MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews

FOGHORN Classics

Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews

All HDTT reviews

Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World

all Nimbus reviews

all tudor reviews

Follow us on Twitter

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger

To gain a 10% discount, use the link below & the code MusicWeb10

John JOUBERT (b. 1927)
Piano Concerto, Op. 25 (1958) [31:59]
Symphony No. 3 on themes from the opera Jane Eyre, Op. 178 (2014-17) [33:17]
Martin Jones (piano), BBC National O. of Wales / William Boughton
rec. 2017, Hoddinott Hall, Cardiff
LYRITA SRCD367 [65:16]

Last year my Recording of the Year was the release of the superb live performance of John Joubert’s most recent opera, Jane Eyre, issued on CD to mark his 90th birthday in March 2017. I mentioned in my original review of the recording that Joubert had excised quite a lot of orchestral material from the opera’s original score but that he had recycled the music into his new Third Symphony. I’m bound to say that at that time I was unsure when we might get a chance to hear that music but now, thanks to the BBC and Lyrita, we have it here. I’m not sure if the symphony has yet received a public performance. Rather unusually, both of the recordings on this disc were broadcast by the BBC during the summer, several weeks before I received the disc for review, though I missed the broadcast of the concerto.

In his excellent notes, Paul Conway tells us that Joubert tightened up the score of Jane Eyre in preparation for the projected concert performance (which eventually took place and which is now preserved on the SOMM recording.) Two whole scenes were excised as well as three orchestral interludes. In all, the revisions took some 45 minutes out of the score; I wonder, in passing, whether the composer regards these as permanent excisions or whether the cuts might be restored were a staged performance to materialise. Mr Conway out that the opera material is not transcribed verbatim but, rather, that the principal ideas provide the material from which each movement is developed. It might be objected that the material is not developed in a “strict” symphonic sense but I can assure listeners that each movement demonstrates very satisfying development of the material. In the opera Joubert used a chamber sized orchestra consisting of strings, single wind and brass, timpani, two percussionists, piano and, for Jane’s wedding scene, an organ. The symphony, however, uses a much fuller orchestra, including triple woodwind (with doubling), a full brass complement, timpani, three percussionists, harp and strings. I didn’t feel any want of colour or orchestral invention when listening to the opera but, my goodness, the fuller scoring in the symphony is terrific, not least the involvement of the harp and the imaginative use of percussion.

There are five movements. The first, ‘Lowood School’ begins with mysterious writing for strings and crotales. Paul Conway rightly identifies an ambiguous tone of voice in this movement. From around 3:30 the music builds to a climax that is both impassioned and extended, after which (from about 5:30) the movement subsides to a quiet conclusion. There follows ‘Thornfield House’ in which, to quote Paul Conway, ‘Joubert fashions a colourful tapestry of interweaving motifs from the second and third scenes of Act I’. The music becomes very powerful and then (from 3:21) we hear a wonderfully orchestrated lighter passage in which the harp has a significant atmospheric role and there are important solos for clarinet, oboe and flute.

The third movement, ‘Thornfield Church’ begins restlessly. Eventually we hear the music for Jane’s wedding procession. However, the troubled nature of much of the music underlines the fact that the day of Jane’s wedding to Rochester is not gong to have a happy outcome. Fleeing from the scene of her abandoned wedding, Jane takes refuge with the Rivers family. In the opera Rivers, the zealous parson (marvellously portrayed on the recording by Mark Milhofer), tries to persuade Jane to accompany him, as his wife, to overseas missionary work. In this orchestral movement, entitled ‘Whitecross Rectory’, I’m sure we’re hearing Jane’s inner turmoil as she is first repelled by the prospect of life with Rivers and then comes to the realisation that her destiny lies with Rochester. A lot of the music in this movement is urgent and turbulent but my ear was also caught by the appealing clarinet solo heard right at the close.

The finale, ‘Thornfield Park’, gets off to a bustling start. Then, in Mr Conway’s words. ‘much of the previously heard thematic material is brought together with the sleight of hand of a master of long-term symphonic planning’. The only thing I’d add is that as Joubert revisits his material he does so now in a very positive vein. The last few minutes of the movement are expansive as Jane and Rochester – and the Third Symphony – arrive at a happy ending with bells pealing.

I really enjoyed this symphony. The thematic material is memorable and the scoring brings the music to life in a most colourful way If music had to be cut from Jane Eyre for very good reasons then I’m very glad that it has found a new home in this symphony. The work is an essential adjunct to the opera. William Boughton and the BBC National Orchestra of Wales play the score with great commitment and skill.

The Piano Concerto is a much earlier work. Its composition came about as a result of the first performance of Joubert’s First Symphony by the Hull Philharmonic Orchestra in 1956. Also on the programme of that concert was the Grieg Piano Concerto and the soloist, Iso Elison (1907-1964), paid Joubert the compliment of staying on to hear the symphony. Impressed by what he heard, he invited Joubert to write a concerto for him and he gave the work’s premiere in 1959. The concerto is cast in the traditional three movements and is scored for a smaller orchestra than the Third Symphony. So far as I’m aware, this is the first recording of the work.

The opening movement is marked Allegro. There’s a very strong rhythmic impetus to the first theme; the music is serious and energetic. At 1:16 the flute introduces a second theme; this has a more lyrical aspect but still I hear tension in the music. What follows features a good deal of vigorous, toccata-like writing for both piano and orchestra. Along the way I admired many imaginative touches in the orchestration, such as a kind of “swirling” effect just after 3:00, which recurs later on. Joubert’s development of his ideas is virile and robust; Martin Jones and the orchestra project the music strongly. The very end of the movement comes as something of a surprise with an almost casual little pay-off. Paul Conway draws an apt parallel with the conclusion of the first movement of Beethoven’s Eighth Symphony.

The first movement has given the percussive aspect of the piano a thorough work-out and at first, as the soloist begins the Lento, it seems that the slow movement will emphasise the cantabile capabilities of the instrument. That impression is reinforced at 0:55 when the woodwind intone a second theme which is almost chorale-like. However, Joubert develops these themes in a very purposeful, almost dark fashion; as in the first movement, the music is strongly rhythmical. The movement builds to a very intense climax around 3:30 during which the horns are satisfyingly prominent. However, after this (from about 4:40) things calm down and the music becomes lyrical, eventually achieving a calm end.

The finale opens with a Lento passage. This is a slow cadenza-like passage for the soloist, interpolated by a series of strange wind chords. At 1:17 the main body of the movement, an Allegro vivace, begins. The music dances along in extrovert fashion. The soloist is required to be nimble fingered and for both the piano and the orchestra there’s a good deal of insistently rhythmic writing. Yet again, there’s much to admire in Joubert’s deft and expert handling of the orchestra. After a powerful climax, at 8:53 the opening wind chords usher in a proper and substantial cadenza, which runs through to 12;53. This is a cadenza in the grand manner and Martin Jones commands our attention. After the cadenza there’s a brief reprise of the Allegro vivace which drives this impressive concerto to an exciting, percussive ending.

This is a fine concerto and Martin Jones, ably supported by William Boughton and the BBCNOW, makes a very strong case for it.

This CD is an important addition to the Joubert discography. The performances are excellent in every way and have been recorded vividly. Paul Conway’s extensive notes provide an ideal and highly knowledgeable introduction to the music.

John Quinn

Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews

all Bridge reviews

all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All Eloquence reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews


Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing