mahler at one point.
Lesley Hatfield takes on A Song of the Night and makes of it a thing of moody passion which the good notes by Lewis Foreman link with Holst's interest in matters Sanskrit. It's a lush piece and comfortably shares the same genre as single movement efforts of this ilk by Dvorák, Saint-Saens and Tchaikovsky. It also makes, presumably unknowing, common cause with another delight I have discovered recently - the Rozycki Violin Concerto (on Acte Préalable). Holst’s sumptuous and chocolate-romantic music in this case is strong on such qualities rather than on drama.
Then comes a violent change of gear with the compact little opera The Wandering Scholar to words by Clifford Bax. The milieu and words can be grouped with those of Howells' Kent Yeoman's Wooing Song and RVW's Hugh the Drover. This opera is wonderfully characterised and given its best chance to shine. Its scale makes it a good match with that other little charmer, Barber's metropolitan A Hand of Bridge - though the latter is more knowing and psychologically piquant as well as more dated. There’s a faintly salacious story in which honest Louis, the farmer, whose ‘loose i’ the hilts’ wife is almost seduced by the roving priest Philippe - playing out the lubricious capers of Falstaff in Sir John In Love - whose predatory charms are frustrated by the wandering scholar, Pierre. The words are in English only. There are nine tracks so it’s easy to get around. We have a really fine performance of a work that is witty-folksy and full of intricate and intriguing instrumental detail. It’s very well done. Roll on a full recording of Sita and The Perfect Fool. All the words are there in the insert and there are lots of them for a piece running 25 minutes.
HOWELLS Hymnus Paradisi
The Howells disc complements the label's extravagant two disc foray into Howells for soloists, choir and orchestra with Rozhdestvensky: Stabat Mater and the explosively voluptuous Missa Sabrinensis. There's a two CD set of those two works which complements this Hickox event very well indeed. Hickox takes things more philosophically than both the classic Willcocks (EMI) and Handley (Hyperion) in Hymnus. Chandos have a way with big choral works as is evident from their Dyson Quo Vadis but also with their magnificent Schmidt Book of the Seven Seals. This reputational glow stands out in the final section of Hymnus: Holy is the True Light. The building of range and tension is felt in all its mastery in the pizzicato ground bass at 3:24 of that track. The climactic surge, when it comes, is irresistible yet sober in grandeur at 4:43. Hickox remains in emotional control even at 5:28 in tr. 6 when one gets an echo of A Mass of Life's O du meine wille.
Hymnus Paradisi is at the heart of the English choral tradition and, more to the point, much loved. It inhabits realms of exultation and exaltation. It concentrates elements from the first section of the Delius Mass of Life and slightly further afield voices from Hilding Rosenberg's Symphony No. 4 Johannes Uppenbarelse with its rapturously pealing 'alleluias' forming their own echo of Howells' Glory is the True Light.
After Hymnus we get A Kent Yeoman’s Wooing Song. This is a secular cantata which was written in the 1930s but not premiered until 1953. It is, in effect, an operatic scena rife with vigour. The latter quality rattles through the second movement: I Have a House and Land in Kent - words also set in a song by Arnold Bax. It continues with final segment I cannot come every day to woo. The more poetic third section is sombrely ardent. There’s a Delian sigh about this but this is diluted in the byplay between Ian Opie and the choir. The whole work is very attractive and full of the sort of invigorating life that holds tweeness at bay.
A bluff and bucolic voice irradiates A Kent Yeoman's Wooing Song. Here the exemplars are Vaughan Williams's Tunning of Elinor Rumming and My Pretty Bess (Five Tudor Portraits) and the merry episodes from Sir John in Love as well as the Wedding Scene from Patrick Hadley's The Hills. The Willcocks Hymnus on EMI Classics (CDM 5 67119 2) is strongly paired with Boult's thunderously declamatory 1974 recording of the Concerto for String Orchestra. The Kent Yeomans's Wooing Song shows a fascinatingly extrovert facet to Howells' genius.
All the words are printed alongside notes by Andrew Green.
ELGAR Light of Life
Light of Life dates from early in Elgar's career and was written in parallel with the secular cantata King Olaf. The opening Meditation - which has been recorded as a freestanding orchestral piece - is very good indeed. The story treated is of Christ healing the blind man. There’s a nice tension between Christ as Light of the World and the light He brought to the blind man's eyes. Strength and majesty is unmistakable in Light of world we know thy Praise. That said there are also very effective passages touched with the static and the meditative, the reflective and the pensive. John Shirley-Quirk is in truly fine voice. There’s succulent work for the woodwind throughout. This is a strong and very satisfying work lovingly realised by Hickox, his strong solo team and excellent choir.
