Frédéric CHOPIN (1810-1849) The 1981 Baldwin Recordings
Fantasie in F minor, Op. 49 (1841) [11:50]
Waltz in D flat major, Op. 64/1 ‘Minute’ (1846-47) [1:41]
Waltz in A flat major, Op. 64/3 (1846-47) [2:40]
Waltz in C sharp minor, Op. 64/2 (1846-47) [3:21]
Waltz in A flat, ‘L’Adieu’ Op. 69/1 (1835) [3:39]
Ballade No. 4 in F minor, Op. 52 (1842-43) [11:00]
Nocturne in C sharp minor, Op. posth [4:10]
Nocturne in F major, Op. 15/1 (1830-32) [4:21]
Nocturne in F sharp major, Op. 15/2 (1830-32) [3:34]
Nocturne in B major, Op. 32/1 (1837) [5:28]
Étude in G flat major ‘Black Key’, Op. 10/5 (1830) [1:40]
Andante Spianato and Grande Polonaise Brillante, Op. 22 (1834) [13:31]
Prelude in C major ‘Reunion’, Op. 28/1 (1838-39) [1:11]
Prelude in A major ‘The Polish Dance’, Op. 28/7 (1838-39) [2:05]
Prelude in G minor ‘Impatience’, Op. 28/22 (1838-39) [0:39]
Prelude in D minor ‘The Storm’, Op. 28/24 (1838-39) [2:21]
Earl Wild (piano)
rec. 1981, Guzman Hall, University of Miami, USA. ADD IVORY CLASSICS
Frédéric CHOPIN (1810-1849) The Complete Etudes Twelve Études (Studies), Op. 10 (1829-32):
C major, Op. 10/1 [2:15]
A minor, Op. 10/2 [1:35]
E major, ‘Tristesse’ Op. 10/3 [4:26]
C sharp minor, Op. 10/4 [2:07]
G flat major, ‘Black Key’ Op. 10/5 [1:43]
E flat minor, Op. 10/6 [3:35]
C major, Op. 10/7 [1:36]
F major, Op. 10/8 [2:26]
F minor, Op. 10/9 [2:04]
A flat major, Op. 10/10 [2:09]
E flat major, Op. 10/11 [2:30]
C minor, ‘Revolutionary’ Op. 10/12 [2:32] Twelve Études (Studies), Op. 25 (1832-36):
A flat major, ‘Aeolian Harp’ Op. 25/1 [2:40]
F minor, ‘Les Abeilles’ Op. 25/2 [1:30]
F major, Op. 25/3 [1:51]
A minor, Op. 25/4 [1:51]
E minor, Op. 25/5 [3:11]
G sharp minor, Op. 25/6 [2:02]
C sharp minor, Op. 25/7 [5:03]
D flat major, Op. 25/8 [1:10]
G flat major, ‘Butterfly’ Op. 25/9 [0:58]
B minor, Op. 25/10 [3:46]
A minor, ‘Winter Wind’ Op. 25/11 [3:38]
C minor, Op. 25/12 [2:39] Trois Nouvelles Études (1839):
No. 1 in F minor [2:15]
No. 2 in A flat major [1:46]
No. 3 in D flat major [1:48]
Earl Wild (piano)
rec. 8-12 June 1992, Fernleaf Abbey, Columbus, Ohio, USA. DDD IVORY CLASSICS
Frédéric CHOPIN (1810-1849) Scherzos and Ballades
Scherzo No. 1 in B minor, Op. 20 (1831) [9:12]
Scherzo No. 2 in B flat minor, Op. 31 (1837) [8:55]
Scherzo No. 3 in C sharp minor, Op. 39 (1839) [6:38]
Scherzo No. 4 in E major, Op. 54 (1843) [10:28]
Ballade No. 1 in G minor, Op. 23 (1835-36) [8:40]
Ballade No. 2 in F major, Op. 38 (1836-39) [7:26]
Ballade No. 3 in A flat major, Op. 47 (1841) [6:54]
Ballade No. 4 in F minor, Op. 52 (1842-43) [10:27]
Earl Wild (piano)
rec. 7-10 May 1990, Fernleaf Abbey, Columbus, Ohio, USA. DDD IVORY CLASSICS 75001 [68:40]
works are canons buried among flowers.” Robert Schumann
Marketed by the Ivory Classics label as 'The Romantic Master', Earl
Wild the American pianist and composer was born in Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania in 1915. Pursuing an exceptionally long performing
career of eight decades he is recognised as one of the foremost
piano virtuoso of his generation. The booklet notes state that
he is, “Considered by many to be the last of the great Romantic
pianists.” Wild, a winner at the 39th Grammy® Awards for
his recording of ‘Virtuoso Piano Transcriptions’, is
renowned for his extraordinary keyboard mastery and is revered
in America. However from my experience he is not as well known
in Britain and Europe as his playing deserves.
