Emil Gilels: Early Recordings Vol. 3 Naxos Historical 8.111386 [BR] : Classical Music Reviews

Emil Gilels lovers, be on high alert: Gilels playing Scarlatti! This rare combination is, so far as I know, only to be had on one other disc, a BBC Legends live recital from the early 1980s. Here we have Gilels playing the same Scarlatti sonatas, but in the mid-1950s, in really pretty good sound for the era, excellently restored. Gilels’ Scarlatti is magical: pianistic in its drama and color, but classical in its tempo and clarity. To achieve piano nirvana, compare Gilels’ B minor sonata K27 to Yevgeny Sudbin’s, or the E major K380 performances of Gilels, Pletnev, Bjelland, Tharaud, and Lipatti. Am I saying Gilels’ Scarlatti is worthy of comparison with these greats? Yes, yes I am. The opening measures of K380 make an indelible impression with their evocation of tolling bells, and the rest has an enviable fluidity and natural clarity; the B minor has poetry and expansiveness, though not as radical as Sudbin’s.

The rest of the disc is fantastic too. The Liszt fantasia on Le nozze de Figaro (completed by Busoni) showcases Gilels’ trademark combination of bravura and good taste: he doesn’t barnstorm through but shapes the piece as a truly operatic fantasy. He doesn’t even burn through the two Paganini etudes, although I have to say his low-key approach cannot reclaim the musical value of the ‘La campanella’ etude from decades of self-aggrandizing virtuosi who have hijacked it in the decades since. His Hungarian Rhapsodies (6 and 9) are very good, even if they don’t knock your jaw clean to the floor. There are a couple technical slips, but mostly I can’t say his rhapsodies are better than, say, Jando’s. Little surprise to find that he hardly ever played them again.

The Chopin’s another story again: the two polonaises are in noble, gallant readings, with the legendary ‘Heroic’ Op 53 showcasing Gilels’ command of the epic and care over detail at once. The Ballade is excellently done, with real poetry and gentleness when called for but a powerfully angry final minute (those haunting quiet chords in the coda are excellently rendered). It rounds out a generous 80 minutes of fascinating playing.

Ward Marston’s sound restoration is heroic as always. The Scarlatti, from a 1955 Melodiya LP, sounds genuinely good, as does ‘Pesther Carnaval’; on the other hand, the final two Chopin selections are a bit constricted in piano tone and the Mozart/Liszt/Busoni fantasy is in sadly primitive shape. Hisses and pops are gone or reduced, but without any loss in presence for the piano itself, which is a relief; the only hint of extraneous noise aside from the Mozart/Liszt/Busoni is at the end of the last track. The booklet notes don’t discuss the music much, but are very helpful to Gilels collectors and others interested in the provenance of the recordings. For casual listeners, the rewards of these excellent recordings are to be had in the hearing.

Brian Reinhart

Reviews of the other Gilels volumes on Naxos Historical

2024 60,000 reviews ... and still writing ...	Search MusicWeb Here