Having just reviewed a fine performance of the original Das
Lied von der Erde
from Houston (Naxos 8.572498
it seemed a good idea to tackle the two Schoenberg arrangements
as played by this curiously-titled orchestra and their principal
guest conductor, Kenneth Woods. These works are the product of
Schoenberg’s Society for Private Musical Performances (Verein
für musikalische Privataufführungen) set up in Vienna in 1918
to promote and present the work of modern composers to sympathetic
One only has to read contemporary accounts of the premiere of Schoenberg’s Second String Quartet in 1908 and see the caricatures published in Die Zeit
to be reminded of just how toxic the Austrian capital was for Mahler, Schoenberg and their forward-thinking allies. Little wonder that Schoenberg felt the need for such a group which, although it folded in 1921, had a substantial worklist and held regular concerts. Among his Mahler arrangements are the Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen
– written for a concert in 1920 – and Das Lied von der Erde
which, apart from the first song, had to be fleshed out by the conductor Rainer Riehn in 1983.
There are several recordings of the Schoenberg-Riehn score, Osmo Vänskä (BIS), Kent Nagano (Sony) and Philippe Herreweghe (Harmonia Mundi) among them. The latter performance, from a conductor I don’t usually warm to, is rather splendid, helped in no small measure by a reach-out-and-touch recording and the presence of a near-ideal tenor, Hans Peter Blochwitz. The soloists on the SOMM recording are all unfamiliar, but seconds into the first of the Wayfarer songs – Wenn mein Schatz hochzeit macht
– I was more than contented with David Stout’s steady, characterful baritone. Diction is good, and the balance between orchestra and soloist seems just right.
The overall sound is wonderfully aerated, perfect for music that’s so artfully distilled, the lower strings especially rich and vibrant. The pizzicati
in that Mahlerian ur
-tune Ging heut’ morgen übers Feld
are a joy to hear, although it’s Stout’s subtle, feeling response to this song that really catches the ear and gladdens the heart. The real pleasure resides in Schoenberg’s masterly arrangement, which preserves the mood and manner of Mahler’s originals while condensing his sound-world to its bare, ear-pricking essentials. Newcomers to this arrangement will be pleased to hear that it’s anything but desiccated, Ich hab’ ein glühend Messer
, a fine example of late-Romantic blush contained in a score of remarkable economy and elegance.
Indeed, elegance is a good description of Woods’ approach to these songs; he coaxes glorious sounds from his players and, thanks to a good recording and quiet audience, every nudge and nuance is easily heard. The aching loveliness of Die zwei blauen Augen
has seldom been so feelingly caught, those dragging rhythms so well judged. Crowning it all is Stout’s fine-spun singing; really, this is a voice I would travel many miles to hear. I’ve added him to my list of singers to watch. And if that’s not enough, the beautifully-turned orchestral coda has a sustained, heart-stopping delicacy I’ve rarely encountered in this oft-played song.
Goodness, what an arresting start to this disc and proof, as I pointed out in my Houston review, that the best Mahler doesn’t only emanate from Vienna, Berlin or Lucerne. What of Das Lied von der Erde
? It’s a tougher piece to bring off, but Das Trinklied vom Jammer der Erde
certainly makes a good first impression, tenor Brennen Guillory, suitably ardent, coping well with Mahler’s taxing tessitura. The orchestral playing is as pointful as before, textures clean without being squeakily so; indeed, despite the general lightness of tread and the rarefied scoring there’s no doubting the music’s provenance.
Woods adopts sensible speeds throughout, and there’s a pleasing scale and shape to this reading that, although it’s less forthright than Herreweghe’s, is no worse for that. Contralto Emma Curtis makes a fine entrance in Der Einsame im Herbst
, but only after a delectable orchestral prelude that simply glows with the colours of autumn. She doesn’t efface memories of Jane Henschel in that Houston recording, but there’s a vulnerability to her delivery that’s entirely apt. Evanescence is always a word that springs to mind here, and that’s evident at every turn, from Curtis’s girlish singing to the orchestra’s dark, woody tones.
Von der Jugend
is wonderfully mobile, Guillory as deft as one could hope for. There are moments, though, when Schoenbergian clarity is replaced by a degree of opacity, but on the whole this Riehn completion is fairly satisfying, and it’s well played and sung. Ditto Von der Schönheit,
with its echt
-Mahlerian calls and counter-calls, Curtis clear and characterful as ever, if a little rushed at times. Bass is sparingly used in these arrangements, but when it appears – as here – it’s reasonably well defined. Unusually for a live recording the nicely etched sound has a compensating halo of warmth that’s easy on the ear.
In Der Trunkene im Frühling
Guillory is perhaps a little overstretched compared with Blochwitz, but otherwise there’s very little to criticise here. As for Der Abschied,
I described it in my Houston review as an abendrot
like no other; and so it proves here, from the opening tam-tam stroke to the falling figures that follow. Curtis may not have the tonal richness of Herreweghe’s Birgit Remmert, but still she sings with quiet authority, shadowed by orchestral playing of equal poise. Even in this trembling air of dissolution and decay, pulse is all important, and Woods doesn’t let it falter. But for all the score’s felicities, the occasional monochrome moment makes one regret all the more that Schoenberg never completed the arrangement himself.
I wouldn’t want to be without Herreweghe and his team in Das Lied von der Erde,
even though he offers no filler. As it happens, it’s the shorter piece on the SOMM disc that’s the real treasure. Make no mistake, the main work is supremely well played and sung, but it does face stiff competition from elsewhere.
A fine Mahler disc, much prized for a radiant account of the Wayfarer songs.