Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Johann Simon MAYR(1763-1845)
Concerto for Piccolo, Flute, Clarinet, Basset Horn and Orchestra
in D minor, Concerto Bergamasco (1820) [24:57]
Keyboard Concerto in C major (c. 1800) [16:17] Trio Concertante for Three Violins and Orchestra in A minor(c.
Natalie Schwaabe (flute and piccolo), Andrea Steinberg (clarinet
and basset horn), Antonio Spiller, Yi Li and David van Dijk (violins),
Franz Hauk (harpsichord)
Bavarian Classical Players/Franz Hauk
rec. 19-22 September 2007, Fahnensaal, Neues Schloss, Ingolstadt,
NAXOS 8.570927 [53:36]
This really is an ‘innocent ear’ review as neither
the music nor the players are at all familiar to me. Mayr was
born near Ingolstadt, Bavaria, and made his home in Italy, where
he established a fine music school. He was also a prolific opera
composer and dabbled in many other genres too. In his succinct
liner-notes Franz Hauk points out that Spohr regarded Mayr as
so immersed in the Italian musical tradition that he’d
lost all traces of his German roots.
To some extent the irrepressible lift and easy warmth of the
works on this disc bear this out but really few works are entirely
devoid of others’ influence; the Concerto Bergamasco
is no exception. The flute-drenched first movement has a Haydnesque
bounce and beat, the almost martial timps providing a gruff
counterpoint to all this glee. Natalie Schwaabe is a fine soloist,
her silvered tones effortless and endearing; as for the orchestral
playing it’s both spunky and spontaneous which makes for
a delightful listen. Andrea Steinberg steals the show in the
second movement. The disarming agility of her clarinet playing
is well matched by the delicious burble from the band. She’s
no less characterful on the basset horn, which features in the
dark-hued third movement.
This concerto brims with charm, but it’s not short of
invention either. There’s wit aplenty too and the good-natured
toing and froing of the third movement is hugely entertaining.
Mayr brings all the soloists together in the finale’s
theme and variations, whose sometimes swooning manner is deftly
handled by all concerned. Goodness, what deep-refreshing music
this is, a cool fountain plashing most pleasurably on a hot,
Conductor Franz Hauk takes the harpsichord part in the Keyboard
Concerto,whose opening Allegro has a distinctly Mozartian
cast. The soloist is well balanced, a boon when the instrument’s
limited dynamics mean it’s easily overwhelmed in boisterous
company. The poise and understated elegance of Hauk’s
playing is a real joy, notably in the Andantino, and
I must say that the recording is one of the most alluring I’ve
heard from Naxos in a while. The concluding Rondo dips
and dances to giddying effect, but Hauk remains a steady, calming
influence throughout. Yet another smile-inducing piece, played
with all the breeze and brightness one could wish.
Brightness comes to mind in the Trio Concertante, but
thankfully that’s more to do with the key than the recording
which is as warm and well-behaved as the rest of this programme.
The soloists are uniformly excellent and they play for all they’re
worth when it’s their turn to take the spotlight. Although
this work isn’t always as inventive as the others here
it’s never less than accomplished and engaging. Huzzahs
to Hauk and his orchestra for providing such sympathetic accompaniment;
as for the Naxos engineers, their sterling efforts earn them
a mention in despatches.
Music of lilt and loveliness, winningly played; a joyful discovery.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.