(1864 – 1949) Elektra (1909)
Linda Watson (soprano) – Elektra; Jane Henschel (soprano) – Klytämnestra;
Manuela Uhl (soprano) – Chrysothemis; René Kollo (tenor) – Aegisth;
Albert Dohmen (bass-baritone) – Orest; Andreas Hörl (bass) – Orest’s
tutor; Jörg Schneider (tenor) – A young servant; Carsten Sabrowski
(bass) – An old servant; Irmgard Vilsmaier (soprano) – An overseer;
Philharmonia Chor Wien, Münchner Philharmoniker/Christian Thielemann
Original stage production: Herbert Wernicke
Restaging Director: Bettina Göschl
Stage adaptation: Frank Kuhlmann, Christoph Lettow
Costume adaptation: Dorothee Melzer
Light adaptation: Felix Kirchhofer, Christian Kass
Video Director: Andreas Morell
rec. live, Festspielhaus, Baden-Baden, 29 January, 1, 4 February
Audio formats: LPCM 2.0, DTS Digital Surround
Picture format: 16:9
Extra features: Cast gallery; Making of Elektra
OPUS ARTE OA 1046 D
Is there an opera as spine-chilling and heart-rending as Elektra?
Maybe there is and if so I haven’t yet seen it. Strauss himself
also seems to have seen no way to continue in this direction.
Elektra became a dead-end and when he returned from darkness
and desperation two years later he had moved to the sunny side
of the street – or almost anyway – with the high society comedy
Der Rosenkavalier. It was a success and it was this more
accessible road that Strauss took during his operatic life –
to the dismay of some avant-gardists who had seen the composer
as a figure-head of early 20th century modernism.
I do have a soft spot for Rosenkavalier and I don’t mind
seeing the following operas either but Elektra grabs
me by the throat in a way that is abominable but still enticing.
This production, originally created for the Bayerische Staatsoper
in Munich in 1997, gripped me in the same way as the recent
Stockholm production (review)
did. And there are similarities, but even more so with the previous
Stockholm production, mentioned in the review: sparse sets but
evocative lighting, no props. Like the recent Stockholm production
red is the symbolic colour – revenge. Yes, there is a staircase
and there is a prop: again as in Stockholm Elektra carries an
axe, the weapon with which her father Agamemnon was murdered.
The lighting isn’t flattering for the characters; facial expressions
become grotesque through the black shadows.
Whereas one in the theatre is fairly distanced from the action
– though in Stockholm one felt drawn into it by the surge of
the music and the acting – in this video realization Andreas
Morell works very much with close-ups and thus automatically
one is caught in the middle of the proceedings. There is always
a risk that the video producer wants to point out something
else than I want to see, but in so concentrated a drama as Elektra
there are mostly clear-cut choices and one is –like it or not
– caught from the outset. It says a lot, however, for the magic
of the Stockholm production, that even in a seat fifteen metres
from the stage one felt totally engulfed by the action.
The singing in Stockholm in mid-December 2009 was terrific and
here in Baden-Baden just a month and a half later the vocal
quality is hardly less impressive. Linda Watson has for the
last decade been one of the leading sopranos in the hochdramatische
Fach and she is formidable. Intense, fearless, brilliant. Jane
Henschel’s Klytämnestra is another superb singing-actor,
insinuating and sarcastic. And she sings with a golden tone
that totally belies her age. Manuela Uhl has also made Chrysothemis
something of a speciality, singing with silvery yet intense
tone. Albert Dohmen, one of the foremost exponents of Wotan,
may look more like a bank clerk than a Greek hero in his black
suit, but he is a wolf in sheep’s clothing and he sings powerfully.
It is uplifting to find that René Kollo, well past seventy,
has retained so much of his voice, considering all the exhausting
Wagner roles he has been singing for so many years. His Aegisth
is a jovial character in white dinner-jacket. It seems, in other
words, that the men in this production are in present time while
the women remain in ancient times. The symbolism in this contradiction
eludes me – but no matter: this is a terrific Elektra,
conducted with the required intensity by Christian Thielemann.
I will without doubt return to it again for pleasure – well,
pleasure is not really the proper word for Elektra, but
you see what I mean – and that’s recommendation enough. But
I wish the Stockholm production could be issued as well.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.