Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
RECORDING OF THE MONTH
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Jonathan DOVE (b 1959) Nights not Spent Alone- Complete works for mezzo-soprano
My Love is Mine (1997) [4:09]
Five Am’rous Sighs (1997) [8:20]
All the Future Days (2004) [20:13]
Cut My Shadow (2011) [8:47]
Nights not Spent Alone (2015) [10:03]
All You Who Sleep Tonight (1996) [20:05]
Kitty Whately (mezzo-soprano)
Simon Lepper (piano)
rec. March 2016, Music Room, Champs Hill, West Sussex, UK. DDD
English texts included CHAMPS HILL RECORDS CHRCD125 [71:15]
I’m a fan of Jonathan Dove’s music; I’ve heard quite a lot of it, mainly his vocal music, and have enjoyed what I’ve heard. Equally, I have been very taken with the singing of the British mezzo, Kitty Whately, and all the more so since hearing her outstanding debut CD, This Other Eden (review). So the combination of an admired composer and an admired singer on the same CD was irresistible.
There’s only one individual song on the disc - My Love is
Mine; all the other offerings are cycles or collections of songs.
The most recent composition, Nights not Spent Alone, was composed
specifically for Kitty Whately; it was jointly commissioned by BBC Radio
3 and the Royal Philharmonic Society Young Artists Scheme. The present
performers premiered it at the Cheltenham Music Festival. I wasn’t
able to attend that concert but I’m glad that I’ve caught
up with the songs now. At Kitty Whately’s suggestion Dove set
three poems by the American poet, Edna St Vincent Millay (1892-1950).
These are frank expressions of feelings and Dove’s music suits
the mood of each individual poem, I think. The first, Recuerdo
(the Spanish word for ‘to remember’) describes the emotions
of a new love affair and it occurred to me as I listened that perhaps
the music is implying that this might be an emotional entanglement that
won’t end well – though I may be wrong since that’s
not clear from the words themselves. Each of the three verses grows
in intensity and the vocal line is underpinned by an insistent piano
part, the harmonies and syncopation of which has a whiff of the Blues
to it. What lips my lips have kissed is a touching song of
recollection – and of regret, I think, for what might have been.
The final song, I too beneath your moon, is an uninhibited
setting of a very frank poem. It sounds to be technically and emotionally
demanding for both performers but Whately and Lepper give it their all.
The music rises to a determined, voluptuous climax on the last line,
“And lust is there, and nights not spent alone.”
In complete contrast, the song which opens the recital, My Love is Mine, speaks of love in a very different way. The text is from the Song of Songs and the piece is unaccompanied because it was written to be sung at a wedding in a Quaker meeting house where no musical instruments are available. In his very good booklet notes Julian Grant describes the song very accurately as “a joyous and touching monody with an occasional melisma.” It is wonderfully expressive and I can only describe Kitty Whately’s singing of it as sensuous.
The choice of texts for Five Am’rous Sighs is unusual. Dove selected poems by two 18th century writers, Lady Mary Wortley Montagu (?1689-1762) and Matthew Prior (1664-1721). I’ve heard of Lady Mary before: she was celebrated for her letter-writing, especially the letters written while her husband was serving as the British Ambassador to Turkey. Three songs set texts by her. Prior’s name was new to me. He was a politician and diplomat but also a prolific essayist and poet. Montagu’s Between Your Sheets becomes highly suggestive by the end and Kitty Whately brings appropriate sensuality to her tone. Both of the stanzas
rise to impassioned climaxes. Prior’s My Heart Still Hovering sounds for all the world like a love song – but there’s a twist in the tale. All These Dismal Looks sets sardonic words by Lady Mary to suitably pithy music.
All the Future Days is a set of six poems by Ursula Vaughan Williams: all are either about or portrayals of women. I like these songs very much indeed. The second, Autobiography, has an ardent vocal line, most expressively sung here. Meanwhile the vocal line is underpinned by a constantly rippling piano part. Best of all are the last two songs. First comes Martha, which concerns the sister of Lazarus in the New Testament story. Martha was pictured in the Gospels as one of life’s ‘doers’ but here both the words and the music express admiration for her steadfastness and application. It’s a very fine song. So, too, is The Siren. The poem tells of the woman who had an intimate relationship with an Angel and then was condemned to sing and mourn his death forever. A huge piano introduction sets the stage for a passionate song which ends with an ardent vocalise. Kitty Whately and Simon Lepper give a compelling rendition of what is, I should imagine, a very demanding song to perform.
Cut My Shadow consists of three settings of poems by Federico García Lorca (1898-1936) in English translations. These poems are literary strong meat. The first, Surprise, is an outpouring of grief for a murdered man. Dove has made a no-holds-barred setting of which Whately and Lepper give a vivid account. Guitar, which is a lament, starts off in a mood of what I might term tense tranquillity and becomes more and more impassioned. The set concludes with Song of the Dry Orange Tree: here the music is angry and angular. These aren’t as appealing as some of the other songs on the disc – which is understandable in view of the subject matter – but, my goodness, they make an impression.
All You Who Sleep Tonight is a collection of twelve songs to words by Vikram Seth (b 1952). These were written for Nuala Willis, the creator of several of Dove’s operatic roles. He is quoted in the booklet as saying that he set out to write a selection of songs that this “unique performer…might sing somewhere between a night-club and the Wigmore Hall.” As you might infer, these 12 songs cover a wide range and, furthermore, several of them are very short since no less than eight of the selected texts are quatrains. Whilst I enjoyed all the songs and mean to cast no aspersions on the earlier ones in the collection it seems to me that the set increases in depth as it unfolds. Thus, some of the settings that we hear early on are quite pithy but Dark Road, Door and Night Watch are all on a deeper level. The last two songs are the most affecting of all. Soon is an intense song about someone facing impending and premature death. All You Who Sleep Tonight is very beautiful and is, in Julian Grant’s words “a rapt gesture of conciliation.”
This programme contains many very fine songs. Dove’s music has great appeal, even in the Lorca settings which are more uncompromising. He’s a genuine melodist and these compositions prove that he has a discerning eye for a text and that he is capable of enhancing his chosen texts through music. The vocal lines consistently compel attention and the piano parts expertly complement the melodic line.
It’s hard to imagine that the songs could be in better hands. Kitty Whately sings this varied programme with consummate skill. Her diction is extremely clear and the tone is simply gorgeous. Her voice has a lovely top while the middle and low registers are rich, full and warm. She has a great ability to put over a song expressively and I found that she grabbed my attention from start to finish. This new album is further proof that this gifted singer could – and should – have a very big career. Simon Lepper’s pianism is no less admirable. He is highly supportive of his singer and ensures that the piano parts always make their full effect.
The technical side of the recording was in the hands of Nigel Short (producer) and Dave Rowell (engineer). They’ve done a fine job in the pleasing acoustic of the music room at Champs Hill, not least in balancing the singer and piano expertly.
This is a very fine release. Kitty Whately comments in a foreword to the booklet that Jonathan Dove’s songs aren’t performed nearly as much as they should be. Well, with advocacy such as this surely that will change.
Kitty Whately and Simon Lepper will be appearing together in rectal at the Three Choirs Festival in Worcester on 28 July. Their programme will include the premiere of a new work by Sally Beamish and a generous selection of Jonathan Dove songs from this disc, including Nights not Spent Alone, My Love is Mine, Five Am’rous Sighs and The Siren from All the Future Days. Details here.