The notes are by Michael Kennedy - one cannot choose fairer than that. The words are there in full in the booklet.
DYSON Canterbury Pilgrims
Pilgrims runs to a freestanding concert prelude At the Tabard Inn. There is then a Prologue and 12 character-pieces, one for each tale.
This two CD set, when first issued in the 1990s, was the answer to many entreaties over a very long period. Choral societies across England had never completely abandoned this vivid sequence of character tableaux. I recall it being on the radio in the early 1970s and still have the broadcast by Donald Hunt, the BBCNSO and Halifax Choral Society on a cassette - remember those? The whole piece runs to 90 minutes plus the concert overture opener which times out at about 12 minutes.
Hickox excelled in grand choral Britishry and Canterbury Pilgrims is a good example of this capacious genre. He brings out the romantic very strongly - more so than Hunt all those years ago - and the recording quality remains among Chandos's ne plus ultra products. The lush element can be heard in the overture - almost filmic. Hickox and Dyson are superbly served by an elite orchestra – the LSO and its choir. The soloists are classic voices and only Robert Tear seems less than opulent. Never mind, he is a practised hand and does not short-change the listener in terms of character rather than caricature. While Chaucerian ribaldry has been pretty much drained off so as not to scare the lieges there is still ruddily boisterous writing aplenty.
The choral Prologue (tr. 3) is lambent and the writing is peaceable, possessing the ground between Delius and RVW. The Knight is heart-surging stuff and while Dyson had little time for Elgar this music has some Froissart-like vigour: virile and rough-hewn. The Squire is splendidly youthful and Tear is good at forthright enunciation though nasal. The Nun takes us back to the peaceful medieval tone of the choral Prologue. The Monk is almost bellicose and by no stretch of the imagination ethereal. This is a man of the cloth but it’s coarse and manly stuff. The music is struck through with gusty rain-swept brashness. The Clerk of Oxenford is a dull or at least reserved dog - a relaxing contrast after the burly Monk. Part 1 ends with The Haberdasher and his fraternity. The Merchant is diverting and imposing but one senses little affection. There's some commanding brass writing in subtle tones rather than brazen expostulations. Some of it sounds rather like Janácek.
The second part, like the first, runs to about 45 minutes. In The Sergeant of the Law, The Franklin Stephen Roberts catches the momentous and even self-important tone, hammered home by roiling drums. The Shipman is rough and buffeted by rampant gales. There’s a touch of RVW in the nicely rounded writing for the strings. The Doctor of Physic starts with a figure reminiscent of the start of RVW's Sea Symphony. Then comes delicate, precise and imposing music with even a hint of Schoenbergian Viennese discord. The Wife of Bath blows aside all fears and cobwebs. This is a merry wife with breezy frivolity. Yvonne Kenny is fully up to the demands of the writing and of the character to which she imparts confidence and humanity. The Poor Parson of the Town is a gentle piece - kindly even - with some lovely translucent writing. No wonder this piece was and is so loved. We end with L'Envoi with its clarion trumpets and panache. The pilgrims now move off on their pilgrimage. In a strange parallel with a certain Russian piece, Dyson conjures the passing cavalcade as it processes towards Canterbury. The choral writing here is full of resource and ear-engaging poetic effect. Some of it sounds positively Delian. There’s a wonderfully contrived fade-out as the pilgrim train disappears from view and earshot.
In Honour of the City sets words by William Dunbar for choir and orchestra. It has been rather eclipsed by Walton's own brilliant setting. This is Dyson’s first choral work and is solidly written: sturdy and optimistic. There are some early echoes of The Canterbury Pilgrims; London links these pieces. It runs to a very compact 15 minutes and deploys Orange and lemons in the brass in Flower of cities. Walton owes the title of his 1937 march to one of the stanzas set by Dyson. Dyson does not hoover up all the potential for setting - Walton had more to say about Dunbar's words. Much of the Dyson is peaceable, companionable and exudes pride and joy in strength and magnificence. The metal clash and bell-clangour suggest a dashing London overlaid with chivalric celebration.
