Havergal BRIAN (1876-1972)
Symphony No. 2 in E minor (1930-31) [53:28] Festival Fanfare (1967) [1:44]
Orchestra/Tony Rowe. DDD
rec. Mosfilm Studio, Moscow, May 1996 NAXOS 8.570506 [55:12]
welcoming Brian's Fourth Symphony recently (8.570308 - see
review), it is a pleasure to report on a further reissue of the
music of this important composer. Originally on Marco Polo 8.223790,
this Second Symphony becomes a must-buy at the cheaper price
begin, though, with the 1967 Festival
one brass-only work. It is one of the last works we know
of by the composer. Its argument is terse but confident.
The performance here mirrors this confidence.
earlier Second Symphony (1930/31) is scored for typically
huge orchestra, including two pianos, three sets of timpani,
organ and 16 horns - although strangely only eight are used
in the present recording. Although in four movements, Naxos
has allocated several track points to each movement, a real
help when interacting with Malcom MacDonald's superb notes.
by Goethe, specifically the early drama, Götz von
Berlichingen, each movement allegedly concerns
a specific character trait of Götz: the first,
resolution; the second, domestic piety; the third, battle;
the fourth, death. Textures are often complex but never blurred.
of the playing leaves a little to be desired, but Brian's
demands are harsh, after all. The mysterious foreboding of
the symphony’s opening leads to some strained playing from
the strings but
there is no denying that the atmosphere is there.
There are contrasts in this first movement, but they have
to be heard in context; thus the second subject, whilst suave
and delicate, never really gives any true balm or hope. Brian’s
inspiration takes flight in the Andante sostenuto e molto
espressivo second movement, where there is a lovely use
of solo violin, although the soloist seems rather recessed
in the overall sound picture.
By far the briefest
movement, the Scherzo only lasts around six minutes. The horns
come into their own here, with antiphonal calls chasing each
other over string poundings. MacDonald is absolutely correct
to identify the Wagnerian elements in the finale: “Siegfried’s
Funeral March” from Götterdämmerung. Brian plans the music
so it moves towards a massive climax that is cruelly cut short,
to be followed by some stunningly beautiful harmonies in the
lower strings. The haunting end leaves one in a sort of stunned
I keep on asking
myself is there no end to Brian's invention? We are privileged
to be able to hear these scores at all, and it is good that
the Moscow Orchestra gives its all for the Brianesque cause.
We need much more of the same ...
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.