Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Ikon II Nickolay GOLOVANOV(1891-1958)
Our Father Op. 9 No. 3 [3:41] Pavel CHESNOKOV(1877-1944)
Salvation is created Op. 25, No 5 [2:47]
Let my prayer arise Op 24 No 6 [6:09]
Let thy good spirit Op. 25 No 10 [2:13]
Bless the Lord, O my soul [2:42]
Rejoice in the Lord, O you righteous Op. 25 No 6 [2:07]
All of creation rejoices in you Op. 15 No 11 [3:39]
We have no other help Op. 25 No 8 [2:11] Aleksandr GRECHANINOV(1864-1956)
Of thy mystical supper Op. 58 No 7 [5:09] Konstantin SHVEDOV(1886-1954)
The Cherubic Hymn Op. 13 [4:49]
The Thrice-Holy Op. 7 [3:14] Pyotr TCHAIKOVSKY(1840-1893)
Come, let us worship - from Op. 41 [2:15] Victor KALINNIKOV(1870-1927)
Come, let us worship Op 11 [1:04]
We hymn thee Op. 7 [1:31]
Rejoice, O Virgin Op. 17 [1:10]
We hymn thee Op. 2 [1:49] Nikolay TOLSTIAKOV(1883-1958)
Bless the Lord, O my soul Op 1, No 1 [3:16] Nikolai RIMSKY-KORSAKOV(1844-1908)
Our Father Op. 22 No 7 [2:01] Sergei RACHMANINOV(1873-1943)
Rejoice, O Virgin Op. 37 No 6 [3:09] Mili BALAKIREV(1837-1910)
Let all mortal flesh keep silence [5:17] Aleksandr KASTALSKY(1856-1926)
Radiant Light Op. 73 [2:51] César CUI(1835-1918)
Song of the Most Holy Theotokos (Magnificat) [8:17]
Holst Singers/Stephen Layton
rec. 8-11 January, 2010, All Hallows, Gospel Oak, London DDD
Russian texts (transliterated) and English translations included
Samples HYPERION CDA67756 [71:35]
This is follow-up to the same artists’ excellent and stimulating
disc entitled Ikon (CDA66928). A long time has elapsed
since that first CD, which was made as far back as 1996, and
which I acquired at the time. The content of the first programme
was rather different from what’s on offer this time around.
The original recital included pieces by Tchaikovsky and a couple
by Grechaninov but for the most part more modern composers such
as Georgy Sviridov (b. 1915), Arvo Pärt and Henryk Górecki
took the compositional honours. This time Stephen Layton has
chosen a good deal of music by composers who were linked to
Moscow’s Synodal School of Church Singing and whose musical
output was primarily - and in some cases exclusively - liturgical.
He’s interspersed their music with liturgical pieces by
some of the major Russian composers, best known for their secular
The offerings by Rachmaninov - a well-known excerpt from his
All Night Vigil - and Tchaikovsky will be familiar to
many collectors. For the rest, however, I suspect that few people
other than specialist collectors - and members of the Orthodox
Church - will know this music. It’s fascinating to hear
liturgical works by composers such as Rimsky - his setting of
The Lord’s Prayer is simple, direct and touching.
And what a contrast between this sincere small-scale piece and
the vibrantly colourful orchestral scores of his to which we’re
so accustomed! Cui’s Magnificat, which closes the
programme, is a fascinating work. The music is elaborate and
dramatic by comparison with much of the remainder of the programme.
Ivan Moody suggests in his most interesting notes that the piece
has more of the concert hall than the church about it. It’s
an ambitious and impressive composition.
I freely confess that I’ve not even heard of several of
the composers represented here, let alone heard their music.
I have come across Grechaninov’s music before, most notably
his moving Passion Week (review).
Here, Layton and his choir offer his Of thy mystical supper,
a very beautiful setting of the communion hymn for Holy Thursday.
This is very devotional music and the Holst Singers do it really
well, their performance culminating in rapt singing of the repeated
word ‘Aliluiya’ at the end.
Pavel Chesnokov is represented by several pieces. The melodic
interest in Let myprayer arise is given to an
alto solo - in this performance all the altos of the choir sing
the line. Layton’s altos respond with fervent singing
while the rest of the choir surround their line with dark-hued
choral textures. All of the Chesnokov pieces in this programme
are beautifully crafted and receive polished performances.
It may be objected that an English choir can’t match the
Slavonic timbres but I must say that the Holst Singers do a
very convincing job throughout, It’s some forty years
since I acquired a smattering of Russian - now largely forgotten
- so I can’t claim any real degree of expertise with the
language but it sounds to me as if their Russian pronunciation
is good. There can be no complaints about the tone they produce
- still less about the sheer quality of the singing. And while
no doubt a Russian choir would produce even more authentic-sounding
performances - though perhaps not so skilled and sensitive -
I don’t feel in the slightest short-changed by the singing
on offer here. To see what I mean sample Kalinnikov’s
Rejoice, O Virgin (‘Bogoroditse Devo’)
and hear how the choir’s deep, tolling bass voices underpin
the choral textures magnificently.
The most celebrated piece on the programme is Rachmaninov’s
wonderful setting of the selfsame text. Layton and his singers
deliver a wonderful, rapt account of this music, which they
build to a majestic climax.
This is largely music that’s off the beaten track as far
as most Western collectors will be concerned. But, unfamiliar
as it may be it’s also very rewarding to hear. The quality
of the music is high and the quality of the performances is,
if anything, higher still. Stephen Layton has obviously prepared
his fine choir superbly for this assignment and they deliver
superb, sonorous and idiomatic performances. The Hyperion engineers
have played a full part by capturing the singing in atmospheric,
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.