The two pieces here were completed within two years of each other. In Honour of the City came first. Each has a feeling of community music-making without capitulation to the lowest common denominator.
Ray Siese and Lewis Foreman provide the supportive and pleasurable notes so we can understand how the music fits in. The sung words are legibly reproduced in full in the typically gratifying booklet.
This first salvo in the Hickox Legacy has been cannily chosen by the Chandos team.
HOLST Cloud Messenger
This Cloud Messenger duo of reissues has been in circulation since MusicWeb International first sprang into existence. Dr Len Mullenger reviewed it in the early days. I felt it was time to look at it again given the Hickox Legacy launch though it forms no part of that series. The major Holst works here are conducted by Hickox with City of London Sinfonia and London Symphony Orchestra forces.
The Cloud Messenger is one of Holst's Indian or Sanskrit works. Its language strikes some parallels with a work from about a decade earlier: Bantock’s Omar Khayyam. The Cloud Messenger was written just before The Planets. It seems to have been benighted by an imperfect premiere in one of Balfour Gardiner's concerts at the Queen’s Hall. Holst was desperately discouraged - he had conducted that premiere and the work soon sank away becoming one of the composer's early horrors which he virulently disavowed. Imogen Holst's critical condemnation set the seal until a BBC performance in the 1960s by Peter Gellhorn and then this recording in 1990.
In The Cloud Messenger a poet persuades a cloud to carry his love message to his distant beloved in the Himalayas. En route the cloud passes over the Ganges temple of Shiva, the god of dance. It’s not a conventionally dramatic or incident-rich tale.
The work’s lambent writing occasionally suggests a slow-blooming ecstasy (tr. 2 6:16) but there’s opulence as well. This presumably lies closer to the reported luxuriance of the opera Sita. It’s certainly a world away from the minimalist beauties of the Rig Veda choral hymns and the chamber opera Savitri. Tr. 4 introduces us to a typical stolid yet satisfying trumpet-delineated march of the type to appear in Ode to a Grecian Urn in the Choral Symphony and in the Whitman-based Dirge for Two Veterans. The first incidence of overt orientalism appears in tr. 4 (2:12) with its glinting peaceable orchestration. The piece ends in a Neptune-like glimmer, some suave writing for the bass and pleasingly tense shimmering violins. The Hymn of Jesus is accorded a stunning recording catching wild and loud abandon as well as the recessed whispers. Paul Spicer treats us to the lovely and moving (in both senses) Ave Maria and finishes CD 1 with the chaste The Evening Watch.
CD 2 start with the sweet ardour of the Seven Part Songs for choir with orchestra H162 from the Joyful Company of Singers conducted by Hickox. The feathery dancing of Sorrow and Joy strikes an idiosyncratic mood. Patricia Rozario is the successor to Janet Baker in her classic EMI recording of A Choral Fantasia. This is a strange gaunt piece, heavy with minatory brass and otherwise fading quickly to awe and a sense of impending cataclysm. There’s something Havergal Brian Gothic about it. A Dirge For Two Veterans picks up again on one of Holst's idées fixes: Walt Whitman. Here the CLS solo trumpet is excellent – slow-calling, yet precise and honeyed in texture. There is nothing of Froissart and bristling lances here, just a stolid funeral plod – veterans, son and father, fallen together. Five years later, separated by the four years of the Great War, Holst turned to Whitman again and specifically to Leaves of Grass for The Ode to Death. This work's resonances are obvious enough - the slaughter of the Great War. It’s a succinct, plangent and soothingly moving work and must be counted high in the Holst oeuvre. How delightful was Holst’s gift in setting female voices in large numbers. This can be placed alongside the excellence of the Groves version of the Ode on EMI Classics. The music ends in mystical tinkling and twangling: bells and starlight. The delectably sung This I have done for my true love and the four part-songs (1894-6) are among his earliest works – smooth, capable and ingratiating. They make a conventionally pleasing envoi to this fine CD double.
The excellent notes for this full value set are by the late Christopher Palmer, by Lewis Foreman and Philip Reed. They are in English only but unusually for Chandos the sung words are not printed. You can however inspect them online and download them in pdf format if you go to the Chandos site and search under the original release numbers:-
The Cloud Messenger is also to be had separately at full price with The Hymn of Jesus as CHAN 8901.
If this collection appeals then discard any passing reservations. You will be pleased.


