Charles IVES (1874-1954)
Symphony No. 2 (1900-1902) [38:20] Elliott CARTER (1908-2012) Instances (2012) [7:53] George GERSHWIN (1898-1937) An American in Paris (1928) [18:45]
Seattle Symphony/Ludovic Morlot
rec. live, Benaroya Hall, Seattle, USA, June 2012 (Ives); February 2013 (Carter); September-October 2011 (Gershwin)
Reviewed as a 24/96 download from
Pdf booklet included SEATTLE SYMPHONY MEDIA SSM1003 [64:58]
Charles IVES (1874-1954)
Symphony No. 4 (1912-1925) (ed. T. Brodhead) [31:12] The Unanswered Question (1906) (revised version) [6:50] Central Park in the Dark (1906) [11:22]
Symphony No. 3 in B flat major, ‘Camp Meeting’ (1908-10) [22:18]
David Gordon (trumpet) (The Unanswered Question)
Seattle Chorale, Cristina Valdés (piano), Joseph Adam (organ) (Symphony No. 4)
Seattle Symphony/Ludovic Morlot, assisted by Stilian Kirov, David Alexander Rahbee and Julia Tai
rec. live, Benaroya Hall, Seattle, USA, January 2015 (Symphony No. 4); September 2014 and April 2015 (Central Park, The Unanswered Question); May, September 2014 and April 2015 (Symphony No. 3)
Reviewed as a 24/96 download from
Pdf booklet included SEATTLE SYMPHONY MEDIA SSM1009 [71:42]
It’s like those London buses: you wait for ages
then several turn up at once. I'm referring to Volume
1 and Volume
2 of Sir Andrew Davis’s Melbourne Ives cycle and to these
two recordings from Ludovic Morlot and the Seattle Symphony. I was very
disappointed by the latter’s Ravel and Saint-Saëns (review),
but a preliminary listen to their Ives was most encouraging; that goes
for both the music-making and the sound. Also, Ivesians will be pleased
to note that Morlot uses the critical editions of all these scores,
something that Davis failed to do in his Melbourne account of the First
I had planned to haul out my various Ives sets for comparative purposes,
but such is the pleasure generated by these Seattle performances that
I was tempted to just sit back and enjoy the music. However, I couldn’t
resist dipping into rival recordings from Leonard
Tilson Thomas, Andrew
Litton and, of course, Andrew Davis. In the past I've praised the
latter’s live Barbican series from January 1996, which was nothing
short of a revelation. I do hope the BBC, who recorded all those performances,
will find a way to make them available to the listening public. I've
suggested cover-mounted CDs on their monthly music magazine. Until then
we'll just have to settle for off-air tapes.
Morlot’s first album opens with a warmly expressive account of
the Second Symphony. He and his players are rhythmically alert, yet
they find a genial flow to the first movement that I like very much
indeed. The recording is splendid, with a nicely rounded bass and a
clean, extended treble. As for Ives’s quotes from popular tunes
– one of the composer's most endearing trademarks - they leap
from the mix, sounding as fresh as the day they were filched. Even more
impressive is Morlot's response to the second movement – marked
Allegro – which has remarkable clarity and thrust.
Goodness, these players are at their committed and passionate best.
Not only that, Morlot shows himself to be a born Ivesian; he’s
attuned to the composer’s unique sound world, so none of the score’s
quirky details pass unnoticed. And the Seattle brass, particularly bracing
in this Allegro, deserve to be mentioned in dispatches. Then
there's fhe Adagiocantabile, which emerges with perfect
musculature and a strong sense of purpose. As for the lower strings
they sound super-lustrous, while in the finale the horns play with a
nuanced beauty that’s just breathtaking. Having done so well thus
far Morlot opts for Bernstein’s ugly splurge on the symphony’s
last chord. At least it's not so protracted; in fact, anyone with editing
experience should be able to prune it easily enough.
For all their faults Lenny’s recordings of the Second –
for CBS/Sony and Deutsche
Grammophon – are long-time favourites of mine, not least because
they capture the unrepentant feistiness of this great score. Morlot
does that, and a whole lot more; factor in first-class playing and terrific
sound and it’s little wonder that this is now my Ives 2 of choice.
The audience certainly loved it, and I daresay you will too. The fillers,
the world première of Carter’s Instances and a fizzing
performance of Gershwin’s An American in Paris, are no
less desirable. A minor quibble; the gap between these two pieces is
far too short. That may not be an issue on the CD, though.
The second album opens with a performance of Ives’s great musical
mélange, the Fourth Symphony. In the first and last movements
the Seattle Chorale are both crisp and fervent, while Morlot and his
three assistants ensure that the work’s carousings and collisions
are disciplined enough for details and cross-rhythms to register with
ease. Just as important are those hymn tunes, which are played with
a breadth – and an abiding affection – that seems just right
for the piece.
While there’s a great deal to admire in Morlot’s Fourth
it doesn’t supplant Davis’s Barbican account in my affections.
Indeed, the latter has an even greater sense of the music’s ambition
– its sheer modernity – than Morlot’s. However, the
more I listened to this Seattle Fourth the more persuasive it seemed.
There’s a tremendous drive here, not to mention a palpable joy
in all those bands and borrowings, that’s hugely rewarding. So
while Morlot isn't as volatile as Davis he's always thoughtful and proportionate
in his response to this score. The recording is full and detailed, with
a spectacular range when required. Cristina Valdés play a mean piano
and Joseph Adam’s discreetly voiced organ part is nicely judged.
I do miss the mournful theremin though, as it adds a strange twist to
Morlot’s readings of the two Contemplations, better known
as The Unanswered Question and Central Park in the Dark,
are no less distinguished. Indeed, these musicians play this music as
if to the manner born. Trumpeter David Gordon is haunting in The
Unanswered Question, and the opposing flutes are bright but never
brittle. As for Central Park inthe Dark it has a
brooding loveliness that’s very well caught by the recording team.
Davis Mark 1 is still very striking in both works, but a combination
of finely calibrated direction, exemplary playing and first-rate sound
puts these new versions way out in front.
There are just as many felicities to be found in this Seattle Third,
among them the genial baroquerie of The Old Folks Gatherin’.
Morlot brings out the gentle stateliness of this music more lovingly
than most. Children’s Day is just as affectionately characterised,
the robust Seattle strings as magnificent as ever. It helps that Morlot
makes Ives’s delectable rhythms lift and bounce with such ease
and naturalness; more important, there’s a profound humanity to
this performance that’s very affecting. E. M. Forster once spoke
of ‘the thousand little civilities that consecrate life’,
and that vital, binding spirit shines trough in Morlot's radiant reading
of Communion, the symphony's aptly titled finale.
I may have had reservations about this team’s Ravel and Saint-Saëns,
but these new additions to the SSM catalogue are in another league entirely.
In particular I’m struck by the wonderful rapport that now exists
between these American musicians and their French music director; this
explains, in part at least, why these performances are so compelling.
I wouldn’t want to be without Bernstein, Tilson Thomas, Litton
or Sinclair, but if pushed to choose just two Ives recordings for my
desert island I'd plump for Morlot's pair.
Outstanding Ives, superbly played, sung and recorded; even the fillers
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger