One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

Some items
to consider

in the first division

extraordinary by any standards

An excellent disc

a new benchmark

summation of a lifetime’s experience.

Piano Concertos 1 and 2
Surprise Best Seller and now

A Garland for John McCabe


DIETHELM Symphonies

The best Rite of Spring in Years

BACH Magnificat

Brian Symphs 8, 21, 26

Just enjoy it!

La Mer Ticciati








Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical

Nimbus Podcast

Obtain 10% discount

Special offer 50% off

Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
(THE Polish label)
Altus 10% off
Atoll 10% off
CRD 10% off
Hallé 10% off
Lyrita 10% off
Nimbus 10% off
Nimbus Alliance
Prima voce 10% off
Red Priest 10% off
Retrospective 10% off
Saydisc 10% off
Sterling 10% off

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Senior Editor
John Quinn
Seen & Heard
Editor Emeritus
   Bill Kenny
Editor in Chief
MusicWeb Webmaster
   David Barker
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


cover image

CD: AmazonUK AmazonUS

Classical Legends In Their Own Words
See below review for full track list
EMI CLASSICS 6 08972 2 [4 CDs: 79:28 + 79:26 + 79:44 + 79:37]

Experience Classicsonline

I occasionally run through all-time sports elevens, or fifteens. Or compile the ultimate concerto performance, real or imagined. Brahms conducting Joachim for example, captured in-house. Or maybe, thinking of symphonies, Dvorák conducting his own Seventh Symphony. I don’t go back much before 1870, but there’s plenty of mileage there. One thing I also imagine is a compilation disc of musicians talking about their lives and careers. Majoring in string players I take in Kreisler’s (real) 75th birthday speech, some Heifetz, being laconic. Both exist and have been released commercially. But what did Huberman sound like, or Thibaud, or Busch, or Sammons? Was Kulenkampff Hanseatically witty? Did Maud Powell speak recognisable Illinois? Was Jaroslav Kocian’s accent hard? Did Kochanski lisp?

Back in the early 1940s as War raged the BBC ran a series of radio programmes devoted to just this idea. A leading musician would be invited to the studio, would have a (scripted) conversation with an interlocutor, and would then play a movement from a sonata or some such. Lionel Tertis went along, and Sammons too when he essayed the slow movement of John Ireland’s Second Sonata with the composer. No evidence now exists of these programmes.

This four disc set fits comfortably into this existing pattern. A musician is interviewed, recordings are played, a character or composer or work is analysed, sometimes briefly; a portrait emerges. The words ‘EMI’ appear so often in the narration that one becomes resistant to presumed product puffing. But I’m prepared to let such things go. For the sake of the preservation of the interviews and the concept in general I’m even prepared not to go to war over the overused words ‘legend’ and ‘legendary’ – is Kissin really a legend? Is John Tomlinson? Angela Gheorghiu? Pappano? Come to that are any of these singers and instrumentalists really legendary? Would Di Stefano describe himself as a ‘legend’?

Enough of the business of promotion and puffing-up, of flogging a product: the idea seems to me sound to preserve the speaking voices of important musicians. You never know how important a musician will be in years ahead. I’m all for preservation and archiving.

Jon Tolansky is the interviewer. The tracks are in the main brief; editing ensures we hear the musician in the main, though we do obviously hear some of Tolansky’s questions. He is heard extensively in the narration tracks. These cover motivations and plot developments in the extracts to be heard from EMI recordings, or biographical detail. This has clearly been deemed necessary to create a self contained unit, an experience with a context – and not just snippets of people talking. It’s not the same therefore as the British Library’s recent releases devoted to poets and writers giving broadcasts. These are heard within the context of the writer’s other broadcasts. Here, with music, one can broaden the experience, though I should think most people reading this would skip many of these tracks, and I dare say they might skip some of the music tracks as well.

My main focus is on the musicians’ own words. Freni for example was ‘prudent’ with her voice when young. She learned Nanetta in three days flat ‘but I was young’, she adds with a laugh. Giulini was thoughtful, Karajan thorough. Grace Bumbry tells of her church beginnings, a recurrent theme, and the influence of Lotte Lehmann. Students ‘depend too much on CDs’ and they need instead to get down to the score. With Vickers one feared for one’s life, he was ‘so real – but perfectly timed’. Things do indeed come alive with Vickers who gets a correspondingly larger whack of disc time. Not surprising really as he’s a riveting chap to listen to. He too had a church background, though he sang in prisons and asylums (not that he was incarcerated, you understand), and worked for Woolworth. His encounter with David Webster of Covent Garden is recounted with relish. He mentions a debt of gratitude to Edward Downes, and especially to Herman Geiger-Torel, who taught him how to inhabit an operatic role; talks too of the famous Trojans production and his subsequent international stardom. Most contemporary opera singers bore Vickers; they don’t ‘reveal’ the person they seek to impersonate, rather they get in the way. Frankly I could listen to JV for hours.