Rob Barnett

  Detailed Track-Listings
Frank BRIDGE (1879-1941)
CD 1
Enter Spring, H 174 (1926-27) [18:36]
Isabella, H 78 (1907) [18:00]
Two Poems for Orchestra, H 118 (1915) [12:58]
Mid of the Night, H 30 (1903) [26:05]
CD 2
Dance Rhapsody, H 84 (1908) [19:16]
Five Entr'actes, H 95 (1910) [12:05]
Dance Poem, H 111 (1913) [13:48]
Norse Legend, H 60 (1905/1938) [4:48]
The Sea, H 100 (1910-11) [22:08]
CD 3
Coronation March, H 97 (1911) [6:49]
Summer, H 116 (1914-15) [10:42]
Phantasm, H 182 (1931) [24:21]
There Is a Willow Grows aslant a Brook, H 173 (1927) [11:19]
Vignettes de danse, H 166 (1938) [11:21]
Sir Roger de Coverley (A Christmas Dance), H 155 (1922) [4:41]
Howard Shelley (piano)
CD 4
Rebus, H 191 (1940) [10:44]
Oration (Concerto elegiaco), H 180 (1929-30) [29:17]
Allegro moderato, H 192 (1940-41) [13:24]
Lament, H 117 (1915) [5:19]
A Prayer, H 140 (1916-18) [17:55]
Alban Gerhardt (cello)
CD 5
Suite for Strings, H 93 (1909-10) [21:03]
The Hag, H 14 (1902) [2:25]
Two Songs of Robert Bridges, H 65 (1905-06) [6:32]
Two Intermezzi from 'Threads', H 151 (1921-1938) [8:33]
Two Old English Songs, H 119 (1916) [7:30]
Two Entr'actes (1906, 1926) [6:38]
Valse Intermezzo a cordes, H 17 (1902) [6:49]
Todessehnsucht, H 181 (1932/1936) [3:53]
Sir Roger de Coverley (A Christmas Dance), H 155 (1922/1939) [4:24]
Roderick Williams (baritone)
CD 6
Blow out, you bugles, H 132 (1918) [5:37]
Adoration, H 57 (1905/1918) [2:55]
Where she lies asleep, H 113 (1914) [3:01]
Love went a-riding, H 114 (1914) [1:40]
Thy hand in mine, H 124 (1917/1923) [2:10]
Berceuse, H 9 (1901) [5:06]
Mantle of blue, H 131 (1918/1934) [2:47]
Day after day, H 164i (1922) [4:55]
Speak to me, my love!, H 164ii (1924) [5:56]
Berceuse, H 8 (1901/1902/1928) [3:23]
Chant d'esperance, H 18ii (1902) [3:40]
Serenade, H 23 (1903) [2:51]
The Pageant of London, H 98 (1911) [15:08]
A Royal Night of Variety, H 184 (1934) [1:27]
Philip Langridge (tenor)
Sarah Connolly (mezzo)
BBC National Orchestra of Wales/Richard Hickox
rec. Brangwyn Hall, Swansea. 26-27 November 2000 (Vol. 1, Vol. 3 [Sir Roger de Coverley]), 19-20 September 2001 (Vol. 2), 28-29 November 2002 (Vol. 3 [other works]), 13-14 May 2003 (Vol. 4), 3-4 December 2003 (Vol. 5), 23-24 October 2004 Vol. 6)
Ralph VAUGHAN WILLIAMS (1872-1958)
A Cotswold Romance - adapted by Maurice Jacobson in collaboration with the composer, from Hugh the Drover [39:34]
Rosa Mannion (soprano) - Mary
Thomas Randle (tenor) - Hugh
Matthew Brook (baritone)
London Philharmonic Choir
Death of Tintagiles [14:48]
London Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
rec. All Saints Church, Tooting, London, 3-4 October 1997
CHANDOS CHAN 10728 X [54:34]
Herbert HOWELLS (1892-1983)
Hymnus Paradisi [46:42]
Joan Rodgers (soprano)
Anthony Rolfe Johnson (tenor)
A Kent Yeoman's Wooing Song† [18:21]
Joan Rodgers (soprano)
Alan Opie (baritone)
premiere recording
BBC Symphony Chorus
BBC Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
rec. All Saints Church, Tooting, London, 2-4, 7 November 1998
CHANDOS CHAN 10727 X [65:12]
Gustav HOLST (1874-1934)
Suite de ballet, Op. 10 [19:24]
