|
Making
a Donation to MusicWeb
About MWI
Site
Map
More
Reviews
How to find a review
Books
Film
Music
Nostalgia
Records Of The Year
Recommendations
Comment
Arthur Butterworth Writes
Phil
Scowcroft's Garlands
Classical
blogs
Reviewers
Logs
Announcements
Don't
Go Here!
Community
Bulletin Board
Web
Ring
Reviewers
Helpers
invited!
Resources
How
Did I Miss That?
British
Composers
British
Light Music Composers
Other
composers
Indexes
Label
Masterwork
Discographies
Composer
National
Themed
Review pages
Complete Books
Programme
Notes
External sites
British Music Society
The BBC Proms
Performers
Orchestra Sites
Recording Companies & Retailers
Online Music
Agents & Marketing
Publishers
Other links
Newsgroups
Web News sites etc
Editorial
Board
Classical Editor
Rob Barnett
Seen & Heard
Editor and Webmaster
Bill Kenny
MusicWeb Webmaster
Len Mullenger
Assistant Webmaster
David Barker
PotPourri
A
pot-pourri of articles
MW
Listening Room
MW
Office
Helping
MusicWeb
Advice
to Windows Vista users
Questionnaire
Site
History
What
they say about us
What
we say about us!
Where
to get help on the Internet
CD
orders By Special Request
Graphics
archive
Currency
Converter
Dictionary
Magazines
Newsfeed
Web Ring
Translation Service
Rules
for potential reviewers :-)
Do
Not Go Here!
April Fools
|
 |
 |
|
Not
available in the USA
Crotchet
|
Ludwig van BEETHOVEN
(1770-1827)
Piano Concerto No.3 in C minor Op.37 (1800) [35:08]
¹
Carl Maria Von WEBER
(1786-1826)
Konzertstück in F minor Op.79 (1821) [16:16] ²
Piano Sonata No.1 in C major Op.24 (1816) [21:13]
Claudio Arrau
(piano)
Philadelphia Orchestra/Eugene Ormandy
rec. Academy of Music, Philadelphia, December 1947
¹
Chicago Symphony Orchestra/Désiré Defauw
rec. Orchestra Hall, Chicago, April 1946 ²
Weber sonata recorded Victor Studio 2, New York
City, February 1941
NAXOS 8.111263
[72:37]
|
|
The C minor Concerto
performance was given a bit of a roasting in The Record Guide.
The contributors there briefly lambasted Ormandy’s “sentimentalised
and vulgar” conducting before consigning the whole thing to
the out tray of critical taste. Well times change but it’s hard
to see quite what so annoyed the writers regarding Ormandy.
Maybe it was the rather over grazioso string phrasing in the
first movement, something that might then have smacked of Rachmaninovian
excess to more puritan sensibilities. Or maybe it was the balance
between piano and orchestra – not especially well judged – that
skewed critical favour against the performance. However one
views these things Arrau has considerable reserves of power,
and in the finale demonstrates a rather striking balance of
command and caprice when it comes to phraseology. In the slow
movement there is perhaps too much of a patrician reserve. He
avoids, if I can put it this way, quiescent chording – and I
find some of the right hand runs strangely cursory. Not vulgar,
just rather unthinking. So whilst I can’t concur with the adjectival
chorus of disgust evinced by The Record Guide the performance
as a whole strikes me as oddly unsatisfying and not properly
thought-through. I will say that Mark Obert-Thorn has tamed
the fierce treble - the highs are still there and it’s still
not altogether comfortable but there’s certainly a richer, mellower
string tone now.
The Weber Konzertstück
was recorded a year earlier than the Beethoven. The accompanist
was Désiré Defauw whose performance here is usually written
off. Defauw was a good musician – violinist and conductor –
but he wasn’t helped by the recording which was very cloudy,
a problem that Obert-Thorn has sought to address in his transfer,
and by his own rather stolid approach. Arrau always remembered
a pre-War performance of the work given in Berlin by Schnabel
– played beautifully he added – and it was a work Arrau kept
in his repertoire until the end, by which time his work-list
had shrunk to Thibaud-like parsimony. Arrau’s articulation has
a bejewelled beauty to it, despite the limitations of the recording,
and a ripe aplomb in the finale. The Sonata was Arrau’s first
American studio recording. It was boxy, sounding rather like
some of those pre-war Parisian ones, and pressed on inferior
wartime shellac, but the playing is vital and communicative.
The transfers as
noted seek to address inherent recording limitations in a variety
of ways – stiffening the bass, cushioning boxy, unreverberant
acoustics, trying to clarify muddied frequencies and ensuring
pitch correction. It’s all been most sensitively done.
Jonathan Woolf
see also Review
by Colin Clarke
|
|
Advertising
Rates
Visitor
stats
MusicWeb
International
has over 25,000 Classical CD reviews on offer
Gerard
Hoffnung Concerts &
The
Bricklayer Story

New
Releases

New
Releases




MusicWeb
sells the Polish
catalogue CDAccord
£10.50 post free W-W

MusicWeb sells the
Arcodiva catalogue
£12.00 post free W-W

£11.50
post-free world-wide
Try
it and see - Sale or Return
MusicWeb
can now offer you discs from the following catalogues:
Prices include postage
Musicweb
Special
Offers
Google Ads - for information about privacy matters, click here.
|