A more obviously emollient singer is the personable Nicolai Gedda. Humorous, affable, linguistically marvellous, he admits he was scared stiff when young. He pays his own dues – to Kurt Bendix amongst others. The Italian School is the one for him and his admiration for Schipa, for example, is vast. Indeed of all the singers here his appreciation of eminent predecessors seems the most acutely developed, though Fischer-Dieskau is no slouch either. Amongst that group Gedda nominates Suthaus in Wagner. He is also acute on language distinctions, noting that the ‘strange’ nasality of much French singing is a result of the language itself. He was a melancholic young man, unhappy, and a dreamer; he identified most with Lensky and Werther. Gedda’s the one I’d most like to spend an hour with, talking of the past and hopes for the future.

Di Stefano’s interview is not in as good quality as the others. I assume it took place al fresco as there are obvious noises off, not unpleasantly so. I imagine him with a glass of wine reflecting on his life - albeit he does so briefly. As all the interviews are in English it’s those whose command is less fluent that are the shortest. Di Stefano insists that ‘the drama comes before the music’ and asserts that ‘I sing the words, the feeling’. The ability to communicate with an audience is the primary concern; he touches briefly on Callas.

Gheorghiu and Alagna are heard in disc one and two respectively. She talks about character-driven development and about early life in Ceausescu’s Romania. He talks of his early love of Sicilian song, of cabaret and the strong feeling he still possesses for the lighter side of things. Inevitably the young guns are of less compelling interest. Ruggero Raimondi, from Bologna, like Verdi, talks finely and acutely about Filippo II and his singing and acting of the role. What kind of man was he, is the question, operatically speaking and Raimondi shows how well developed is his awareness of the problem and its best solution. John Tomlinson is equally convincing, at greater length, on Duke Bluebeard. In fact his analysis – madness and alienation, and the function of compassion both in this work and an allied one such as The Flying Dutchman makes one stop and think. Bluff though he appears, Tomlinson’s lexicon is profound. He too had a chapel background. He is honest about his early struggles; his voice had no top. He pays tribute to his teacher Patrick McGuigan. This feature is a constant one and shows the lasting, fundamental value of a good coach to young singers.

Fischer-Dieskau cites Rudolf Bockelman as an inspiration. Ludwig too was admired. Fischer-Dieskau’s famously precocious Winterreise (he was 16) is duly noted. There is a brief analysis of Wolf. One wishes there were more of his speaking voice. He is followed by Antonio Pappano who is something of an in-house EMI opera conductor, as well as an orchestral one and a fine pianist too. Crucially he knows all about the voice, via his father and his own studies. He cites the importance, the primacy indeed of ‘the general rhythm of the words’ which dictates so many things, not least tempo. He is good on the explosive nature of Italian religiosity and fear. There are two instrumentalists to complete the set. To be frank I wish this had been an all-vocal box (Pappano included for his insights – maybe) and Rostropovich and Kissin excluded. Kissin’s statuesque conversational style is too clipped to be revealing. His problems with Beethoven are ‘spiritual’ and he feels for the composer ‘love without reciprocation’, which is a neat summary. The familiar tones of Rostropovich – like Menuhin and Tortelier, also of EMI’s stable, one hardly believes he’s dead – talk of his father’s terrible death when the young cellist was 14. Shostakovich’s famous insult to a musician – you’re a ‘mezzo fortist’ - is here. It means an avoidance of dynamic extremes, and the composer apparently loathed timidity in these matters. But the thing of which Rostropovich was most proud in his life? Not his musical memories, not his premieres or honours or awards; it was his latter to Pravda. ‘I have a clean conscience’.

Nevertheless these instrumentalists do feel like a sop to try to round out the box. Why not keep it an all-singers box and do something similar with instrumentalists? I noted my own archival interest in recorded voices. I don’t know how generally this is shared. I can say that the words and music aspect has been well attended to and if there is a deal of self-promotion by EMI then that’s the name of the game.

