Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
François COUPERIN(1668-1733) Concert No. 1 from the Concerts Royaux [10:51]
Concerts Nos. 5-7 from Les Goûts Réunis, ou Nouveaux
Concerts [9:35; 13:05; 14:23]
Concert No. 8, dans le gout théatral from Les Goûts
Réunis ou Nouveaux Concerts [20:54]
Concert No. 9, intitule Ritratto dell’amore from Les
Goûts Réunis, ou Nouveaux Concerts [17:54]
Concerts Nos. 10-13 from Les Goûts Réunis, ou Nouveaux
Concerts [8:50; 17:02; 6:32; 8:17]
Concert No. 14 et dernier de cet livre from Les Goûts
Réunis, ou Nouveaux Concerts [8:37]
Thomas Indermühle (oboe, oboe d’amore, baritone oboe);
Henk de Wit (bassoon); Ursula Dütschler (harpsichord)
rec. 11-14 December 1995, The English Reformed Church, Amsterdam and
22-25 March 1991, Kirche Blumenstein, Switzerland
CAMERATA CM-15045-6 [68:48 + 67:12]
The booklet notes for this release open with a funny sentence,
“King Louis XIV could afford the best of everything, which
is probably why the finest wines of his time are no longer to
be had.” I’d always wondered why you can never find
the early 18th vintages on the supermarket shelves
and here’s the answer, King Louis XIV drank the lot.
François Couperin was in the employ of King Louis XIV,
who had his musicians perform weekly chamber music concerts
in the last years of his life. After the king died in 1715 Couperin
had an opportunity to bring these works together, and in 1722
he published the “Concerts royaux” and in 1724,
“Les Goûts réunis ou Nouveaux Concerts”.
We’ve come across oboist Thomas Indermühle before
on these pages, with concertos by Telemann and Albinoni, and his teamwork with bassoonist Henk de Wit and harpsichord
player Ursula Dütschler is excellent. These performances
are all very stylish and elegant, and one can imagine the king
being royally entertained.
It is good to have as many of these works collected together
in one place, though some change in instrumental timbre beyond
oboe in such an extensive programme might have been welcome.
Thomas Indermühle has been cloned to give us an oboe duet
in the Menuet en Trio of Concert No. 1 which is
a convincing effect, but otherwise it is an awful lot of reeds
and plucking tangents. The harpsichord in this Camerata production
might also have recorded with a little more body in the sound.
The balance is decent enough, but there are more upper harmonics
in evidence than lower resonance, which would have helped in
filling out the harmonies. The recordings in two different locations
are highly compatible and there are no serious jolts from one
to the other, though of the two the Amsterdam church in the
Begijnhof is a touch less resonant.
I’ve had a listen to the Barthold Kuijken’s single
disc selection on the Accent label, ACC23153, the flute and
cello mix having a gentler and more rounded feel to the sound.
Avie Records has a nicely sonorous strings and harpsichord only
programme from Les Goûts Réunis on AV2132,
showing another of the many ways in which these pieces can be
presented. I’m not sure how the king would have responded
to this rather melancholy picture, and Thomas Indermühle’s
oboe is certainly a more overtly lyrical option. The long and
short of it is that this two disc set is more one to dip into
as the mood takes rather than to be heard in one sitting, which
in any case is certainly not how they originally would have
The sprightly dance movements in this recording are done with
tremendous élan, the more plangent Gravement sections
not overly weighed down with artificially sought emotional cares,
the Tendrement and other moods nicely poised and performed
with courtly taste. If you are a fan of this period and national
style, then this recording will appeal greatly. Be aware however,
that other instrumentations are available.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.