This recording has a lot of competition. Even Naxos have two
other versions of the Third Concerto available: Grumiaux in
their Classical Archives series (9.80608),
and the 1994 Dong-Suk Kang recording (8.550752),
which might well have been the first version owned by many listeners.
Does it make sense to market another CD of these works, particularly
of the Third? In the current financial climate, almost certainly
not - neither Fanny Clamagirand nor the Sinfonia Finlandia Jyväskylä,
nor indeed Patrick Gallois, can really be considered names sufficiently
'big' to trigger loyalty buying.
Fortunately for music-lovers, Naxos often appear not to let
profitability be their chief concern. Curious as it may seem,
this appears to be their first recording of the First and Second
Concertos. More to the point, this is a CD crammed with beautiful
Clamagirand has a fine, warm tone, ideal for this kind of music.
This is her first major recording for Naxos - previously appearing
only as soloist in Georges Taconet's Violin Sonata on Marco
Polo in 2005. On this form, it is a safe bet that it will
not be her last. Few outside Finland will likely be very familiar
with the Sinfonia Finlandia Jyväskylä; their name will not roll
off the tongues of many non-Finns! Yet the group has been making
music for half a century or so and their Naxos CDs of Haydn,
have been reviewed here. Their experience shows in these recordings:
they deliver practically faultless performances, deftly guided
by the reliable Patrick Gallois.
Saint-Saëns may not be the most profound of composers, but as
an inventive melodist he is virtually unsurpassed. Many music-lovers
will be familiar with the Third Violin Concerto in B minor,
op.61, particularly the gorgeous slow(ish) movement; it still
finds an occasional spot in the concert repertoire. Yet the
other two concertos also deserve a place, written as they are
with listener enjoyment in mind, rather than intellectual dissection.
The First (published) Concerto in A, op.20is better described
as concise rather than short. Bright and instantly memorable,
it would make a superb encore piece for the intrepid concert
soloist. The Second (published) Concerto in C, op.58 is, despite
the opus number, a relatively early work, written a year before
the First. It is both stylish and dramatic, particularly in
the first movement - which is actually longer than the First
Concerto - and the unusual, almost Sicilian-sounding second.
The recording is very good, with an excellent balance between
orchestra and soloist. For good measure and no obvious reason,
there is a postcard-style photo of the Seine at dusk on the
As far as this disc is concerned, no one should let the Naxos
price differential be the only consideration: this is quality
music in quality performances.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.