(b. 1939) The Angels for unaccompanied choir (1994) [5.03] Ashes Dance Back for choir and electronics (1997) [17.25] Marahi for unaccompanied choir (1999) [10.26] The Summer’s Cloud’s awakening for choir, flute,
cello and electronics (2001) [30.53]
Jonathan Harvey (electronics); Clive Williamson (synthesiser); Ilona
Meija (flute); Arne Deforce (cello)
Latvian Radio Choir/Kaspars Putnins (The Angels), James Wood
rec. 19 April 2005, St. Saviour’s Church, Riga (The Angels);
live, St. John’s Church, Riga, 1 November 2008
HYPERION CDA67835 [63.43]
The archetypal Jonathan Harvey piece mixes voices with electronics,
and that is not surprising. He was, after all, a choirboy at
the long defunct St. Michael’s Tenbury Wells. His own
son was in the choir at Winchester Cathedral. It was for his
son’s voice that he wrote ‘Motuos Plango’
in 1980 employing the great tolling bell of Winchester Cathedral
and using computer manipulation techniques. Even, quite often
performed anthems like ‘I Love the Lord’ of 1976
and ‘Come Holy Ghost’ from 1984 have such a distinctively
dense sound using wave formations, constant repetition of phrases
and thick tonal clusters that you feel that the a capella
voices have been treated with an old fashioned ring modulator.
It’s not surprising then that this new disc by the superb
Latvian Radio Choir should include two works for choir and electronics.
It starts more modestly with Harvey’s commission for the
King’s Carol Service of 1994 The Angels
also recorded back in 1995 on excellent ASV disc by The Joyful
Company of Singers (CD DCA 917).
Angels and mysticism are a sort of Harvey ‘thing’
one might say. Here with a text by his late friend Bishop John
Taylor he also uses a wordless choir which provides harmonic
support for a limpid melody shared between the other voices,
now in unison, now in canon. A line or two of Taylor’s
verse sums up the composer’s intentions “Their melody
strides not from bar to bar/but like a painting, hangs there
entire/one chord of limitless communication”. It’s
worth following the beautiful text whilst listening, as it can
sometimes get lost in the thick miasmic texture.
Jonathan Harvey has the ability to draw pre-eminent parts from
several religions or sects and channel these both musically
and spiritually. We can hear this in the Anglican tradition,
as in the anthems mentioned above, the Roman Catholicism of
his massive ‘Madonna of Winter and Spring’ of 1986
and Buddhism, which has always fascinated him. We find quite
abhorrent images on our TV screens of Buddhist monks burning
themselves to death but there is an element in Buddhism, of
giving ourselves back to the elements from which we emerged.
These elements play a major role in the next work, Ashes
Dance Back. Michael Downes’ excellent enclosed
notes tell us that the work “realizes the idea of the
‘self’ - represented metaphorically by the choir
- to the elements of wind, fire and water”. He goes on
later: “Harvey processed sounds of wind, fire and water
through a computer analysis of choral sounds producing a recording
that blends almost seamlessly with the sound and creates the
illusion that the elements themselves are singing.” From
time to time the ‘elemental’ sound is clearly audible
and at the others just fragments of the text. The Indian poet
Rumi is used in a beautiful translation by poet Andrew Harvey.
I quote “ I burn away: laugh; my ashes are alive!/I die
a thousand times/my ashes dance back/A thousand new faces”.
It is an emotional and spiritual exercise listening to this
work as it often is with Harvey but the journey is certainly
We are also told that Ashes Dance Back, although continuous,
can be heard to be in three movements. For this forlorn listener
Hyperion might have been more helpful and tracked the work accordingly.
Had the done so the structure, which is difficult to grasp if
it exists at all, might then have been more clearly elucidated.
Although Marahi is only ten minutes in duration,
it has the longest text (all texts are given clearly and translated).
It is in Latin, Sanskrit with spoken sections in English. Texts
in honour of the Virgin and of the Buddha are inter-mixed very
directly. These encapsulate Harvey’s beliefs and background.
At one point the composer asks the voices to make animal noises.
These are performed here most successfully and believably. These
are included because Harvey’s wants to “suggest
the interdependency of different acts of creation”. The
whole work attempts to demonstrate “the continuity between
Christian and Buddhist beliefs”. The performance is striking
although the spoke English is not always clear.
The last work The Summer Cloud’s Awakening
is also the longest. To the choir and the electronics Harvey
adds a flute and a cello. This work has a very short text: two
in fact by Buddha Shakyamuni. It is one of his most extraordinary
scores and reveals a world of stasis and spiritual depth almost
beyond the experience of western religious comprehension. It
was composed for James Wood. In addition to the Buddhist text
sung in the English - given in translation in the booklet -
there are also musical quotes from Wagner’s ‘Tristan
und Isolde’. The famous chord drifts periodically across
the texture as well as other motifs. The music is not all mystery:
there are some faster and more ‘focused’ passages.
These ideas were to build into his 2006 opera ‘Wagner
Dream’. In these works there is a fascination with human
suffering brought about by human desire. To explain the music
would be ridiculous. You simple must buy the disc to draw your
own conclusions. You will either consider it a masterwork or
crass and pretentious.
I’m not sure why Hyperion has taken three years to get
this disc onto the market but it has been worth it. There are
some significant and fascinating pieces here. The recording
is ideal with balance and engineering of demonstration class.
The performances committed, stunning and seemingly flawless.
Well worth investing in.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.