Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Niccolò PAGANINI (1782-1840)
Violin Concerto No. 2 in B minor, MS 48, La Campanella (1826)
Violin Concerto No. 4 in D minor, MS 60 (1829-30) [30:42]
Vogtland-Philharmonie, Greiz-Reichenbach/Stefan Fraas
rec. Neuberinhaus Reichenbach/Vogtland, January 2004 EDITION HERA HERA02115 [60:02]
novelty here - the gimmick, if you prefer - is a different Adagio in
the B minor concerto. According to soloist Michael Jelden's
program note, Paganini's manuscript of the solo part includes
both the standard Adagio and a two-line, solo-and-bass
version of this one - in other words, it's not orchestrated,
or even filled out texturally. Jelden has done so, "strictly
following Paganini's annotations in the solo part, in Paganini's
style." He correctly notes that "[t]he character
of the piece is very different from the rest of the concerto," but
it's certainly pleasant enough. Once past a brief introduction
incorporating surprise-symphony effects, the five-and-a-half
minute movement consists mostly of a long, broad cantilena
for the soloist over a pizzicato-based accompaniment, with
brief turbulent outbursts offering contrasts.
gimmick, however, wasn't necessary. Jelden, who apparently
divides his concertizing between virtuoso concerti and modern
works, does a fine job with the solo parts here. His principal
asset is a full, firm-bowed sounding of every note,
no matter how brief in duration -- it struck me as a sort of
violinistic counterpart to Bernard Haitink's conducting --
which ensures that the melodies really sing expressively.
This particularly tells in the central Adagios: that
of the B minor is, for all its simplicity, almost operatically
expansive, while the second theme of the D minor's Adagio
flebile e con sentimento has a lovely searching quality.
Jelden also infuses the 6/8 rhythms in each concerto's final Rondo with
a nice swing and lilt -- these movements aren't just about
the technical fireworks.
the down side, within Jelden's generally accomplished technique,
rapid passages in sixths -- whether arpeggiated or double-stopped
-- prove to be stumbling blocks, in terms of both tone and
intonation. The sequential phrase at 5:43 in the B minor's
first movement, for example, never quite makes it up to pitch;
nor does some of the following cadence. But the similar, lower-lying
passagework at 10:47 is spot-on. And in vaulting upward leaps
and other such bits of target practice, his aim is precise.
have to admit that the provincial-sounding compound name of
the orchestra didn't inspire my confidence - indeed, the 65-member "Vogtland-Philharmonie" turns
out to be an amalgamation of two previously separate, presumably
smaller, orchestras in Greiz and Reichenbach. But I needn't
have worried: the playing is adept and polished. I particularly
enjoyed the full-throated ritornellos, with big, round
brass interjections interrupting that of the D minor. The violins
might be relatively understaffed -- here and there in tutti,
they can't always hold their own against the brasses' harmonies
-- but they're unfailingly well-blended, clear and in tune.
The exposed, unaccompanied phrases that open the D minor are
true, with only the highest notes turning a touch glassy.
engineering is excellent, but the proofreading department fell
down on the job: Paganini's first name is misspelled throughout
-- one "c" for two, and an acute accent for a grave
-- and the English grammar and syntax in Jelden's translation
of his own note could have used editorial intervention.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.