Earl Wild: Chopin - The 1981 Baldwin
Recordings The title of the disc refers to Earl Wild’s association with the Baldwin
Piano Company from New York City. They recorded six Baldwin
performers on LPs to be given away by their dealers to buyers
of a Baldwin piano and not intended for commercial public circulation.
For his recording session, in 1981 at the University
of Miami, the sixty-six year old Earl Wild used a Baldwin
SD-10 piano. The other Baldwin pianists: Jorge Bolet, Ruth Laredo,
David Barillan and Gilbert Kalish did not use the same piano
for their recordings. Wild recorded an all-Chopin programme,
although, there was a separate compilation LP of the performances
of all six players entitled ‘The Essential Piano Library’ given
away to libraries. A couple of years later Baldwin allowed Audiofon
Records to release Earl Wild’s acclaimed Chopin recordings commercially,
however, not all the works from the sessions would fit on the
LP. This disc from Ivory Classics is the first time that all
the Chopin material from Earl Wild’s legendary Baldwin Recordings
from 1981 at the Guzman Hall has been available on compact disc.
The first work on the sixteen track disc is the Fantasie in F minor in
which Wild impressively captures the myriad moods and brings
significant insights to the score. Other notable tracks includes
the ‘Minute’ Waltz Op. 64/1 where one can easily
imagine an excitable dog chasing his tail. The Waltz in C
sharp minor, Op. 64/2 is interpreted as a highly seasoned
score bursting briskly with vast resources of energy. Revealed
by the soloist as an elegant score the Waltz in A flat major, ‘L’Adieu’ Op.
69/1 is evocative of models at a haute
couture fashion show. In the substantial Ballade
No. 4, often regarded as Chopin’s greatest Ballade,
Wild successfully blends irresistible melody with considerable
grandeur. In the celebrated Nocturne in C sharp minor,
Op. posth he conveys a convincing dark foreboding. In
the highly melodious Nocturne in F sharp major Earl Wild
reveals heady emotions that could easily represent a secret
love affair. The Etude in G flat major, known as the ‘Black
Key’, one of my favourite Chopin scores, is played with
reasonable vigour and a sense of fun bordering on hilarity.
Carrying the grand title the Andante Spianato and Grande
Polonaise Brillante, Op. 22 is a substantial score in two
sections where the Andante Spianato segues into
the Grande Polonaise Brillante.With the pastoral character of the lovely Andante
Spianato Wild paints the scene of a brook flowing through
green meadows. By contrast the Grande Polonaise Brillante contains
a copious degree of drama. Earl Wild interprets the Prelude
in A major ‘The Polish Dance’, Op. 28/7 most sedately,
losing its dance-like delicacy and charm and bordering on the
funereal. The rumbling Prelude in D minor ‘The Storm’,
Op. 28/24 is relentlessly evocative of a wild and stormy night.
For Ivory Classics the 1981 recorded
sound, remastered using 24-bit power,
is bright, clear and decently balanced. Some slight background
hiss has been retained and the sound would I feel have benefited
from a touch more depth. The liner-notes including the interesting
and informative essay by James E. Frazier provide a high quality
Earl Wild: Chopin
- The Complete Études The complete Études (Studies) were recorded and originally
released in 1992 when Wild was seventy-seven. Again Wild favoured
a Baldwin piano for the Columbus recording sessions.The
first set of twelve Études, Op. 10 (1829-32) was published
as such in 1833 and was dedicated by Chopin to Franz Liszt.