A Song of the Night, Op. 19 No. 1 [8:31]
Lesley Hatfield (violin)
The Wandering Scholar, Op. 50 [25:24]
Ingrid Attrot (soprano) - Alison
Neill Archer (tenor) - Pierre
Alan Opie (baritone) - Louis
Donald Maxwell (bass) - Father Philippe
Northern Sinfonia/Richard Hickox
rec. St Nicolas Hospital, Gosforth 15-16 May 1996
CHANDOS CHAN 10725 X [53:40]
  Edward ELGAR (1857-1934)
The Light of Life, Op 29 [62:48]
Judith Howarth (soprano) (The Mother of the Blind Man)
Linda Finnie (contralto) (Narrator)
Arthur Davies (tenor) (The Blind Man)
John Shirley-Quirk (baritone) (Jesus)
London Symphony Chorus
London Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
rec. All Saints Church, Tooting, London, 1-3 February 1993
CHANDOS CHAN 10726 X [62:48]
George DYSON (1883-1964)
CD 1
Overture: At the Tabard Inn [11:41]
The Canterbury Pilgrims [90:55] (cont)
CD 2
In Honour of The City of London [15:08]
Yvonne Kenny (soprano)
Robert Tear (tenor)
Stephen Roberts (bass)
London Symphony Chorus
London Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
rec. Blackheath Halls, London 30 September and 1, 4-5 October 1996
CHANDOS CHAN 241-43 [57:25 + 60:42]
John TAVENER (b. 1944)
CD 1
We Shall See Him As He Is - Ikon of the Beloved (1990) [61:08]
John Senter (cello)
Patricia Rozario (soprano)
John Mark Ainsley (tenor)
Andrew Murgatroyd (tenor)
BBC Welsh Chorus
Britten Singers
Chester Festival Chorus
BBC Welsh Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
CD 2
Eis Thanaton - a Ritual - Sung in Greek (1986) [37:50]
Patricia Rozario (soprano)
Stephen Richardson (bass)
City of London Sinfonia/Richard Hickox
Theophany for pre-recorded tape and orchestra (1992-93) 29:03
Jeremy Birchall all male voices, including 'Adam' solo
Margaret Feaviour 'Eve' solo
Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
rec. Royal Albert Hall, London, 23 July 1992 (We Shall See Him As He Is); Blackheath Concert Halls, London, 4 February 1994 (Eis Thanaton); Wessex Hall, Poole Arts Centre, 5 May 1994 (Theophany)
CHANDOS CHAN 241-42 [61:08 + 67:06]
Gustav HOLST (1874-1934)
CD 1
The Cloud Messenger, H111* [43:11]
The Hymn of Jesus, H140 [22:24]
Della Jones (mezzo)*
London Symphony Chorus
London Symphony Orchestra/Richard Hickox
Ave Maria, H49 [3:48]
The Evening-watch, H159 [4:37]
Susanna Spicer (alto solo) - Mark Milhofer (tenor solo)
Finzi Singers/Paul Spicer
CD 2
Seven Part-songs, H162* [23:05]
A Choral Fantasia, H177* [16:42]
A Dirge for Two Veterans, H121 [6:31]
Ode to Death, H144 [12:27]
Patricia Rozario (soprano)*
Joyful Company of Singers
London Symphony Chorus
City of London Sinfonia/Richard Hickox
This have I done for my true love, H128 [5:48]
Rachel Wheatley (soprano solo)
Four Part-songs [7:36]
Finzi Singers/Paul Spicer
rec. St Jude on the Hill, Hampstead, London; 4-5, 9 June 1990 (The Cloud Messenger; The Hymn of Jesus); St Silas The Martyr, Kentish Town, London 25-26 March 1993 (Ave Maria, The Evening-watch, This I have done for my true love; Four Part-songs); All Saints Church, Tooting, London 3, 5 September 1994 (other works)
CHANDOS CHAN 241-6 [74:22 + 72:44]


































































