Cesare Siepi 
                  Giuseppe VERDI 
                  (1813–1901) 
                  Ernani: 
                  1. Infelice! e tu credevi [3:39] 
                  
                  Nabucco: 
                  2. Tu sul labbro dei veggenti 
                  [4:54] 
                  Arrigo BOITO 
                  (1842–1918) 
                  Mefistofele: 
                  3. So lo Spirito che nega [3:07] 
                  
                  Giuseppe VERDI 
                  I vespri Siciliani: 
                  4. O tu, Palermo [4:18] 
                  Don Carlo: 
                  5. Ella giammai m’amo! [8:12] 
                  
                  Amilcare PONCHIELLI 
                  (1834–1886) 
                  La Gioconda: 
                  6. Si, morir ella de’ [4:38] 
                  
                  Vincenzo BELLINI 
                  (1801–1835) 
                  La sonnambula: 
                  7. Vi ravviso [3:03] 
                  Gioacchino ROSSINI 
                  (1792–1868) 
                  L’Italiana in Algeri: 
                  8. Le femmine d’Italia [3:22] 
                  
                  Il barbiere di Siviglia: 
                  9, La calunnia [4:22] 
                  Wolfgang Amadeus 
                  MOZART (1756–1791) 
                  Don Giovanni: 
                  10. Deh vieni alla finestra 
                  [2:16] 
                  Paolo TOSTI 
                  (1846–1916) 
                  11. L’ultima canzone [4:41] 
                  
                  12. Non t’amo più [4:46] 
                  
                  13. Malia [3:08] 
                  Luigi DENZA 
                  (1846–1922) 
                  14. Occhi di fata [3:23] 
                  Paolo TOSTI 
                  15. Serenata [3:17] 
                  Augusto ROTOLI 
                  (1847–1904) 
                  16. Mi sposa sara la mia bandiera 
                  [4:56] 
                  Renato BROGEI 
                  (1873–1924) 
                  17. Visione Veneziana [3:34] 
                  
                  Vincenzo BILLI 
                  (1869–1938) 
                  18. E canta il grillo [3:12] 
                  
                  Cesare Siepi (bass) 
                
                This is a disarmingly 
                  fine selection of early Siepi recordings 
                  made between 1947 and 1948, the earliest 
                  of them when the bass was only twenty-four. 
                  They show an almost fully formed artist 
                  with a powerfully, resonantly deployed 
                  voice, still perhaps a touch unsupported 
                  in the very lowest register but nevertheless 
                  of exceptional quality. An added pleasure 
                  is to encounter some of these none-too-easy 
                  to locate Cetras and especially so 
                  in such good nick. Though they date 
                  from the early post War years several 
                  of the 78s are harder to find than 
                  one might suppose. 
                
                Sonorous, controlled, 
                  eloquent – all words that came to 
                  mind as one listens to the first track, 
                  the extract from Ernani. The eighteen 
                  sides are not presented chronologically 
                  so we have to measure one’s judgement 
                  in the knowledge that, say, the Don 
                  Carlo and I Vespri Siciliani 
                  arias precede those from Ernani 
                  and Nabucco in the chronological 
                  run of things. The fifteen months 
                  between the earliest 1947 sessions 
                  and the October 1948 ones do show 
                  a perceptible technical advance. But 
                  even in that earlier stage, with his 
                  saturnine Mefistofele aria, 
                  we encounter the powerful sense of 
                  characterisation, the adept lightening 
                  of tone, the personable impersonation, 
                  that remained such intense features 
                  of his singing.
                
                Note too his prudence 
                  and tact in O tu, Palermo, 
                  the aria from I Vespri Siciliani 
                  – nothing exaggerated here, full of 
                  serious command. Given his minimal 
                  training the assurance is really rather 
                  astonishing. So too the gripping Don 
                  Carlo – in which he marries command 
                  of textual nuance with theatrical 
                  perception; perhaps, to be super critical, 
                  there is not quite the last ounce 
                  of characterisation but it’s a close 
                  run thing. His Bellini is elegantly 
                  phrased and his Rossini is predictably 
                  engrossing – suave humour enlivens 
                  his approach and he’s a stylishly 
                  natural Rossinian. His famous Mozartian 
                  persona was already seemingly in place 
                  by c.1948 – some of these Cetras can’t 
                  be dated with certainty but they must 
                  be contemporaneous with the dated 
                  1947-48 sequence. The lighter songs 
                  shows that he has the grace and vocal 
                  agility to caress Tosti, to billow 
                  in the Arcadian forests of Billi and 
                  to revel in the strength of Denza. 
                
                
                Siepi’s youthful 
                  élan permeates every bar of 
                  this wholesome and impressive selection, 
                  which is finely transferred and well 
                  annotated into the bargain.
                
                Jonathan Woolf
                see also reviews 
                  by Goran 
                  Forsling and Robert 
                  Hugill