Amadeus MOZART (1756Ė1791) Symphony No.40 in G minor, K550
[24:16] Symphony No.35 in D, Haffner,
K385 [16:14] Symphony No.36 in C, Linz,
Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra/Fritz Reiner (K385 and K550) Chicago Symphony Orchestra/Fritz
Reiner (K425) rec. Pittsburgh 1947, 1946 (K385
and K550); Chicago 1954 (K425); ADD
INSTITUTO DISCOGRAFICO ITALIANO IDIS6537 [63:41]
As can be seen from the recording dates, these will not be ďauthenticĒ
performances insofar as they use a large orchestra, but they will
be authentic performances because they are performances from the
heart, given with fire and spirit. It should also be remembered
that Mozart once said, whether in jest or not I donít know, that
for him the perfect orchestra included forty violins! The first
movement of K550 sets off at a brisk pace and Reiner never drops
the tempo, keeping it in control with a fine sense of line and
style, and repeating the exposition. The only downside is the
huge, and very vulgar, rallentando he employs over the final chords
which spoils an otherwise perfectly judged performance. The slow
movement is lovely; moments of utter simplicity alternate with
high drama, with charming playing, but spoiled by another huge
rallentando at the cadence. The minuet and trio is straight forward
with a delightful transition from minuet to trio, which contains
some gorgeous woodwind playing, and yet another large rallentando
at the end. The finale races away but not with joy, this is Mozart
in G minor, remember, with desperation. This is a fine performance,
especially well judged in tempi, drama and repose. My only objection
is the slowing down at the ends of movements Ė however, I am sure
that when this recording was made, and for some time after, this
was the norm and we never questioned it. Donít let it ruin a fine
The sound for the Haffner Symphony is fierce and hard driven,
and so, I am sad to report, an intelligent performance is spoiled.
Reiner sets a cracking pace for the opening Allegro; it is thrilling
and it is matched by a slow movement of great tenderness but
in this latter the beautiful sound she elicits from the strings
sounds hard edged. The minuet is fast but the trio is fantastic
Ė full of gemŁtlichkeit and with a real dancing lilt.
The finale is a fraction too fast making some of the string
articulation a problem. This is a fine performance, full of
humour and with a great spirit, let down by the recording.
Sometimes itís the small things which tip you off to the quality of
a performance. In this recording of the Linz Symphony
in bars 8, 9 and 10 of the slow introduction of the first movement,
thereís the merest hint of a forte before the music falls
back to piano. Reiner accents these fortes with
such subtlety that I knew I was I for an intelligent performance.
And so I was. The first movement races along at a cracking pace,
joking and full of high spirits. The slow movement is a serene
haven of peace. Here, Reiner withholds full power from the fortes
which gives a much more singing quality to the whole piece.
The Minuet is distinguished by some lovely oboe and bassoon
playing and the finale is taken at a true racing pace Ė a real
Presto and itís thrilling, made all the more exciting by Reiner
not applying the brakes in the final cadence but racing through
it bringing the music to rousing conclusion.
This is a very interesting issue, especially so for students of interpretation.
The recorded sound is of its age, of course, but in the Linz
and 40th Symphony the remastering is excellent,
showing us fine and intelligent Mozartean performances. The
fierceness of the sound in the HaffnerSymphony
can be tempered somewhat with a treble cut, but this does rob
the sound of some of its bloom. Certainly this isnít a disk
of Mozart for everyone but I hope that I have managed to convey
some of the excitement and satisfaction I felt whilst listening.
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.