Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
Pierre de LA RUE (c.1460-1518) CD1 Magnificat Tone IV [15:05] Magnificat Tone I [12:11] Salve regina V [8:20] Magnificat Tone VII [10:45] Magnificat Tone II [10:46] ANONYMOUS (15th, 16th centuries)
Antiphon, 'Sancta Maria succurre miseris' [01:44] Antiphon, 'Tribus miraculis' [01:32] Antiphon, 'Dedit mihi Dominus pennas'
[00:30] Antiphon, 'Virgo gloriosa' [00:51] CD2 Pierre de LA RUE
Salve regina II [10:05] Magnificat Tone VI [13:05] Magnificat Tone VIII [12:54] Salve regina IV [8:08] Magnificat Tone V [11:00] ANONYMOUS Antiphon, 'O quam gloriosum est regnum' [00:54] Antiphon, 'Dum medium silentium' [01:00] Antiphon, 'Bene omnia fecit' [00:23]
((Deirdre Brown (soprano); Mary Beth Campbell (soprano)*;
Cynthia Gates (soprano); Charmian Harvey (soprano)*; Marie
Magistry (soprano); Carole Therien
(soprano); Dan Cabena (alto); Lori Henig (alto); Josée Lalonde (alto); Éric Tremblay
(alto); Stephen Bélanger (tenor); Bernard Cayouette (tenor); Micah Lamb (tenor);
Garth MacPhee (tenor); Martin Auclair (bass)*; Alfred Lagrenade (bass); Philippe
Martel (bass); Normand Richard (bass); Yves Saint-Amant (bass) [* sing in Magnificat
I, Magnificat VI only])/Peter Schubert rec. August, 2005; June 2006, l’Église
de la Visitation Montréal, Canada. DDD NAXOS 8.557896-97 [61:53
Pierre de La Rue (c.1460-1518)
was of Josquin’s (c.1440-1521)
generation. His compositional skills made use of old and
new techniques: imitative textures and new ways to achieve
a variety of effects and elicit a variety of emotions in
five- and six-part writing for example. Yet for this innovation,
remarkably little of his output is in the current catalogue:
a Clerks’ Group Gaudeamus (307) CD with the third Salve
Regina is closest; masses on Naxos 8.554656, and
the rest anthologies. So this is a significant – and warmly
welcomed - release. The
singing of Montréal-based VivaVoce is clean and characterful.
Because the texture of La Rue is not so dense as that of
Josquin, there is a greater emphasis on the individual singers
than on unified ensemble sound. It’s more of collection of
soloists. Which is not to imply any lack of polish or roughness.
In fact, the singing – the voices are very closely miked – is
real and personal with a note of purpose and urgency throughout.
The bases, of which there are five - as many as the higher
registers - are particularly earthy and compelling; the articulation
clear and unfussy. Although
Peter Schubert - who studied under Boulanger - founded VivaVoce
almost ten years ago, their discography is not a large one
yet. The characterful and precise performances on this CD
might change that.
La Rue seems likely to have been born some time between
1452 and 1465, depending on whether documentary evidence
for Peter van Straaten can be taken as referring (also) to
Pierre de La Rue. What we do know is that he worked for most
of his life in the Habsburg-Burgundian chapel in the service of the Burgundian
Dukes who lived and travelled throughout what is roughly
It’s said that the tragic life of Marguerite of Austria
- a member of the aristocratic family with whom La Rue seems
to have had a special link - inspired her fondness for sad
chansons, and that this informed some of La Rue’s work. It
seems just as probable that his extensive travel with the
court offered him a multiplicity of musical experiences and
styles on which to draw for his own plangent way of writing.
In either case, it was Pierre de La Rue who was the first
composer anywhere to complete a series of polyphonic Magnificat settings.
They are somewhat restrained and, although there is joy in
them, it is a veiled, mild one.
The Magnificat is a biblical song from St. Luke’s
Gospel sung by the Virgin Mary at her first awareness of
the importance of the child to which she was shortly to give
birth. It was first sung to a plain melody at the end of
Vespers, preceded and succeeded by antiphons appropriate
to the time of year. Since such a melody was chosen to accord
with the antiphons’ mode(s), there are eight possible Magnificat ‘tone’s.
We know La Rue set all eight throughout his life. He strove
to make them all different in feel and atmosphere - but we
no longer have the ‘Tone III’. They are for four voices (Tones
II, IV, V, VII and VIII), five (Tone VI) and six (Tone I)
and employ such techniques as mensuration canon, different
registers to evoke singers’ different ages and parallel motion.
The Salve Regina is one of four Marian antiphons
for the end of Compline (the final office of the day) and
for special Marian services. A favourite of La Rue’s, he
composed six such laudatory settings. We hear three on these
two discs; they use contemporary chansons and quote melodies
by Dufay and Binchois, which must have been an attempt to
arrogate to the Habsburg-Burgundian court some of the prestige
of those great and greatly-respected musicians. Because of
the intimate relationship between these compositions and
a composer like La Rue, Peter Schubert
has included half a dozen or so short antiphons to reinforce
the notion that even the such profound and elevated music
as La Rue’s here had a context.
In the case of both the Magnificats and Salve
Reginas alternating verses are sung in chant (odd-numbered
verses) and polyphony (even) – except for the second Salve
Regina: each work, of course, has the text in common.
None of the works is longer than fifteen minutes; this
is ample time for La Rue to establish, develop and amplify
the themes as needed. It also means that the CDs can be – and
have been – easily arranged to offer the maximum variety… the
three types of music (antiphon, Magnificat and Salve
Regina) alternate and make for a very stimulating listening
experience given the concentration of formas.
As noted, La Rue’s music isn’t so rich as that of Josquin.
It takes but a few minutes of listening to the music on this
welcome pair of CDs, though, to appreciate why La Rue was
held in such high esteem in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries.
His music is focused and bright yet profound without being
overly complicated. These are qualities which Schubert and
VivaVoce have done well to concentrate on communicating.
The recording is clean, if a little on the dry side; the
liner notes ample; the texts (those, of course, of the Magnificat and Salve
Regina are essentially repeated) are reproduced in Latin
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.