The second set of twelve Études, Op. 25 (1832-36) was published
as a single volume in 1837 bearing the dedication to Franz Liszt’s
mistress Countess Marie d’Agoult. In 1840 Ignaz Moscheles and
François-Joseph Fétis published their celebrated piano instruction
book Méthode des Méthodes de piano (Method of Methods
for the Piano). Chopin’s Trois Nouvelles Études (Three
New Études) were composed in 1839 as his contribution to
the supplementary volume to the Méthode. Although the Trois
Nouvelles Études were actually published in Chopin’s lifetime
in 1840 it was thought - incorrectly - that they had been published
as posthumous works.
Of the Twelve Études, Op. 10
(1829-32) Earl Wild’s interpretation of the Étude in C major,
Op. 10/1 is noteworthy with his right hand arpeggios sounding
like waves lapping on the shore. The soloist in the Étude
in A minor, Op. 10/2 has a scurrying quality that feels
like a fiendishly difficult exercise. I was impressed by the
fun and frolics with the black notes in the ‘Black Key’ Étude
in G flat major, Op. 10/5. One senses that Wild is less
comfortable with the serious and nervous temperament of the Étude
in E flat minor, Op. 10/6 than my benchmark interpretations
from Murray Perahia on Sony Classical and Maurizio Pollini on Deutsche
Grammophon. With the repeated notes
and arpeggios of the tempestuous Étude in F minor,
Op. 10/9 the soloist communicates anger and frustration. A strong
feel of the parlour expressed by the Étude in A flat major,
Op. 10/10 does not convey the technical difficulties of the
study. The final work of the opus 10 set is the appropriately
titled ‘Revolutionary’ Étude in C minor, Op. 10/12.
Chopin was inspired to write the C minor by the invasion
of Warsaw by the Russian army and Wild does not fail in providing
power and tension in profusion.
In first of the Twelve Études, Op. 25 the Étude
in A flat major, Op. 25/1, known as the ‘Aeolian Harp’,
one marvels at the splendid embellishments and other wizardry
that Chopin demands. In the Étude in F minor, Op. 25/2
known by the sobriquet of ‘Les Abeilles’ (The Bees)
Wild convincingly suggests a picture of insects in flight
and in the Étude in A minor, Op. 25/4 one feels the
temperament of this restless and nervy study. His interpretation
of the Étude in E minor, Op. 25/5 is evocative of birds
darting around foraging for food. Unlike some performers he
chooses not to accentuate the attractive melody in the central
section. The brief Étude in G flat major,Op.
25/9 titled ‘Butterfly’ is a jovial and swift piece
that contrasts with the frenzied attack by Wild in the Étude
in B minor, Op. 25/10. The B minor study has a
melodic central section that provides a welcome respite. I
enjoyed the playing of the Étude in A minor, Op. 25/11
titled ‘Winter Wind’, a complex and turbulent work
that sends a chill down the spine. The final piece of the
opus 25 set is the Étude in C minor, Op. 25/12 that
is noteworthy for its rapid left and right hand arpeggios over
a noble melody.
With the Trois Nouvelles Études I particularly enjoyed the
Slavic feel to the forthright Étude,
No. 1 in F minor. In the Étude,
No. 2 in A flat major Wildimparts a disconcerted
and restless quality and in the Étude, No. 3 in D flat major a
generally pensive mood is established with undercurrents of
Ivory Classics release was recorded
by Earl Wild in 1992 at Fernleaf Abbey,
Columbus, Ohio. The digital quality of this 20-bit State-of-the-Art
Original recording is of a high standard, being especially bright
and clear with an impressive balance. For those technically minded
we are informed that the recording has been remastered at 24-bit
using the SADiE Artemis High Resolution digital workstation. James
E. Frazier again provides the liner-notes and essay; a model of
the finest annotation.
