Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Support us financially by purchasing
this through MusicWeb
for £12 postage paid world-wide.
Antonio Vivaldi and Contemporaries: Virtuoso Recorder Concertos Antonio VIVALDI (1678-1741)
Concerto in C, RV443 [10:45]
Concerto in c minor, RV441 [10:34]
Concerto in F, RV442 [8:43]
Concerto in C, RV444 [9:21]
Concerto in a minor, RV108 [7:50] Giuseppe SAMMARTINI (1695-1750)
Concerto in F [13:38] Jacques-Christophe NAUDOT (1690-1762)
Concerto in G, Op.17/5 [11:05] Alessandro SCARLATTI (1660-1725)
Concerto Grosso in d minor [6:37]
Richard Harvey (recorder)
London Vivaldi Orchestra/Monica Huggett, Roy Goodman
rec. EMI Studios, Abbey Road, London (?), c.1982 (?). DDD ALTUS ALU0002 [79:05]
The main part of this recording first appeared on CD as ASV CDGAU111, itself
a reissue of an LP first released in 1982. This makes a nonsense of the date
1998 given for the Altus reissue, though that may well refer to the extra items
which have enlarged the original release by 30 minutes. First issued by Altus
in 2000, it now reappears with the identical catalogue number. I’ve given the
EMI studios as location, as per the information in the Altus booklet, though
in 1982 the location was given as Bishopsgate Hall, London.
It’s in no small measure thanks to this recording that I installed a new printer
without tears or tantrums in a fraction of its playing time: that’s quicker
than any previous installation. If the music didn’t help the process, it certainly
assisted my mood and the boredom of watching the paint dry.
We were not short of recordings of the Vivaldi recorder concertos, with at least
ten extant versions of RV444, eight of RV442, 41 of RV443, 14 of RV108 and 25
of RV441, one of the best of RV441 also being available as a filler to a highly
recommendable budget twofer of L’Estro Armonico from the Academy of St
Martin in the Fields and Neville Marriner (Decca Duo E4434762). Similarly one
of the best recordings of RV443 features as the filler for another Decca Duo
Vivaldi recording from the ASMF, this time of the Op.9 set, La Cetra
The other works, however, are much less easy to come by: the Naudot has just
three recordings to its name, only one of which includes music by Vivaldi (RV443
and 444). The Sammartini has ten recordings but the Scarlatti appears to have
only two apart from the present recording.
The new Altus CD, then, offers a unique coupling. It also serves an important
function in tracing the rise of the recorder concerto in much the same way,
if less comprehensively, as a recent series of recordings on Avie traced the
rise of the North Italian Violin Concerto. (AV2106, 2128 and 2154).
With no direct competition, the best choice of a comparison album comes from
Hyperion on their budget Helios label: Peter Holtslag, treble and sopranino
recorders, and the period-instrument Parley of Instruments/Peter Holman perform
RV441, 442, 443, 444, 445 and 108 (CDH55016). The shorter playing time of the
Hyperion is amply compensated for by the low price (around £6.50, or £5.99 if
downloaded in mp3 or lossless sound, with pdf booklet, from Hyperion).
There’s another collection containing the same six concertos plus a sonata,
performed by Michael Schneider on CPO (777304-2), on which I found absolutely
nothing amiss yet couldn’t bring myself to recommended with enthusiasm – review.
Surprisingly, Holtslag and Holman are slightly slower overall than Richard Harvey
in every concerto except RV108. The differences are not huge and there’s no
suggestion that Harvey ever sounds rushed: in actuality both sets of performances
are stylish and sprightly but not breakneck.
The greatest differences occur in the slow movements, which Harvey tends to
take more slowly than Holtslag. In RV443, for example, the largo takes
4:02 against 3:49; of versions which I checked for comparison only two take
longer: Il Giardino Armonico (Warner) take 5:19, but they are noted for extremes
of tempo. This is my favourite movement of all these concertos and it lends
itself to a wide degree of latitude, with Martin Feinstein and the Feinstein
Ensemble (BCR) dashing through in 3:02. Both the Hyperion and Altus recordings
fall into the middle of the range, along with Héloïse Gaillard and Ensemble
Amarillis (Ambroisie AMB9944, download/stream only, or Naïve AM143, 4 CDs) and
these three seem to me just right, with the difference between them more apparent
on paper than in reality, though it’s obvious that Holtslag keeps the music
moving more nimbly than Harvey if you listen consecutively.
Maurice Steger on a recent CD of Vivaldi Concerti per flautino (Harmonia
Mundi HMC902190) takes 4:32. A slower tempo allows him decorate the solo part
a little more – too much, you may think. I liked this album in general and
the slow movements in particular –
DL News 2014/12: I should have given the link to eclassical.com
– I do think, however, that this movement sounds a bit funereal on rehearing
it. See also review
by Dominy Clements.
Holtslag opens his recording with RV441. Unusually, he’s marginally slower
than Harvey in all three movements of this concerto, not just in the outer movements:
5:04 + 2:41 + 3:49 against Harvey’s 4:40 + 2:15 + 3:39. I very much like Holtslag
overall but I do think him a shade too slow at times in this concerto. Most
recordings of this work which I value tend to agree with Harvey: Marion Verbruggen,
for example, with Nicholas McGegan on a 2-CD Harmonia Mundi album, coupled with
Janet See in the Flute Concertos, takes 2:10. (HMX2907340/41, download only.)
The Hyperion is well worth considering, especially as it’s so inexpensive.
If you want a rival recording of the Sammartini your best option is Camerata
Köln on Deutsche Harmonia Mundi, coupled with other works by Giuseppe and Giovanni
Battista Sammartini (download only or stream from Qobuz).
Alternatively Pamela Thorby with Sonnerie (Linn CKD217, with Telemann Suite
in a minor and Vivaldi RV441, 443 and 444 – DL
News 2013/13). Good as both of these are, I enjoyed the new Altus recording
just as much.
The Naudot concerto was published as a flute concerto, but is usually performed
on the recorder, as by Michala Petri with the Academy of St Martin-in-the Fields
on a 4-CD set, The Art of the Recorder (Decca Collectors’ Edition E4758464).
Again, though I’d be very happy to own the Decca set at its attractive price,
I’m more than happy with the Altus. If you are looking for more music by Naudot,
there’s a collection of the six Op.11 flute concertos on Hungaroton (HCD31600:
Pál Németh, wooden flute, and Capella Savaria, download only – from eclassical.com,
mp3 and lossless, No booklet). It’s very attractive, if rather inconsequential
The Scarlatti is the third of his oddly-named Sinfonie di Concerto Grosso.
There are two other concertos from this set on Hyperion Helios CDH55005 at budget
price and the complete set is available on Tactus TBB661990, 2 CDs, both of
which I reviewed in DL
News 2014/14, but the Altus recording is equally recommendable.
The support offered by the London Vivaldi Orchestra is very good – hardly surprising
when Monica Huggett is leader/director for most of the concertos and she and
Roy Goodman are responsible in the movements where a solo violin is required.
Though recorded early in the digital era, the sound is good, with the continuo
just audible, as it should be.
The booklet contains helpful notes on the composers and works contained on the
CD but, apart from noting that both Vivaldi and Sammartini employed higher-pitched
instruments than usual, there’s no description of the recorder employed: it’s
a treble or a sopranino recorder for Vivaldi and Scarlatti and a descant instrument
These small complaints about the documentation apart, then, although there is
strong competition for all the music on this album, differently coupled, if
the programme appeals, you should be more than happy with the Altus reissue.