Alia Vox are busy re-mastering for multi-channel SACD the entire
back catalogue of their recordings with Jordi Savall and his various
instrumental and vocal groups. This Dowland disc is Volume 17 of the series.
The re-mastering and presentation are exemplary, giving the listener every
opportunity to come to terms with this remote masterpiece by, as the
original frontispiece puts it “John Dowland Bacheler of Musicke, and
Lutenist to the most Royall and Magnificent, Christian the fourth, King of
Denmark ... “ It goes on for several more lines of appellation for his
royal patron. There are twenty one parts to this book of
lachrimae
and courtly dances.
The sequence is performed with meticulous attention to Dowland's
instructions by a consort of five viols and a lute, all members of Savall's
Hespèrion XX group. Most of this music is slow and solemn, a
characteristic not so much of the period as of Dowland himself. The years
following the death of Elizabeth I were indeed those of the '17th century
melancholy'. It went on to influence poets, musicians and philosophers
throughout the Jacobean period. The common people saw this as a cult of the
educated and aristocratic classes and it was much lampooned in contemporary
satires. For us, with the benefit of over four centuries perspective, this
slow and gentle music is quite a relief from the brief, aggressive and
lively cultural artefacts that now absorb us. The last thing one can imagine
is a John Dowland tweet. He needs space gradually to develop and repeat his
gloomy ideas. A modern listener may well find this music rather sad and
hypnotic. The nearest music of this era is that of the late Sir John Tavener
who also demands temporal space.
As implied by the title, there are seven 'tears'. Each tear is about
five minutes long and separated from the next by one or more
galiard,
pavan,
almand or
funerall. For continuous listening the
dances, described as passionate but all gravely beautiful and never
indecorous, do much to sugar the pill of all that crying. Perhaps the way to
get inside this distant music is to turn down the lights and play a lot of
it at a suitably moderate volume.
There are plenty of alternative recordings but, given its excellent
sound and its very reasonable price, this is irresistible. If you need
another reason then heed Dowland's own words: “though the title doth
promise teares unfit guests in these ioyfull times, yet no doubt pleasant
are the teares which Musicke weepes, neither are teares shed always in
sorrow, but some time in ioy and gladness.”
Dave Billinge