Making a Donation to MusicWeb

Writing CD reviews for MWI

About MWI
Who we are, where we have come from and how we do it.

Site Map

How to find a review

How to find articles on MusicWeb
Listed in date order

Review Indexes
   By Label
      Select a label and all reviews are listed in Catalogue order
   By Masterwork
            Links from composer names (eg Sibelius) are to resource pages with links to the review indexes for the individual works as well as other resources.

Themed Review pages

Jazz reviews


      Composer surveys
      Unique to MusicWeb -
a comprehensive listing of all LP and CD recordings of given works
Prepared by Michael Herman

The Collector’s Guide to Gramophone Company Record Labels 1898 - 1925
Howard Friedman

Book Reviews

Complete Books
We have a number of out of print complete books on-line

With Composers, Conductors, Singers, Instumentalists and others
Includes those on the Seen and Heard site


Nostalgia CD reviews

Records Of The Year
Each reviewer is given the opportunity to select the best of the releases

Monthly Best Buys
Recordings of the Month and Bargains of the Month

Arthur Butterworth Writes

An occasional column

Phil Scowcroft's Garlands
British Light Music articles

Classical blogs
A listing of Classical Music Blogs external to MusicWeb International

Reviewers Logs
What they have been listening to for pleasure



Bulletin Board

Give your opinions or seek answers

Pat and present

Helpers invited!

How Did I Miss That?

Currently suspended but there are a lot there with sound clips

Composer Resources

British Composers

British Light Music Composers

Other composers

Film Music (Archive)
Film Music on the Web (Closed in December 2006)

Programme Notes
For concert organizers

External sites
British Music Society
The BBC Proms
Orchestra Sites
Recording Companies & Retailers
Online Music
Agents & Marketing
Other links
Web News sites etc

A pot-pourri of articles

MW Listening Room
MW Office

Advice to Windows Vista users  
Site History  
What they say about us
What we say about us!
Where to get help on the Internet
CD orders By Special Request
Graphics archive
Currency Converter
Web Ring
Translation Service

Rules for potential reviewers :-)
Do Not Go Here!
April Fools

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.