Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
for £16.00 postage paid World-wide.
Sergei RACHMANINOV(1873 - 1943) Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom(1910) [96.11]
Protodeacon - Father Andre Papkov (bass)
Celebrant – David Adams (tenor)
Second Celebrant – Todd E. Berry (bass)
Kansas City Chorale/Charles Bruffy
rec. St. John's Center, Kansas City, Missouri, 12–15 October 1995
NIMBUS NI 5497/8 [41.26 + 53.45]
The Russian Orthodox Church was not as bound up with Russian
classical music as the Roman Catholic and Anglican Churches.
During the 19th century composed music remained central
to both these latter but the Russian Orthodox liturgy relied
solely on traditional chants. In 1878 Tchaikovsky wrote his
Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom, and showed how a contemporary
composer could reinvigorate the traditional liturgy. Tchaikovsky's
setting was not without controversy within the Russian church
and raised a number of debates about what sort of music was
suitable for use within the church. A school of church composition
developed which worked within the accepted canonical forms,
producing both new work and arrangements of traditional chants.
Following Tchaikovsky, a number of composers composed complete
liturgical cycles, including Ippolitov-Ivanov, Gretchaninoff
and Tcherepnin. Whilst Rachmaninov was a student he attended
lectures on Russian chant by Stepan Smolensky, the historian
and chant scholar. At the age of 20, Rachmaninov composed a
sacred concerto on a text for the feast of the Dormition of
the Mother of God. Smolensky was sufficiently impressed with
it to try to persuade Rachmaninov to write more for the church;
Smolensky even offered Rachmaninov a post at the Synodal School
of Church Singing.
It was not until 1910 that Rachmaninov turned his attention
to liturgical music and wrote a setting of the Liturgy of St.
John Chrysostom, the main Eucharistic service of the Russian
Orthodox church. When Rachmaninov's setting was premièred in
1910, it was in a concert by the Moscow Synodal Choir. They
did not perform the work complete but included just the major
hymns. It is not entirely clear whether Rachmaninov intended
the work for liturgical use, but he set not only the major hymns
but all the other parts of the service (litanies, responses)
which are typically sung by a choir.
Rachmaninov was not an expert in liturgical music, so his setting
revisits each text and sets it anew without preconceived ideas
about what was or was not correct form. He would make greater
use of traditional chant in his setting of the All Night Vigil
(the so-called Vespers) which dates from five years later and
this latter work is the greater piece. But Rachmaninov's setting
of the Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom is a notable achievement
and it is profoundly expressive.
The completeness of Rachmaninov's setting gives performers something
of a problem: how much of the priestly and diaconate responses
should be included. Recordings vary; with some giving what is
essentially a selection of the major choral items and others
including the deacon's part to help make sense of the piece,
so that the choir's responses are a response to something.
This disc, recorded in 1995 in Kansas is probably one of the
most complete recordings as it includes not only the deacon
but two celebrants as well. The result is a performance which
approaches liturgical re-construction and as such is very welcome.
This generous approach, though, means that the recording spreads
over two discs.
Not everyone will want to have Rachmaninov's work performed
in such a leisurely fashion. But Father Andre Papkov, who sings
the deacon's role, has an impressive, dark Russian voice and
a supremely compelling way with the chant. He brings dual training
to the role as he not only studied at the New England Conservatory
but serves as Protodeacon in the Russian Orthodox Church. The
two celebrants do not have a Russian Orthodox background and
are members of the Kansas City Chorale.
The idea that we are listening to a service seems to have affected
the recording itself, as the choir is recorded in a rather generous
acoustic, with levels low and quite a bit of distance between
them and the listener. Conductor Charles Bruffy seems to have
been aiming for a performance which approached the mystical.
This is emphasised by the sound quality of the choir; being
an American group they lack the deep sound and dark vowels which
Slav choirs bring to this repertoire. Instead they give us flexibility,
clarity and a nice control of vibrato; all things which might
make this disc appeal to you. But on repeated listening I kept
coming back to the distancing effect of the recording and acoustic.
Rachmaninov wrote strong, romantic music and frankly I want
a performance with more vigour and more presence. This is a
shame. There is a fine, shapely musical account of the work
somewhere in there, but it lacks a dramatic response to Rachmaninov's
The Kansas City Chorale is a 24 person professional choir, based
in Kansas and Charles Bruffy is the musical director - and has
been since 1988.
The CD booklet includes an excellent article by Vladimir Morosan,
the editor of “Sergei Rachmaninov – The Complete Sacred Works”.
The full text of the Liturgy is included, but in English only
and I rather missed having a transliteration of the Russian
This disc recommends itself to those who wish to have a complete
liturgical account of the work. Not everyone will like the way
the recording stretches to two discs. Even if you buy this account
I would recommend getting another version which responds more
positively to the drama and vigour of Rachmaninov's setting.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.