music concerts by Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra.
Mahler 9 Elder
New Lyrita Release
and Cello Concertos
Lyrita New Recording
OF THE MONTH
Ritchie Symphony 4
OF THE MONTH
Seen & Heard
Editor in Chief
Jabuka (The Apple Festival) (1894) [92:19]
Dance Arrangements from Jabuka [46:09]
Strauss Orchestra/Christian Pollack
rec. Delnicky dum, Pozorice, Czech Republic, 28-30 June 2005
and 9 January 2007
NAXOS 8.660216-17 [74:05
Our thoughts naturally
turn to Johann Strauss II at this time. Thanks to the New Yearís
Day concert in Vienna, his waltzes have helped to see in the
New Year for generations. This world premiere recording from
Naxos gives an airing to an extremely rare Strauss operetta.
Itís certainly worth a listen for parts of the disc, though
ironically not for the operetta itself.
Jabuka (The Apple
Festival) had a rather tortured birth. It is set in a fictional
Slavic town, and the very informative booklet notes suggest
that Strauss was influenced in this direction by the staging
of Smetanaís Bartered Bride in Vienna in 1892. However,
the two librettists had different ideas about what form the
piece should take: one wanted a classical operetta while the
other wanted a more serious operatic setting. As a result the
plot is pretty see-through and this probably contributed to
its lapse into obscurity after its successful first performance.
Itís all about disguise, mistakes and a haughty heroine gaining
her comeuppance, but what operetta isnít?
The conductor, Christian
Pollack, is a professor at the Vienna Conservatory. He prepared
the score and assembled the orchestra, and some of his students
sing in the lesser roles. This seems very much a labour of
love for him, and this is apparent in his conducting. He has
an instinctive feel for the natural swing of Straussís rhythms,
and he brings out the colour in the sparkling orchestration
beautifully. This is clearly music that he lives and breathes.
The European Johann Strauss Orchestra was assembled specially
for this recording (most come from the Brno Symphony Orchestra)
and they are the best reason for buying this set. They are
especially attractive in the Dance Arrangements which Strauss
made from the Operetta, included as an appendix on Disc 2.
The chorus are composed of university and high school students,
and unfortunately it shows. They seem remarkably bound to their
seats and their performance never catches fire or taps into
the energy of the piece. They are far too serious for this
light score, and it is almost as if they were singing in a
requiem rather than an operetta.
The solo singing is too
variable. Mirko and Vasil, the two brothers who act as heroes
(sung by Thomas Tischler and Wolfgang Veith), get into the
spirit very well and sing ringingly throughout. Elisabeth Wolfbauer
is also attractive as Annita. In some cases, however, the sound
made by the singers is just plain unpleasant. Veronika Groiss,
who sings the heroine, Jelka, is squally and insecure throughout,
and Franz FŲdinger, who sings Joschko, is out of tune almost
throughout. He acts in the comic role of the court bailiff,
and no doubt Strauss experts would tell me that he is merely
using the Sprechstimme style expected in operettas of Straussís
time, but Iíd rather have tuneful singing, thank-you very much.
While itís normal Naxos practice, it doesnít help that there
are no texts or translations, just a cued plot summary.
It says something that
the best element of this set is the orchestral dances derived
from the operetta. Jabuka is diverting, but it isnít
a patch on Straussís more famous operettas. Stick to Die
Fledermaus and The Gipsy Baron if you want Strauss
on the stage. This recording plugs a gap, however, and we should
be grateful to Naxos for continuing to do such excellent work
in expanding the repertory. Buy it for the dance arrangements:
youíll be whistling them long past New Year.
Gerard Hoffnung CDs
Donate and get a free CD
Follow us on Twitter