1954) Psalm 148 (2009) [5.50] (1) My Guardian Angel (1997) [2.12] Vertue (2005) [7.13] Ascending into Heaven (1983) [7.11] (3,5,7,8,9) little tree (2004) [6.26] (2) Wild Mossy Mountains (1982) [5.02] (9) a blue true dream of sky (2003) [3.46] (3,4,6) Madrigal (2008) [2.28] Two Human Hymns (1995) [2.28] (10) Illuminare, Jerusalem (1985) [2.09] (10) Drop down, ye heavens, from above (1983) [1.31] Love Bade Me Welcome (1995/7) [3.01] Ettrick Banks (1985) [4.41] (9)
Matthew Knight (trombone) (1)
Jude Carlton (marimba) (2)
Marie-Claire Lindsay (soprano) (3)
Elly Brindle (alto) (4)
Felicity McDermott (alto) (5)
Emma Gullifer (alto) (6)
Pierre Dechant (tenor) (7)
Christopher Dollins (bass) (8)
Matthew Fletcher (organ) (9)
Annie Lydford (organ) (10)
Choir of Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge/Geoffrey Webber
rec. 8-10 July 2010, Jesus College Chapel, Cambridge
DELPHIAN DCD34095 [59.26]
Amazingly this is the first disc devoted entirely to Judith
Weir's choral works. It contains all of her music for unaccompanied
choir or with just one instrument. The music ranges from her
first choral piece in 1983 to the most recent in 2009. It was
recorded by the choir of Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge
under their director Geoffrey Webber; though it was actually
recorded in the chapel of Jesus College, with its 2007 organ
built by Orgelbau Kuhn of Switzerland.
Weir's setting of Psalm 148 was first performed in a
concert including all the Psalms, celebrating the 800th
anniversary of the University of Cambridge in 2009. It is written
for the rather unusual combination of choir and trombone, with
the trombone providing a lively counterpoint to the choir rather
than simply adding the bass notes. This results in some interesting
textures. Though Weir's psalm is designed as a paean of praise,
the work is thoughtful and not at all bumptious.
My GuardianAngel is a short, simple direct piece
written in 1997 for the Spitalfields Festival. Except that with
Weir, nothing is ever quite as simple as it appears. Vertue
was also written for the same festival in 2005. It sets three
poems of George Herbert. The composer wrote them in memory of
a friend who was a supporter of the festival. Weir responds
to Herbert’s poetry with a directness and subtle plainness
that is almost severe. Even in the third movement, where the
harmonic language becomes more anguished, there is still a directness
Ascending into Heaven is Weir's first major choral work.
Dating from 1983, it sets a Latin text by Hildebert of Lavardin
(1056-1133) (the English translation in the CD booklet is by
Weir herself). The organ plays a large part, but it doesn't
accompany rather than comment on and punctuate the choral parts.
Weir uses some lovely high organ textures that certainly indicate
the influence of Weir's teacher Messiaen. The work uses the
contrasts between the organ and the simpler and more complex
choral passages. The choral writing has real clarity and hints
of plainchant, but firmly in the modern idiom. A feeling of
rapture is suggestive of the music of Hildegard.
In little tree Weir sets the poetry of e.e.cummings (a
poet that she seems to have returned to more than once). It
comprises three short pieces for choir and marimba written originally
for the Young People's Chorus of New York. Weir uses three-part
chorus for upper voices, expanding into four parts for the final
piece. The marimba forms an interesting adjunct to the textures,
acting as continuo. There is a sense here of Weir matching the
apparent simplicity of cummings' poems, when in fact neither
of them is simple at all.
Her early, rather Messiaen-esqe organ piece, Wild Mossy Mountains
was written for the Edinburgh-based organist Michael Bonaventure;
the title comes from the text of a poem by Robert Burns.
Another e.e.cummings setting, a blue true dream of sky
was written in honour of choral director and organist Philip
Brunelle and first performed by his Plymouth Church Choir in
Minneapolis. This is a melodically attractive piece with a rapturous
solo soprano part accompanied by the choir.
Madrigal was commissioned by Kings College, Cambridge,
in 2008 to celebrate the 60th birthday of their then
chief conductor, Stephen Cleobury who had himself commissioned
Weir's Illuminare Jerusalem. It sets words from a Sardinian
folk-tale based around some pseudo-medieval organum. There is
a folk-like character to the setting, but mixed with something
Two Human Hymns were commissioned by the University of
Aberdeen for the University's Quincentenary in 1995. These set
George Herbert and another 17th century poet, Henry
King. In both pieces the choral part is lyrical with organ interruptions
in the first and toccata-like episodes in the second.
The other commission from Kings College, Cambridge, Illuminare,
Jerusalem was for the 1985 service of Nine Lessons and Carols.
The text, rather than Latin, is an anonymous 15th
Century Scottish one. Weir's setting is rhythmically lively
and with an interestingly dense harmonic texture.
Drop down ye heavens, from above was another Cambridge
commission, for Trinity College choir, which was performed in
1983. The text, in English, comes from the Advent Prose in a
lovely hymn-like setting.
Love, bade me welcome is a version of the first of the
Two Human Hymns which Weir made two years after its original
composition. It was made for a choir from Orkney, the Mayfield
Written in 1985, the final organ piece Ettrick Banks
is based on the Scottish air of that name. This setting combines
a flowing texture with denser harmonies.
In listening to these pieces I kept coming back to the athleticism,
intensity and clarity of Weir's writing. There is often a purity
and austerity to the line of her music which not for the first
time feels rather Calvinist. These pieces are always approachable,
but on first acquaintance you feel that you are missing something.
That there is more underneath is evident from repeat hearings.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.