There have been a couple of Figaros on DVD lately where 
                the plot is distorted and the setting more or less absurd. After 
                all this it is a relief to see that David McVicar presents a ‘normal’ 
                version with elegant staterooms and period costumes. And it doesn’t 
                seem in the least old-fashioned! On the contrary the sets, the 
                costumes and the action go hand in hand with the music. The production 
                breathes with Mozart - no artificial respiration is necessary 
                - and we are confronted with real characters of the late 18th 
                century. They are performed with a lightness and a cobweb-free 
                liveliness that make them easily transformable to the present 
                day.
                  
McVicar 
                    has read the score closely and reacted to Mozart’s ‘under-story’ 
                    – the directions and comments that are in the orchestra, sometimes 
                    reinforcing the text, sometimes contrapuntal and even telling 
                    a different story. He, the composer, knows more than the characters 
                    themselves. In McVicar’s mind the overture is no mere prelude 
                    to the evening, where the audience have an opportunity to 
                    finish their conversations. This musical masterpiece is a 
                    little symphonic poem which, though in no way thematically 
                    related to the following play as the overtures to Così 
                    fan tutte and Die Zauberflöte are, lends itself 
                    to an amusing pantomime. And the high spirits that are evoked 
                    continue as an undercurrent all through the opera – even though 
                    there are also moments of darkness, even brutality. Count 
                    Almaviva, who is presented as a many-faceted human being, 
                    is also a hothead. In the second act he actually hits the 
                    Countess – maybe a nod in the direction of reality, where 
                    physical violence within marriage seems on the increase. Another 
                    parallel may be the teenaged Cherubino appearing markedly 
                    tipsy in the last act. Closer to the revolutionary ideas of 
                    Beaumarchais’s late 18th century is the obvious 
                    antagonism between Figaro and the Count. The third act scene 
                    with the sextet, when it is revealed that Marcellina and Bartolo 
                    are Figaro’s parents, is more straightforward comedy – but 
                    far from the slapstick farce it can sometimes be in less sensitive 
                    hands. Overall style is the buzzword for this production; 
                    inventiveness within a traditional concept. Just one tiny 
                    detail: there is no scene-shift between acts 3 and 4, just 
                    frozen positions and then over to Barbarina’s aria where she 
                    mourns the loss of the pin for which we have been prepared 
                    in the previous scene.
                  
Musically 
                    it is also a highly attractive performance. Antonio Pappano 
                    paces the music excellently, giving the singers a certain 
                    freedom to make individual imprints and allowing them to embellish 
                    the vocal line. The effect is both stylish and elegant. It 
                    is also a musically very complete version where both Marcellina 
                    and Don Basilio are allowed their arias in the last act. Both 
                    are well sung. It is a particular pleasure to see and hear 
                    Philip Langridge in the latter role, vocally seemingly indestructible. 
                    He both looks and sings just as splendidly as he did when 
                    I last saw him on stage – and that must be close to twenty 
                    years ago!
                  
Good 
                    singing and acting is moreover the order of the day with not 
                    a weak link among the cast. Erwin Schrott is a splendid Figaro, 
                    manly, youthful, good looking and a magnificent singer. He 
                    has bass notes that elude many a Figaro and generally makes 
                    a sensitive and believable valet. Miah Persson is a mercurial 
                    and expressive Susanna, definitely in the top flight of lyrical 
                    sopranos in the world today. Her facial expressions reveal 
                    all her feelings and she sings an exquisite last act aria. 
                    Together with her mistress, the Countess, she also performs 
                    a lovely Letter Duet in act 3. On her own Dorothea Röschmann 
                    excels in the Countess’s two arias, standing out as a truly 
                    tragic person but with a will of steel; this comes through 
                    in the intensity of her singing. Dove sono in act 3 
                    is more powerful than most readings I have heard – but sensitive. 
                    Great singing indeed! Gerald Finley is also a splendid actor 
                    combining burnished tone with honeyed suavity when it suits 
                    him. Rinat Shaham is truly boyish in the notoriously difficult-to-cast 
                    role as Cherubino and sings with nervous passion. She is almost 
                    in the Christine Schäfer class, a singer to my mind unsurpassable 
                    in the role. Jonathan Veira, another splendid actor, makes 
                    the most of Dr Bartolo, even though he is more baritone than 
                    bass and lacks the booming bottom notes.
                  
The 
                    presentation is exemplary with a detailed tracklist in the 
                    booklet which makes it easy to access individual numbers. 
                    The sound is splendid and the video direction excellent. There 
                    are enough overview pictures to get involved in the settings 
                    but the director works a lot with close-ups which pays dividends 
                    with so eminent a cast of singing actors. This is one of those 
                    DVD operas that requires to be seen again and more than once. 
                    Readers who don’t believe in over-fanciful reconstructions 
                    or transportations in time can rest assured that this is the 
                    real thing – and still up to date.
                  
Göran 
                    Forsling