Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Richard WAGNER (1813-1883) Die Meistersinger von Nurnberg:Prelude to Act 3 (1868) [8:17]
Edward ELGAR (1857-1934)
Cello Concerto in E minor, op. 85 (1919) [31:04]
Johannes BRAHMS (1833-1897)
Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 68 (1876) [47:27]
Alisa Weilerstein (cello)
Berliner Philharmoniker/Daniel Barenboim
rec. live, Sheldonian Theatre, Oxford, 30 April-1 May 2010, DDD
Video director: Rhodri Huw
Sound PCM 2.0 DTS Master Audio Surround Sound
TV format 1080i Full HD 16:9. Region Code All (worldwide)
The Prelude to Act 3 of The Mastersingers gets a restrained
but sonorous opening. The cellos are joined in seamless progression
by the dignified violas, second violins then first violins.
This is all solemnly meditative before a dawn glow from the
wind instruments. The effect is one of sheer density rather
than brightness. Yet what is enchanting is the softest of sensitive
entries by the strings again from 3:44 (in the DVD’s continuous
timing). Then at 4:46 the video director rightly homes in on
the flutes as they confirm a brighter phase. This is made more
memorable by the ethereal serenity of the probing first violins
in their high register. The brass response to this is suitably
fulsome but Barenboim pares down optimistic motif on its appearance
on strings and clarinet at 7:21; it is, after all, marked p
dolce. Then the lovely oboe take-up appears and also attracts
the video director’s focus. This all helps establish a contemplative
yet beneficent opening mood.
In the Elgar Cello Concerto the tone is set not by the rhetorical
opening solo but by the lyricism of Alisa Weilerstein’s second
solo leading into her introduction of the opening theme. This
has a sad beauty yet flows ever smoothly like a cloudy morning
the features of which gradually clear. The central section (13:09)
is more tender and emotive, especially its second theme (13:48)
featuring lovely calm interplay between strings and woodwind.
The return of the uneasy opening of this section and the soloist’s
lead-in to the reappearance of the movement’s first theme is
passionate yet more rhetorical than angry. I compared Barenboim’s
live performance with the Philadelphia Orchestra and Jacqueline
Du Pré in 1970 (Sony 82876 78737 2). From the opening solos
this is more gritty, tense and reflective. The first theme is
not as smooth, more wan, but the central section has less by
way of contrast. Weilerstein/Barenboim go for an overall smoothness
of line. Du Pré/Barenboim point more clearly the distinction
in phrasing between first and last appearances of the first
theme. You can hear this in particular when the phrasing in
six notes gives way to phrasing in four notes then two notes,
giving a more halting and harrowing effect.
The introduction to Weilerstein/Barenboim’s second movement
scherzo is nifty yet quite warm. It is as if the soloist wants
to get away from the nimble semiquavers into something more
contemplative. Then, just as whimsically, she returns to athleticism.
This is deftly done, all the more so for not parading its virtuosity.
Barenboim supplies by turns a suitably feathery or rosy orchestral
backcloth. Soloist and conductor reveal the joie de vivre.
The ardent second theme (19:41), by not being too soulful, can
live peaceably with this. The 1970 Du Pré/Barenboim scherzo
is has a more substantial, wrenching introduction, a main body
of more nervous energy and a second theme whose declamatory
qualities are emphasised by forceful pointing of rhythm and
accents. The 2010 team give us some welcome respite.
Weilerstein’s slow movement is lyrical, tender and intimate.
The phrasing is sensitive, so are the dynamic contrasts. You
can hear this in the small swell from 24:13 and then the pianissimo
at 24:17, though the pp at 25:40 is undercooked. There’s
lots of portamento but it’s smoothly applied and the
orchestral strings match it when echoing the soloist. This movement
isn’t searing; the appassionato passage (25:00) is no
more than firm. This is where Du Pré is more gripping, lacking
Weilerstein’s beauty but intensely drawn out; arguably overdone.
Again Weilerstein displays a lyrical heart in the expressive
introduction of the finale. Its main theme has a resolute crustiness.
The second theme (29:43) is treated in more musing, exploratory
fashion. The crown of the movement and work is the third theme
(34:09), which can be read as a sad summation of life’s loves
and passing. Weilerstein/Barenboim play it with feeling and
dignity, keeping it flowing until Weilerstein finds her greatest
expressiveness for the return of the slow movement theme and
a magical shading down to pianissimo (37:42). Du Pré
is weightier for the opening crustiness and engages your attention
more. Her climax of the third theme is heartrending but her
return to the slow movement theme is over-expansive.
Tension is ever-present in Barenboim’s first movement of Brahms’
First Symphony. It underpins a powerful introduction with strings
that can sing. He also lays bare an epic quality as can also
be heard in the later oboe, flute and cello solos. A relative
formality is brought to the first theme but a greater opulence
can be found in the second one (45:09). A pity there’s no exposition
repeat. It’s also a shame that the lady double-bassoon player
isn’t pictured in her crucial solo. Instead at 48:59 at the
beginning of the crescendo in the development towards
the recapitulation we see the doubling cellos. For the next
minute or so that turbulent crescendo is thrillingly
realized. In the coda the sighing strings are allowed to be
a touch more velvety.
The tension is still there at the beginning of the slow movement
with intense, heavy string sound permitting a more striking
contrast when oboe and flute offer a balmy escape. Further relief
comes in the lovely, seamless singing line of the solos from
oboe and clarinet. There remains a steely quality to the strings
whose statements of comfort still have a careworn perspective.
They become more lilting towards the closing section with its
sweet violin solo and smooth doubling horn judiciously balanced
before a finely sustained violin solo ending. The third movement
intermezzo is wonderfully assured. At its outer edges Barenboim
secures a lovely clarity of line: all is smooth, light and comely.
The second section (65:45) is more urgent, the trio (66:22)
more sombre and portentous before a benevolently pastoral close.
On DVD you can see how controlled by Barenboim this is but it
sounds quite free.
The finale has a caring, expressive opening followed by neat
contrasting of capricious pizzicato and grave arco
strings before an edgily passionate horn solo. The big
string tune is rich-grained and flowing, yet this is a movement
of many contrasts. It’s all nicely detailed by Barenboim with
flexibility of tempo and dynamic but never allowed to halt the
overall burning progression. Two examples that made Barenboim
himself smile in appreciation: the touches of portamento
from sunny, Viennese style violins from 83:18 and the Mendelssohnian
texture of soft tremolando strings against ascending
then descending wind from 84:54.
Here then are interpretations of considerable substance in a
Blu-Ray Disc which has superb crispness of picture and clarity
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.