Wild with this complete set of Études is up against extremely
strong competition. There are magnificent sets from Perahia
on Sony Classical and Pollini on Deutsche Grammophon
that rank amongst their finest recordings (see details below). In
the Études Perahia
is highly compelling, displaying remarkable pianism with a broad
expressive range. The digital sound on Perahia’s Sony recording
has outstanding presence and clarity. Pollini’s magisterial
accounts of the Études are
brilliantly characterised totally engaging the listener. I found
the admirable analogue sonics for Pollini on Deutsche Grammophon
of eminent quality being especially cool and clear.
Earl Wild: Chopin - Scherzos and Ballades I especially enjoyed Earl Wild’s recital of Chopin’s 4 Ballades and
4 Scherzos. Thisis one of the finest recordings
of these scores that I have heard and are worthy of a place
in any collection.
In the Scherzo No. 1 in B minor, Op. 20 Wild provides an abundance
of drama amid the intensity of the anger and power. Glorious
melody abounds in the Scherzo No. 2 in B flat minor,
Op. 31 with playing from the American
soloist that is delicious one minute and bursting with ferocious
power the next. The performance
of the Scherzo No. 3 in C sharp minor, Op. 39 conveys
darkness and scorn with the smooth coolness of a block of polished
marble. With his expressive playing of the Scherzo No. 4 Wild
communicates spirited humour with a darting sense of restlessness.
This is a highly impressive recital of an elevated standard that will
delight and satisfy most listeners. I remain a strong advocate
of Artur Rubinstein’s remarkably compelling 1959 New York City
performances of the Scherzos. These acclaimed recordings
are available on a marvellously re-mastered RCA Victor Red Seal
Living Stereo SACD 82876-61396-2 RE1 (c/w 4 Ballades)
and also on RCA Victor Red Seal 09026 63045-2 (c/w 4 Ballades and Tarantelle).
The Ballade No. 1 in G minor, Op. 23 is given a performance
that abounds in incident. We hear an exciting amalgam of passion,
vigour, poignancy, athleticism, tenderness and impulsiveness;
rather like the life story of an intrepid adventurer. The playing
of the Ballade No. 2 in F major, Op. 38 contrasts beauty
and delicacy with a wild storminess. In the Ballade No. 3
in A flat major, Op. 47 the soloist evokes the innocence
and emotional reassurance of the infant’s nursery against a
character of flamboyant impulsivity. Irresistibly enchanting,
the Ballade No. 4 in F minor, Op. 52 in this interpretation
has a highly perfumed, dance-like quality.
recorded this recital for Ivory Classics in 1990 at Fernleaf Abbey, Columbus, Ohio. I was impressed by the high
standard sonics that are bright, vividly clear and well balanced.
The ample booklet contains an interesting essay of the Scherzos and Ballades by
Christopher Weiss together with a biography of the pianist.
My longstanding benchmark recording of Chopin’s 4 Ballades are
the magnificent performances from Arthur Rubinstein that he
made in 1959 at New York City. Rubinstein’s interpretations
are truly magical and I find it hard to imagine that I will
hear playing that contains more poetry and expression. The Rubinstein
recordings are available on RCA Victor Red Seal Living Stereo
SACD 82876-61396-2 RE1 (c/w 4 Scherzos) and also on RCA
Victor Red Seal 09026 63045-2 (c/w 4 Scherzos and Tarantelle).
Perahia also greatly excels in Chopin’s 4 Ballades.
He recorded them in 1994 in Switzerland. I admire his expansive
lyricism that combines power with sensitivity in what is arguably
Perahia’s finest recorded recital. It is available on Sony Classical
SK 64399 (c/w selection of Nocturnes; Etudes; Mazurkas etc).
In the performances of these three ‘all Chopin’ discs I did not experience
any excessive showmanship, outsized personality or contrivance.
