Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
František BENDA(1709-1786) Violin Concerto in C major, Lee II-1 (c.1739) [17:30]
Violin Concerto in B flat major, Lee II-18 (c.1740) [15:24]
Violin Concerto in D major, Lee II-16 (c.1740) [18:48]
Violin Concerto in A minor, Lee II-16 [20:19]
Prague Philharmonia/Ivan Ženatý (violin)
rec. May 2011, and January 2012, Martínek Studio, Prague
SUPRAPHON SU 4064-2 [72:26]
Benda was one of the most illustrious, possibly the single most
illustrious, Czech violinist of the eighteenth century. Yet
fewer than twenty concertos of his concertos for his own instrument
have survived. In this disc we hear four of them in performances
from Ivan Ženatý who plays a modern set up violin
with musicians drawn from the Prague Philharmonia, comprised
2-1-1-1 and harpsichord - baroque sized (but modern instrument).
The intimate nature of the music making suits the performances,
and indeed the nature of the compositions themselves. These
are pleasantly old-fashioned, more akin to Vivaldi than an Italian
contemporary like Tartini - akin to Vivaldi, yes, in a sense,
but rather lacking the flair, panache, colour and hubristic
danger of Vivaldi.
Which is not to suggest that they are not worthy or exciting
in their own way. The C major has a forceful first movement,
but the slow movement remains in the memory more for its character
than for any true melodic distinction. The finale is probably
the finest of the three movements, fizzing with energy and clever
contrasts between ritornellos and the vivid, slashing solo violin.
Here, for sure, one feels the impress of Vivaldi’s spirit.
Here, too, one can tentatively gauge just what sort of virtuoso
Benda must have been.
The confident, fluent, Italianate lyricism that floods the B
flat major is aerial in its finesse, showy in places, whilst
not achieving much true distinction. Someone else added extraneous
parts to the D major - let’s name him; Johann Georg Pisendel,
who was a friend, and led the Dresden court orchestra which,
because it was larger than the orchestra for which Benda wrote,
needed something ‘extra’ to play. In Supraphon’s
recording we scrub off Pisendel’s horn parts and go back
to the bare, string accompaniment. Finally there is the later
A minor Concerto, a rather more ‘affetuoso’ work
with a melancholy cadenza (Ženatý’s own).
Here we find Benda being just a touch too liberal with his expressive
caesurae, just a little artificial and over gallant. The finale,
though, is rollicking good fun.
Ženatý plays in an accomplished way throughout.
He’s not the first person among Czech fiddlers that I’d
think of for this repertoire, but he acquits himself with honour.
He’s one of the more bafflingly inconsistent performers
around on disc, so this is good news.
Benda’s violin music is highly accomplished and highly
polished. I can’t say it’s desperately original,
nor is it always melodically special, but it’s well presented
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.