Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Machet die Tore weit
see end of review for track listing
Kay Johannsen (organ), Michael Aures, Daniel Kartmann (percussion),
Katarzyna Mycka (marimbaphone, vibraphone),
Handel's Companye Continuo
Stuttgarter Hymnus-Chorknaben/Rainer Johannes Homburg
rec. 2-5 June 2011, the Christuskirche, Stuttgart-Gänsheide,
Text included, no translations
MUSIKPRODUKTION DABRINGHAUS UND GRIMM MDG 902 1725-6
Christmastide is a great time for choirs. Concerts attract large
audiences, and there is much repertoire to choose from. There
is also a wide market for discs with Christmas music. This explains
why several of such discs with the Stuttgarter Hymnus-Chorknaben
are on the market. Its present conductor, Rainer Johannes Homburg,
writes in his liner-notes: "Ever since its re-establishment
after 1945, all its directors have presented recordings for
Advent and Christmas."
This choir may not be one of the world's most famous choirs
of boys and men. It has built up a good reputation, in particular
among its former conductor, Gerhard Wilhelm (1918-2009), who
retired in 1987. This disc bears witness to the choir's qualities.
It presents an attractive programme of mostly German music from
the late 16th century to the present time. One of the features
is that the singing is stylish. By that I mean that there is
a clear difference in the way the various pieces are sung dependent
on the time of their composition. The motets by Eccard and Schütz,
for instance, are performed with marked accents on the stressed
syllables and basically non-legato, whereas in the motet O
Heiland, reiß die Himmel auf by Brahms the choir sings
much more legato. In a piece like Fürchtet euch nicht
by Albert Becker, the treatment of dynamics is in accordance
with common practice in the 19th century. The disc closes with
the motet Fürchtet euch nicht by Johann Sebastian
Bach, in which the rhythm is wonderfully exposed, even though
I felt that the choir here is close to its technical limits.
The qualities and the stylistic characteristics of this choir
are such that this disc could have been really good. If ...
the conductor had not come up with the bad idea of arranging
many pieces, in particular the early stuff. These arrangements
mainly involve the addition of various percussion instruments
and/or marimbaphone and vibraphone. The programme opens with
the 6-part Machet die Tore weit by Andreas Hammerschmidt.
It is a mystery to me why it was thought necessary to add percussion.
It doesn't make it any better; qiute the contrary. The same
goes for the two motets by Michael Praetorius. If a choral performance
was thought to be less 'festive', then the addition of period
wind instruments, like cornetts and sackbuts, would have been
a much better option. Although I don't know the original versions
of the pieces by Walther Schmidt and Jean Clanché I can't
imagine that they really need such instruments as marimbabraphone,
vibraphone, crotales or congas. It is no surprise that the unarranged
pieces come off best by far.
One more modern piece whose original I do know is O come
all ye faithful in the arrangement by David Willcocks, here
sung on the text Herbei, o ihr Gläubigen. It’s
a Christmas evergreen in Britain. Homburg even decided to sing
it in the English style, but that doesn't work, which is partly
due to the German text. I am not impressed by the quality of
the German translation anyway, but once again it proves how
hard it is to sing music which is so strongly connected to a
specific text. I have the same feeling here as in English hymns
which were originally based on German music. For some reasons
Willcocks’ famous descant doesn't sound as well in young
German throats as in those of their British counterparts.
The genuine German pieces receive much better performances.
A nice example is Magnificat peregrini toni by Siegfried
Reda in which the organ plays the major role. The choral part
is an arrangement of the melody from the Cantional (1627)
by Johann Hermann Schein, on the German text Meine Seele
erhebt den Herren. Carl Riedel's Kommet, ihr Hirten
is an arrangement of a traditional melody from the early 17th
century. The dynamic contrasts here are handled particularly
All in all, I have mixed feelings about this disc. I admire
the choir's singing and its sense of style, and the unarranged
pieces are done rather well. That makes it even more frustrating
that the oldest pieces in the programme are damaged by arrangements.
Johan van Veen
Track listing Andreas HAMMERSCHMIDT(1612-1675) Machet die Tore weit [1:55] Michael PRAETORIUS(1571-1621) Der Morgenstern ist aufgedrungen [2:40] Walther SCHMIDT(1913-1991) Zu Beth'lem überm Stall [2:27] Michael PRAETORIUS Den die Hirten lobeten sehre (Der Quempas) [5:51]
Heinrich SCHÜTZ(1585-1672) Die Himmel erzählen die Ehre Gottes (SWV 386) [4:07]
Jean CLANCHÉ(no dates given) Wunderbare Freude! Wunderbare Nacht! [5:00] David WILLCOCKS(b.1919) Herbei, o ihr Gläubigen [4:25] Johannes BRAHMS(1833-1897) O Heiland, reiß die Himmel auf, op. 74,2 [4:29]
Johann ECCARD(1553-1611) Nun komm der Heiden Heiland [2:56] David WILLCOCKS O komm, o komm Immanuel [4:09] Michael PRAETORIUS Es ist ein Ros entsprungen [4;20] Siegfried REDA(b.1948) Magnificat peregrini toni [4:44] Johann ECCARD Übers Gebirg Maria ging [2:55] Carl RIEDEL(1827-1888) Kommet, ihr Hirten [1:30] Albert BECKER(1834-1899) Fürchtet euch nicht [2:53] Heinrich SCHÜTZ Also hat Gott die Welt geliebt (SWV 380) [2:29] Johann Sebastian BACH(1685-1750) Fürchte dich nicht (BWV 228) [8:43]
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.