Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
for £12.49 postage paid World-wide.
Gabriel FAURÉ (1845-1924) Complete Barcarolles:
Barcarolle No. 1, Op. 26 in A minor (1881) [4:56]
Barcarolle No. 2, Op. 41 in G major (1885) [6:32]
Barcarolle No. 3, Op. 42 in G flat major (1885) [7:14]
Barcarolle No. 4, Op. 44 in A flat major (1886) [3:32]
Barcarolle No. 5, Op.66 in F sharp minor (1894) [5:21]
Barcarolle No. 6, Op. 70 in E flat major (1896) [3:23]
Barcarolle No. 7, Op. 90 in D minor (1905) [5:21]
Barcarolle No. 8, Op. 96 in D flat major (1906) [3:22]
Barcarolle No. 9, Op. 101 in A minor (1908-9) [2:56]
Barcarolle No. 10, Op.104/2 in A minor (1913) [3:16]
Barcarolle No. 11, Op. 105 in G minor (1913-14)[4:05]
Barcarolle No. 12, Op. 106 bis in E flat major (1915) [3:01]
Barcarolle No. 13, Op. 116 in C major (1921) [4:33] Trois Romances sans paroles, Op.17:
No. 1 in A flat [1:51]
No. 2 in A minor [2:17]
No. 3 in A flat major [2:41]
Charles Owen (piano)
rec. 5-7 July 2010, Wyastone Concert Hall, Monmouth. DDD
AVIE AV2240 [63:19]
The music of Gabriel Fauré is elusive in a number of ways. He
shows a fondness for the 6/8 time signature, a rhythm that can
feel either as if it is in 2 or 3. His training as a church
musician shows in his modal harmonies, so the music seldom feels
settled in a particular key. Although there is something unmistakably
personal in its utterance, at the same time there is an ambiguity
about it. This is particularly so in his later music, which
is less melodic than his earlier style; the outer movements
often present a continuous flow dominated by ostinato patterns.
The piano Barcarolles were written between 1881 and 1921, covering
most of Fauré’s creative life. As the name suggests they were
inspired by Chopin’s wonderful Barcarolle, op. 60. Here and
there one hears an echo of Chopin, but for the most part Fauré’s
piano writing is not obviously derived from any other composer.
He frequently resorts to an accompaniment in semiquavers to
evoke the ripple of water. If one plays these works all at once
this can become a little monotonous, so I would recommend playing
them in groups of three or four.
Charles Owen adopts fairly deliberate tempi for the most part,
and his dynamics are restrained, in keeping with the intimate
nature of the music. His right hand often has a sparkling quality,
noticeable from the very first Barcarolle. The melodies transfer
effortlessly between the hands; this is an effect Fauré resorts
to quite frequently, but is particularly evident in the sixth
Barcarolle. The rapid scale passages in the right hand of the
third Barcarolle are played with great fluency, without being
merely decorative. The seventh Barcarolle marks the onset of
Fauré’s later, more opaque style; this piece has a notable air
of introspection. The eighth and eleventh Barcarolles are more
extraverted, but most of the later pieces feature melodies that
proceed by chromatic steps, rather like a crystal forming in
a concentrated solution. Owen is unfailingly responsive to the
subtle and unexpected nuances of this music.
The disc is rounded out by the early Romances sans Paroles.
These three pieces were written when Fauré was still a schoolboy,
and show the influence of the Mendelssohn Songs Without Words.
The gentle syncopation of the first Romance is well balanced
against the melody. The third has a relaxed charm and shows
Fauré’s fondness, even in his compositional infancy, for melodies
that proceed by downward steps. The recording is very good.
Jean-Philippe Collard’s 1990 compilation of the Barcarolles
and Romances also includes the delightful Dolly suite, four
Valses-caprices, a Mazurka, and the Souvenir de Bayreuth, based
on themes from the Ring cycle. After Owen’s sensitivity I found
Collard’s way with the music rather summary, and the repetitive
character of the piano writing was more pronounced.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.