Founding Editor Rob Barnett Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Modest MUSSORGSKY(1839 - 1881) Khovanshchina (1882)
Aleksej Krivchenya (bass) - Prince Ivan Khovansky, head of the
Streltsy; Vladislav Piavko (tenor) - Prince Andrey Khovansky, his son;
Aleksej Maslennikov (tenor) - Prince Vasily Golitsin; Aleksandr Ognivtsev
(bass) - Dosifey, head of the schismatics; Victor Nechipailo (baritone) -
Boyar Shaklovity; Irina Arkhipova (mezzo) - Marfa, a schismatic; Tatiana
Tugarinova (soprano) - Susanna, an old schismatic; Gennadi Efimov (tenor) -
Scrivener; Tamara Sorokina (soprano) - Emma, a maiden from the German
Quarter; Yurij Korolev (bass) - Varsonofyev, a retainer of Golitsin; Yurij
Grigoriev (baritone) - Kuzka, a Strelets
Choir and Orchestra of the State Academic Bolshoi Theatre and the
Kremlin Palace of Congresses/Boris Khaikin
rec. 1974 (according to the booklet; other sources say 1972)
MELODIYA MELCD 10 01867 [3 CDs: 40:31 + 61:35 + 57:13]
Russian history was a central interest for Modest Mussorgsky.
Boris Godunov deals with the troubled years around 1600
and Khovanshchina a similarly dark period about a century
later when there was opposition to Peter the Great’s attempts
at westernizing Russia. It was Prince Ivan Khovansky, the Old
Believers and the Streltsy who plotted against Tsar Peter, but
Peter got the best of it and the followers of Khovansky committed
mass suicide. At least they do in the opera, but Mussorgsky
was rather free in his way with historical facts.
Mussorgsky wrote his own libretto and started composing in 1872,
before he revised Boris Godunov. Illness and over-consumption
of alcohol prevented progress during long periods and when he
died in 1881 the opera was still unfinished. His friend Rimsky-Korsakov
completed it and orchestrated it and in that version it was
finally premiered in 1886. In the 1950s Dmitri Shostakovich
re-orchestrated the work in closer accordance with the composer’s
intentions and it is that version that is most often heard today.
On the present recording it is the Rimsky-Korsakov version that
is performed. Khovanshchina has never attained the same
popularity as Boris Godunov. One reason I believe is
the complicated plot, another is the slow dramatic speed. Even
so, there is a lot of accessible music with such numbers as
the Dance of the Persian Slaves and some groovy choruses.
The present version was recorded in 1974 and has been re-mastered.
The sound is good with lots of detail. The voices are very close
and in the face of the listener. Listening with headphones,
which I regularly do, I had to change the volume setting intermittently
to protect my eardrums. Orchestral music needed some extra decibels,
but when one of the grand basses appeared the sound was unsociable
unless I turned it down quite a lot.
Boris Khaikin (1904-1978) was one of the legendary Russian conductors
during the last century. He was principal at the Kirov Theatre
in Leningrad 1944-1953, whereupon he moved over to the Bolshoi
in Moscow. He recorded Khovanshchina with the Kirov forces
in 1946 (see review) and again in 1974 at the Bolshoi.
There is no doubting that either of these two recordings are
as idiomatic as could be with conductor, orchestra and singers
steeped in a tradition with roots struck deep in the 19th
century. What they also have in common are some less attractive
features, typical of the Russian tradition: voice production.
Slavonic wobble has long been a pejorative but in the olden
days this was normal. Beauty of tone was subordinated to drama
and intensity. In the old recording the chorus sometimes sprawls.
By contrast the Bolshoi evinces more Western ideals and thus
a more sonorous and even choral sound. Listen to the chorus
that concludes act III. Beautiful singing! Solo voices are however
still Slavonic in 1974 - at least the sopranos and tenors. Fortunately
the sopranos have little to sing but Piavko’s Prince Andrey
has that typical hard tenor tone that cuts glass, and he sings
at an unremitting fortissimo. Efimov in the character role of
Scrivener is easier to digest. Then there is Alexej Maslennikov,
who was a major artist and in a different political climate
he would have had a commanding international career. Herbert
von Karajan engaged him for his recording of Boris Godunov
in 1970 where he was Shuisky and also doubled as the Simpleton.
His Golitsin on this recording is a worthy memento of this singer,
a smooth, mellifluous, lyrical voice utilized with the utmost
sensitivity and elegance.
When we move over to the lower voices there is a lot more to
relish. First and foremost we have Irina Arkhipova, one of the
greatest mezzo-sopranos active during the 1960s and 1970s. Marfa
was among her greatest roles and the Fortune telling aria (CD
2 tr. 3) is beautifully sung - marvellous. She surpasses by
a wide margin both Sofya Preobrazhenskaya on the earlier Khaikin
recording and Elena Zaremba on a DVD from Liceu.
On the male side there is a host of strong baritones and basses,
not least the baritone Victor Nechipailo who has a long expressive
solo in act III. The most central characters are Ivan Khovansky
and Dosifey, the leader of the schismatics. The former is magnificently
sung and acted by Aleksej Krivchenya, who at the time of the
recording was well past 60. Born in 1910 he died in March 1974,
which makes me wonder whether this recording was made that year.
Anyway it is obvious that it is an old singer, no longer so
sonorous, but with an expressivity that is almost visible. The
latter is beautifully sung by Aleksandr Ognivtsev with a somewhat
lighter and more baritonal voice. He is not quite in the same
class as Mark Reizen on the older recording, but then no one
is really in that class and Ognivtsev is splendid in his own
Khovanshchina is an opera that grows with each hearing.
The story is as unwieldy every time but the great power and
beauty of the music makes it worthwhile. This Bolshoi recording,
in spite of some less than inspiring singing, has a great deal
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.