Jonathan Woolf

Full tracklist
CD 1
Introductory Announcement -Jon Tolansky [0:23]
Madama Butterfly: Un Bel Di (Extract) - Che Tua Madre (Extract)
Angela Gheorghiu/Antonio Pappano/Orchestra dell' Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Roma [6:16]
Narration 1 - Angela Gheorghiu/Jon Tolansky [1:42]
Carmen: La La La La (Extract With Voice Over) - Angela Gheorghiu/Michel Plasson/Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse [[3:01]
Narration 2 -Angela Gheorghiu/Jon Tolansky [0:45]
Early Life And Formative Years - Angela Gheorghiu/Jon Tolansky [5:40]
La Bohème: Si, Mi Chiamano (Extract With Voiceover) - Angela Gheorghiu/Orchestra Sinfonica di Milano Giuseppe Verdi/Anton Coppola [5:02]
Narration 3 - Angela Gheorghiu/Jon Tolansky [2:06]
Manon: N'est Ce Plus Ma Main (With Voiceover) - Angela Gheorghiu/Roberto Alagna/Orchestre Symphonique de la Monnaie/Antonio Pappano [7:41]
Narration 4 - Angela Gheorghiu/Jon Tolansky [1:11]
Aida (1986 Digital Remaster): O Patria Mia –Mirella Freni/Wiener Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan [2:48]
Narration 1 -Mirella Freni/Jon Tolansky [1:27]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Jon Tolansky/Mirella Freni [5:25]
Narration 2 -Mirella Freni/Jon Tolansky [0:45]
La Bohème: Sono Andati (With Voice Over) - Thomas Schippers/Coro del Teatro dell'Opera, Roma/Mirella Freni/Nicolai Gedda [6:59]
Narration 3- Mirella Freni/Jon Tolansky [1:16]
Otello: Ave Maria (With Voice Over) -Mirella Freni/Berliner Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan [6:00]
Narration 4 -Mirella Freni/Jon Tolansky [1:10]
Carmen: Les Tringles Des Sistres Tintaient (Extract) - Grace Bumbry/Orchestre De L'Opéra National De Paris/Rafael Frühbeck De Burgos [0:43]
Narration 1 -Jon Tolansky/Grace Bumbry [2:04]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Jon Tolansky/Grace Bumbry [6:39]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Grace Bumbry [0:58]
Carmen: Habanera (Extract With Voice Over) -Grace Bumbry/Rafael Frühbeck de Burgos/Orchestre de l'Opéra National de Paris [3:16]
Narration 3 -Jon Tolansky/Grace Bumbry [1:37]
Interview: On Singing With Jon Vickers - Grace Bumbry/Jon Tolansky [4:22]
CD 2
Fidelio: Gott! Welch Dunkel Hier (Extract With Voice Over) - Jon Vickers/Philharmonia Orchestra/Otto Klemperer [2:24]
Narration 1 -Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [3:02]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years- Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [9:01]
Samson Et Dalila (2001 Digital Remaster), Act I, Scene 2: Israël! Romps Ta Chaîne (Samson/Les Hébreux) -Georges Prêtre/Choeurs René Duclos/Choeurs et Orchestre de l'Opéra National de Paris [1:19]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [1:21]
Interview: Studying Oratorio And Opera - Jon Vickers/Jon Tolansky [4:11]
Otello: Gia Nella Notte (Extract With Voice Over) - Jon Vickers/Mirella Freni/Berliner Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan [1:11]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [1:55]
Otello: Ah! Mille Vite...Si, Pel Ciel - Il Fazzoletto (Extract With Voice Over)
Jon Vickers/Mirella Freni/Peter Glossop/Berliner Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan [4:14]
Narration 4 - Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [1:46]
Otello: Chi È Là? Otello? (Extract With Voice Over) - Jon Vickers/Mirella Freni/Berliner Philharmoniker/Herbert von Karajan [4:38]
Narration 5 - Jon Tolansky/Jon Vickers [1:00]
Rigoletto: La Donna E Mobile, Plus Interview: The Beginning Of His Career And His Stage Debut - Nicolai Gedda/Jon Tolansky [2:05]
Narration 1 -Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [2:59]
Boris Godunov: O, Kak Tomitel'no (Extract With Voice Over) -Orchestre National de la Radiodiffusion Française/Issay Dobroven/Nicolai Gedda [0:39]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [0:53]
Interview: Formative Years And Pinkerton With Callas And Karajan - Nicolai Gedda [4:40]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [0:22]
Le Postillon De Lonjumeau (2001 Digital Remaster): Mes Amis, Écoutez I'histoire (Act 1) - Nicolai Gedda/Orchestre National De La Radiodiffusion Française/Georges Prêtre [3:44]
Narration 4 - Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [0:36]
Wether: Lorsque I'enfant (Extract With Voice Over) - Nicolai Gedda/Orchestre de Paris/Georges Prêtre [1:04]
Narration 5 - Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [0:41]
Interview: Singing Traditions And Schools, And Massenet's Werther - Nicolai Gedda [8:13]
Wether: Traduire...Ah!...Pourqoui Me Réveiller (Extract With Voice Over) -Nicolai Gedda/Orchestre de Paris/Georges Prêtre [3:20]
Narration 6 - Jon Tolansky/Nicolai Gedda [0:43]
Manon: Lo Son Sol (Extract With Voice Over) - Giuseppe Di Stefano/Philharmonia Orchestra/Alberto Erede [0:55]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Giuseppe Di Stefano [1:26]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Jon Tolansky/Giuseppe Di Stefano [1:27]
Narration 2 -Jon Tolansky/Giuseppe Di Stefano [0:56]
Interview: Approach To Opera Performance - Jon Tolansky/Giuseppe Di Stefano [1:13]
La Bohéme: Come Va? (Extract With Voice Over) - Giuseppe Di Stefano/Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, Milano/Antonino Votto [1:04]
Interview: More About Approach To Opera Performance, And Singing With Maria Callas - Jon Tolansky/Giuseppe Di Stefano [2:09]
Un Ballo In Maschera: Non Sai Tu Che Se L'anima Mia (Extract With Voice Over)
