Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Jean Xavier LEFEVRE (1763-1829)
Clarinet Quartet V in E flat [15:45]
Clarinet Quartet VI in B flat [16:30]
Clarinet Sonata in B flat, op.12 no.1 (c.1805) [9:20]
Clarinet Sonata in E flat, op.12 no.2 (c.1805) [10:08]
Clarinet Sonata in B flat, op.12 no.3 (c.1805) [8:40]
Eduard Brunner (clarinet)
Ana Chumachenco (violin); Hariolf Schlichtig (viola); Wen-Sinn Yang
(cello); Adrian Oetiker (piano)
rec. Musikhochschule, Munich, March-June 2005 (Quartets), January
2007 (Sonatas). DDD
TUDOR 7150 [61:05]
As the fine essay in the CD booklet explains, Lefèvre was a
very conservative composer; in some respects he was less a composer
than a clarinettist and pedagogue who wrote music to elaborate
his teachings. In fact, he retired from composing well before
he turned fifty, already having said what he wanted to say,
with a body of works that included seven clarinet concertos,
21 clarinet sonatas, and over 150 clarinet duos, mostly for
Lefèvre's innovations lay in technique, rather than music. It
would be wrong, therefore, to come to this disc expecting to
hear the fireworks associated with Weber, for example. What
you get instead are a series of expressive, graceful, beautifully
crafted miniatures - most of the individual movements are only
two or three minutes long, with the rondo finale of the op.
12 no.1 Sonata lasting a little over a minute. There is elegance,
wistfulness, restraint and humour in abundance, all in accordance
with the principles Lefèvre expounded in his widely published
and far-reaching method.
The Clarinet Quartets are the more substantial works.
Lefèvre wrote them for clarinet, violin, viola and, rather quaintly,
basso - here supplied by Wen-Sinn Yang's able cello. They are
reminiscent of those of Krommer and Crusell, and - allowing
for the change of instrument - the flute quartets of Hoffmeister,
all of whom are approximate contemporaries - Crusell was in
fact a pupil of Lefèvre's, such was the latter's reputation.
The op. 12 works were published as Three Grand Sonatas around
1805, and were composed for clarinet and, again, continuo, played
and partly improvised here on the piano by Adrian Oetiker.
A hugely experienced, multinational cast of musicians has been
assembled for this disc, and it is difficult to fault any of
their playing, either individually or as an ensemble. The recording
is very good, although the clarinet keys do clatter a bit at
times, and Brunner does take quite extravagant breaths in places;
both noises are particularly noticeable in the sonatas.
Tudor have previously released Lefèvre's four other extant clarinet
quartets - reviewed
here - , as well as three of the seven clarinet concertos
(Tudor 7098). Together with this disc they give a fine overview
of an interesting musician.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.