Wild’s playing seems to evolve from his inherent feel for the
music. It is often understated yet radiates a sense of instinctive
individuality. At times I demanded more extremes of dynamic
yet the personality of the playing greatly satisfies owing predominantly
to the immense integrity of these cultivated interpretations.
On a general level if one requires their Chopin performances
to have additional servings of passion, vitality and drama one
needs to hear interpretations from Murray
Perahia, Maurizio Pollini, Grigory Sokolov and Martha
Argerich. For those needing accomplished artistry and a special
sense of poetry the playing of Artur Rubinstein is essential
listening. I class Rubinstein as the consummate Chopin
interpreter and at times marvel at the extent of his imagination,
his lightness of touch and the poetry he brings to his interpretations.
The warm and thoughtful playing of Claudio Arrau shares similar
values to those of Rubinstein. One might also consider the talents
of Vladimir Horowitz, a performer who is renowned for his remarkable
insights and technique, and also Dinu Lipatti's scrupulous
and subtle performances.
Over the years I have assembled an extensive collection of Chopin
recordings and there are many wonderful interpretations available
in the catalogues. My particular favourites are shown below.
These three recital discs are not my first choice recommendations,
however, they are splendidly performed. I’m sure that I will
return to them often; especially the version of the Scherzos and Ballades.
the following recordings of works contained on these
Ivory Classics discs. Waltzes: a)
Artur Rubinstein recorded 14 Waltzes in 1963 at Rome
for RCA Victor Red Seal 09026 63047-2 (c/w Impromptus; Fantaisie
Impromptu and Bolero).
Claudio Arrau recorded 14 Waltzes in 1979 at Switzerland
for Philips 400 025-2.
Dinu Lipatti recorded 13 Waltzes at his final recital
in 1950 live at the Besançon Festival for EMI Classics ‘Great
Artists of The Century’ 5 62819 2 (c/w Bach PartitaNo.
1; Mozart Piano Sonata No. 8, K310 and Schubert Impromptus
No. 3 and No. 2, D899).
Artur Rubinstein recorded 4 Ballades in 1959 at New York City for RCA Victor Red Seal
Living Stereo SACD 82876-61396-2 RE1 (c/w 4 Scherzos)
also on RCA Victor Red Seal 09026 63045-2 (c/w 4 Scherzos and Tarantelle).
b) Murray Perahia recorded 4 Ballades in 1994 in Switzerland
for Sony Classical SK 64399 (c/w selection of Nocturnes; Etudes; Mazurkas etc).
Artur Rubinstein recorded 19 Nocturnes in 1965 at Rome,
a two disc set for RCA Victor Red Seal 09026 63049-2.
Claudio Arrau recorded 21 Nocturnes in 1978 at Amsterdam
for Philips ‘50 Great Performances’ 464 694-2 (c/w Barcarolle and Fantaisie).
Preludes: a) Maurizio Pollini recorded 24 Preludes, Op. 28 in
1974 at Munich for Deutsche Grammophon 413
b) Claudio Arrau recorded 24 Preludes, Op. 28in
1973 at Amsterdam for Philips ‘The Originals’ 475 7768 (c/w Impromptus 1-4; PreludesNo.
25 and No. 26 ).
c) Martha Argerich recorded 24 Preludes, Op. 28in
1975 at Munich for Deutsche Grammophon 463
663-2 (c/w PreludesNo. 25 and No. 26, Piano Sonata
Grigory Sokolov recorded 24 Preludes,
Op. 28in 1990 at Paris for Naïve Records OP 30336.
a) Murray Perahia recorded 12 Études, Op. 10 and 12 Études,Op.
25 in 2001 in London for Sony Classical SK 61885.
b) Maurizio Pollini recorded 12 Études, Op. 10 and 12 Études,Op.
25 in 1972 at Munich for Deutsche
Grammophon 413 794-2.
Artur Rubinstein recorded 4 Scherzos in 1959 at New York City for RCA Victor Red Seal
Living Stereo SACD 82876-61396-2 RE1 (c/w 4 Ballades)
also on RCA Victor Red Seal 09026 63045-2 (c/w 4 Ballades and Tarantelle)
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.