Maria Callas/Giuseppe Di Stefano/Orchestra Del Teatro Alla Scala, Milano/Gianandrea Gavazzeni [3:58]
CD 3
La Traviata: Libiamo Ne'Lieti Calici (Extract With Voice Over) - Narration
Roberto Alagna/Berliner Philharmoniker/Claudio Abbado [2:33]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years And Influences - Jon Tolansky/Roberto Alagna [3:03]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Roberto Alagna [3:26]
Il trovatore: Ah, Si Ben Mio - Di Quella Pira (With Voice Overs) - Roberto Alagna/London Voices/London Symphony Orchestra/Antonio Pappano [9:43]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Roberto Alagna [1:32]
Carmen: Carmen, Je Suis Las De Souffrir! (With Voice Over) - Angela Gheorghiu/Roberto Alagna/Thomas Hampson/Inva Mula/Choeur 'Les Elements'/Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse/Michel Plasson [6:02]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Roberto Alagna [0:58]
Macbeth (1999 Digital Remaster): Come Dal Ciel Precipita (Banco)
Ruggero Raimondi/New Philharmonia Orchestra/Riccardo Muti [2:25]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Ruggero Raimondi [2:41]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years, Don Carlo: Ella Giammai M'ao (Extract)
Jon Tolansky/Ruggero Raimondi/Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden/Carlo Maria Giulini [8:50]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Ruggero Raimondi [1:27]
Tosca: Giàmi Struggea L'amor Della Diva! (With Voice Over) - Angela Gheorghiu/Ruggero Raimondi/Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden/Antonio Pappano [4:49]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Ruggero Raimondi [0:56]
Götterdamerung: Hoi-Ho (Extract With Voice Over) - Sir John Tomlinson/Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks/Bernard Haitink [1:11]
Narration 1
Sir John Tomlinson/Jon Tolansky [2:14]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Sir John Tomlinson/Jon Tolansky [5:15]
Narration 2 - Sir John Tomlinson/Jon Tolansky [1:15]
Götterdämmerung: Hier Sitz'Ich Zur Wacht (With Voice Over) - Sir John Tomlinson/Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks/Bernard Haitink [7:07]
Narration 3 - Sir John Tomlinson/Jon Tolansky [1:07]
Bluebeard's Castle: Hajnalban Az Elsöt Leltem - Negyediket Éjjel Leltem
Anne Sofie von Otter/Sir John Tomlinson/Berliner Philharmoniker/Bernard Haitink [13:03]
CD 4:
Die Schöne Müllerin, D. 795 (W. Müller) (1997 Digital Remaster): Wohin?
Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau/Gerald Moore [2:12]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [3:15]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years, And Singing Schubert's Winterreise
Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [2:54]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [0:36]
Winterreise: Gute Nacht (With Voice Over) - Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau/Gerald Moore [5:50]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [2:32]
Interview: Wolf's Lieder - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [0:39]
Narration 4 - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [1:51]
Mörike Lieder (2003 Digital Remaster): Der Feuerreiter - Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau/Gerald Moore [4:57]
Narration 5 - Jon Tolansky/Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau [1:07]
Le Villi: La Tregenda (Act 2, Parte Sinfonica 2) - Antonio Pappano/Roberto Alagna/London Voices/London Symphony Orchestra [3:33]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Antonio Pappano [3:00]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Jon Tolansky/Antonio Pappano [3:32]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Antonio Pappano [1:07]
Requiem Mass: Dies Irase (Extract) - Rex Tremendae (With Voice Over) - Antonio Pappano/Anja Harteros/Sonia Ganassi/Rolando Villazon/René Pape/Orchestra dell' Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Roma/Coro dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia [6:55]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Antonio Pappano [3:09]
Piano Concerto No.3 In C Op.26 (Extract With Voice Over) - Evgeny Kissin/Philharmonia Orchestra/Vladimir Ashkenazy [1:40]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Evgeny Kissin [0:52]
Interview: Early Life And Formative Years - Jon Tolansky/Evgeny Kissin [3:23]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Evgeny Kissin [0:43]
Piano Concerto No. 5 In E Flat Op.73 'Emporer' (Extract With Voice Over) -
Evgeny Kissin/London Symphony Orchestra/Sir Colin Davis [4:16]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Evgeny Kissin [1:15]
Suite No. 1 In G BWV1007: Prelude (Extract With Voice Over) - Mstislav Rostropovich [1:05]
Narration 1 - Jon Tolansky/Mstislav Rostropovich [2:00]
Mstislav Rostropovich Interviewed By Jon Tolansky [Childhood & Early Life]
Mstislav Rostropovich [3:36]
Narration 2 - Jon Tolansky/Mstislav Rostropovich [0:40]
Interview: Memories Of Britten - Cello Suite No.1 Op 72 (Extract With Voice Over)
Mstislav Rostropovich/Jon Tolansky [4:00]
Narration 3 - Jon Tolansky/Mstislav Rostropovich [1:51]
Interview: On Discussing The Music Of Shostakovich With The Composer - Lady Macbeth Of Mtsensk (Extract With Voiceover) - Mstislav Rostropovich/London Philharmonic Orchestra [1:57]
Narration 4 - Jon Tolansky/Mstislav Rostropovich [1:36]
Interview: On Writing A Letter Of Protest To Pravda - Cello Concerto No 2 In G Op.126 (Extract With Voice Over) - Mstislav Rostropovich/Ussr State Symphony Orchestra/Yevgeny Svetlanov/Jon Tolansky [3:20]



