Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827) Seven Variations in E flat major on theme Bei Männern, welche Liebe fühlen from the opera The Magic Flute by Mozart for cello and piano, WoO 46 (1801) [9:43]
Kreutzer Sonata in A major, Op.47 (1802-03), arr. for cello and piano by Karl Czerny [40:50]
Sonata in D major for cello and piano, Op.102 No.2 (1815) [21:03]
Ivan Monighetti (cello), Pavel Gililov (piano)
rec. September 2008, Witold Lutoslawski Polish Radio Concert Studio, Warsaw. DDD
DUX 0704 [71:37]
Beethoven’s music can serve as the basis for the perfect “motivation
tape”. This disc will surely raise your spirits. The music is
full of optimism, and this performance is fittingly buoyant.
Monighetti and Gililov present a high-voltage reading from two
strong voices: Gililov’s piano sound is round and concentrated,
Monighetti’s cello is generous and radiant. Intonation is characterised
by a sense of natural breathing and perfect articulation.
The disc opens with the Bei Männern Variations. The composer
is as inventive as ever, and the music is bright and diverse.
The more transparent pages are Mozartean – Classical, not Romantic.
But the stubborn, Ländlerish stomp of the final variation is
unmistakably Beethoven. The musicians play with lively tempi
and faultless balance.
Karl Czerny arranged the Kreutzer for cello – and we
get a bloody good cello sonata! The difference is apparent,
especially in the first movement, which is no longer as hysterical
as the original. Boy, I miss those desperate shrieks from the
violin! The cello pictures a sea storm, while the violin had
the storm rising to the skies. If in the original version the
violin usurped absolute power, here the piano part is the one
with the higher pitch, and has greater prominence. In the slow
movement the cello part is rather elevated so it loses little
in the way of innocent “larkishness”. What the cello can give
in return are its warmth and depth, and of these Monighetti
shares plenty. The cello is also a more suitable accompanist,
when the piano takes the leading role. The viscous slow variation
is marvelous, and the quiet afterglow of the last variation
is magical. I don’t see a significant variance from the violin
version in the last movement – a happy, unstoppable tarantella.
The first movement of Beethoven’s Fifth Cello Sonata
is heroic and gallant. That’s the kind of music that Strauss
in Don Quixote called “a knightly theme”. The
second movement, the only real slow complete episode in Beethoven’s
cello sonatas, is marked Adagio con molto sentimento d’affetto,
and with good reason. It is lugubrious, yet with a feeling of
acceptance. It is similar to the slow movements of Beethoven’s
last piano sonatas, but also to another Adagio affettuoso
- the sad slow movement of the First Quartet. In contrast,
the last movement sounds a bit lacking in emotion. Its intricate
fugal development gives more to the brain than to the heart
– maybe the performers could add something here. Anyway, it
is not so long as to become boring.
The disc is very well recorded, and the cello sound is admirably
clean. The liner-note in Polish and English contains an interesting
essay on the three works, although I suspect that some of the
logic was lost in translation.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.