Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Heinrich von HERZOGENBERG (1843–1900) Sechs Mädchenlieder von Paul Heyse Op. 98 [12:30] (7)
Kanons aus dem neugrichischen Liebes-Skollen von Goethe Op. 79 (excerpts) [7.32] (1,2,3)
Acht Lieder und Romanzen Op. 26 (excerpts) [11.11] (7)
Nachtlied [5.08] (1, 4, 5, 6)
Vier Notturnos (Gedichte von Joseph von Eichendorff) op. 22 [16.44] (7)
Iris-Anna Deckert (soprano) (1); Sarah Wegener (soprano) (2); Anja Bittner (soprano) (3); Ursula Eittinger (alto) (4); Andreas Weller (tenor) (5); Manfred Bittner (bass) (6); Gotz Payer (piano); Ensemble cantissimo (7)/Markus Utz
rec. Radiostudio, Zurich, 14 October 2010 and the Konservatorium Winterthur, Konzertsall, 11 February 2011
CARUS 83.451 [51.42]
In the CD booklet for this new disc of music for choir and vocal
ensemble, the composer Heinrich von Herzogenberg is described
as best known for his church music. In fact I had never heard
a note of his music but know him from Ethel Smyth’s autobiography
‘Impressions that Remained’. Smyth describes Herzogenberg in
these terms, “A more learned musician can never have existed”,
she continues saying that “he used to compose for a given number
of hours daily and as may be guessed the result was often dry”.
Leipzig-based Herzogenberg and his wife became friends of Smyth’s
when she studied in Leipzig and in fact Herzogenberg eventually
became Smyth’s teacher.
Sechs Mädchenlieder von Paul Heyseare
for 3-part women’s chorus and piano. They set a cycle of poems
which cover the emotional life of a woman from imminent marriage,
disillusion, love, unfulfilled desire and finally self-determination.
It is not clear when they were written but they were probably
designed for the Musik Hochschule where Herzogenberg taught.
They are coolly creditable, firmly in the Mendelssohn-Brahms
axis as opposed to the Liszt/Wagner one. The booklet describes
them as masterly, but to me the music fails to capture the strength
of character in the poems; the songs sound a little too much
like the teaching exercise that they probably were. That said,
they are cleanly and nicely sung by the ensemble cantissimo
and might usefully find their way into the repertoire of all
The Kanons op. 79 for three sopranos were written
for a colleague’s singing class. Here we are given three of
the five. They were written after Herzogenberg heard Brahms’s
Kanonsand decided he could do better.
I have to confess that I have never heard Brahms’s versions,
but here again Herzogenberg provides music which is nicely correct
but fails to grab the attention. Soloists Iris-Anna Deckert,
Sarah Wegener and Anja Bittner blend beautifully in the songs.
In 1879 Herzogenberg published eight 4-part female voice choruses
as Acht Lieder und Romanzen, here ensemble cantissimo
contribute three of them. Herzogenberg was the conductor of
the Leipzig Bach-Verein and, we are told, greatly valued pure
singing. Two years before the publication of these songs he
had founded a choir school for the ladies of the choir, these
songs were undoubtedly practice material.
Finally the Vier Notturnossetting Eichendorff
poems. Eichendorff was Herzogenberg’s favourite poet and Herzogenberg
set his poems throughout his composing career; these songs date
from 1876. The title Notturno was often applied to piano
music, but here Herzogenberg uses it for vocal music which is
themed on the night. The four songs are in distinctively contrasted
styles and the results are attractive. But again, despite the
clean performances I found myself thinking of didactic material.
These are preceded by another night piece, Nachtliedfrom Drei Gesange nach Dichtungen von Friedrich Hebbel;
this time for mixed voice ensemble. The male voices make an
interesting relief in the programme.
Heinrich von Herzogenberg perhaps deserves to be better known
as a composer, but this disc is not the disc to improve his
reputation. The performances are excellent, doing Herzogenberg
a great service, but the music seems more suited to the rehearsal
room. Nothing on the disc remotely approaches the vividness
or intensity which Herzogenberg’s great contemporaries such
as Brahms could achieve in this repertoire.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.