Making a Donation to MusicWeb

Writing CD reviews for MWI

About MWI
Who we are, where we have come from and how we do it.

Site Map

How to find a review

How to find articles on MusicWeb
Listed in date order

Review Indexes
   By Label
      Select a label and all reviews are listed in Catalogue order
   By Masterwork
            Links from composer names (eg Sibelius) are to resource pages with links to the review indexes for the individual works as well as other resources.

Themed Review pages

Jazz reviews


      Composer surveys
      Unique to MusicWeb -
a comprehensive listing of all LP and CD recordings of given works
Prepared by Michael Herman

The Collector’s Guide to Gramophone Company Record Labels 1898 - 1925
Howard Friedman

Book Reviews

Complete Books
We have a number of out of print complete books on-line

With Composers, Conductors, Singers, Instumentalists and others
Includes those on the Seen and Heard site


Nostalgia CD reviews

Records Of The Year
Each reviewer is given the opportunity to select the best of the releases

Monthly Best Buys
Recordings of the Month and Bargains of the Month

Arthur Butterworth Writes

An occasional column

Phil Scowcroft's Garlands
British Light Music articles

Classical blogs
A listing of Classical Music Blogs external to MusicWeb International

Reviewers Logs
What they have been listening to for pleasure



Bulletin Board

Give your opinions or seek answers

Pat and present

Helpers invited!

How Did I Miss That?

Currently suspended but there are a lot there with sound clips

Composer Resources

British Composers

British Light Music Composers

Other composers

Film Music (Archive)
Film Music on the Web (Closed in December 2006)

Programme Notes
For concert organizers

External sites
British Music Society
The BBC Proms
Orchestra Sites
Recording Companies & Retailers
Online Music
Agents & Marketing
Other links
Web News sites etc

A pot-pourri of articles

MW Listening Room
MW Office

Advice to Windows Vista users  
Site History  
What they say about us
What we say about us!
Where to get help on the Internet
CD orders By Special Request
Graphics archive
Currency Converter
Web Ring
Translation Service

Rules for potential reviewers :-)
Do Not Go Here!
April Fools

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.