MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews

FOGHORN Classics

Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews

All HDTT reviews

Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World

all Nimbus reviews

all tudor reviews

Follow us on Twitter

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger

Buy through MusicWeb for £53.50 postage paid World-wide see details:

Purchase button


Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
The Collector’s Edition

Includes symphonies, concertos, chamber music, piano sonatas, sacred music, Fidelio, and lieder
Various artists recorded 1957-1996
Full listing here and at end of this review
EMI CLASSICS 3877392 50 CDs [c.55 hours]

[Also available here Mozart and Schubert boxes]

This is one of three big boxes from EMI – the others feature Mozart and Schubert – which represent something of a departure for a major company. EMI have probably issued comparable size boxes before but most probably in anniversary or complete edition mode, and undoubtedly costing more than this one which comes in at hardly more than 1 a disc. That territory belongs to the likes of Brilliant Classics who issued some 40 disc boxes of major composers about three years ago at under 1 per disc. I am not sure quite who these very cheap mega-boxes are aimed at but we’ll come back to that later.

The arbitrary number of 50 CDs probably fits Beethoven quite well – better than Mozart or Schubert – because this does allow coverage of just about all his major works. Reviewing the list of those played here against a catalogue of the composer’s published opuses, there is not much missing – a couple of overtures, the two string quintets, woodwind trio and horn sonata seem to be the most important items not included. And these could probably have been squeezed in – I presume that suitable recordings were not to hand. There are not many "WoOs" but there again few, if any, of Beethoven’s unpublished works are masterpieces. So, in terms of coverage, this set would give you a recording of almost everything significant that Beethoven wrote.

Next I will give you an overview of the box and then we’ll come back to the different elements in more detail; this section is really about testing out whether you might just be interested. In physical terms, it is only about the size of a CD case cubed – a very positive feature – and some of the artists are listed on the side. Karajan and Giulini are at the top of the list although they conduct but one and two works respectively, albeit major ones. Once one has mastered how to open the box, essentially by dismantling it, the contents look crammed but there is quite a lot of extraneous cardboard inside to hold the paper-thin disc envelopes in place. For one moment I mistook the cardboard for two chunky booklets but, in terms of documentation, there is simply a track listing. Dates of recordings are given in years and on a "wholesale" basis – for example the piano sonatas are noted as 1968-1974. The earliest date seems to be 1957 so it seems likely that all are in stereo and the two violin romances from 1996 appear to be the only digital recordings. They seem to be there merely to allow "ADD/DDD" to be claimed. Shame on you EMI, particularly as Menuhin’s performances of these works would have done nicely and legitimately allowed another big name to be placed on the side on the box. Most of the material is from the late 1950s and 1960s and some of it may be having a last outing before EMI lose the exclusivity of the copyright. Nevertheless, apart from the odd exception, the sound quality should not be a deterrent. As we will see, most of these recordings are worth having and few of them are otherwise available at the moment.

For the most part, the various genres are effectively complete sets by the same artists – the major exception is the piano concertos for which Emil Gilels plays the first, second and fourth, and Bruno Leonardo Gelber plays the third and fifth. The symphonies and overtures are played by the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra under André Cluytens, and the soloist in the violin concerto is David Oistrakh. The piano sonatas are the work of Eric Heidsieck who also partners Paul Tortelier in the cello sonatas. In the violin sonatas Christian Ferras is accompanied by Pierre Barbizet. The string quartets are the later recordings of the Hungarian String Quartet and the Hungarian Trio feature in the piano trios - they were two completely separate groups. The Melos Ensemble play the large chamber works: the Piano Quintet, Sextet, Septet and Octet. In the sacred choral music we get Giulini’s Missa Solemnis and Mass in C. Fidelio is Karajan’s 1971 recording featuring Jon Vickers and Helga Dernesch in the leading roles. The final disc has Birgit Nilsson singing Ah, Perfido! and Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau singing lieder. So, if enough of that appeals, read on!

Symphonies and Overtures

The cycle of symphonies recorded by André Cluytens with the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra in the late 1950s is consistently good. It was once a mainstay of the Classics for Pleasure LP catalogue and has been out on CD before on Royal Classics. The sound is indistinguishable from that issue with quality which is about average for its early stereo vintage although rather light in the bass. It will be interesting to see what the likes of Mark Obert-Thorn or Andrew Rose can do with it when the copyright expires in a year or two. The playing of the Berlin Philharmonic is highly committed throughout the cycle without being as pristine as it later was in Karajan’s cycles for DG. In terms of interpretations, the Eroica and the Choral symphonies are not quite as stirring as they can be but the fifth, sixth and seventh symphonies are readings of the highest order. In the Pastoral symphony Cluytens captures perfectly the spirit of each movement and, if there is a better version of this work on record, I haven’t yet heard it. In the ninth symphony Cluytens takes a generally spacious view. Frederick Guthrie is a slightly disappointing bass soloist but the other vocal contributions hit the spot, particularly tenor Nicolai Gedda. The same forces also give us six overtures in the same vein with the Leonoras being represented by No. 3.


David Oistrakh is the soloist in the violin concerto, a reading emphasising beauty and notable for a very long-breathed first movement. He is well supported by Cluytens, here conducting French radio orchestral forces. Afterwards John Lill plays the solo part in the wonderful Choral Fantasy with its pre-echoes of the ninth symphony. Alexander Gibson directs the erstwhile Scottish National Orchestra – and presumably their chorus although this is not stated – in a splendid reading, again coming from the Classics for Pleasure LP catalogue. These recordings have come up well on CD but the sound quality in the other concerto recordings is generally much less convincing. The Triple Concerto takes the wooden spoon in the whole box in this regard. Lev Oborin is the pianist but his piano seems to be in a world of its own or possibly in a bathroom. David Oistrakh and Sviatoslav Knushevitsky are more central to the sound picture and the late 1950s Philharmonia Orchestra is conducted by Sir Malcolm Sargent. As an interpretation it is fair enough but it is hard to believe EMI doesn’t have something better sounding in the vaults. The Gilels recordings of the first and second piano concertos have rather better sound but, as in other recordings from EMI France of the period, they are light in the bass. Gilels is sometimes wayward – for example in the slow movement of the first concerto which is taken at an exaggeratedly slow tempo. He also lingers a little in the slow movement of the second concerto but less intrusively and there is real poetry here. He is nothing short of majestic throughout the fourth concerto which was recorded with the Philharmonia Orchestra under Leopold Ludwig in markedly better sound – this is one of the gems of the box. Bruno Leonardo Gelber’s third and fifth were made about a decade later with the New Philharmonia Orchestra under Ferdinand Leitner. Gelber‘s readings are powerful conceptions and he is well supported by Leitner. Tempi tend towards extremes and just occasionally the music almost runs away from him. The recorded sound is rather inconsistent – mostly it is unobtrusive but there are some patches of hardness and unnatural piano tone. Overall, the concertos are a mixed bag that made me hanker for the likes of Perahia and Kovacevich but I shall certainly return to Gilels in the fourth piano concerto.

String quartets

The Hungarian String Quartet’s 1960s cycle sounds well and is made up of consistently well-played if not very distinctive readings. Whilst the greatness that beckons from the last of the Op.18 quartets is here evident – the slow introduction to the finale is magnificently played – the Razumovsky’s are less successful, particularly Op.59 No 3. The next quartet – The Harp – almost makes up for that and with No. 12 the Hungarians step up a gear. Their readings of the late works lack a little of the intensity of the Lindsays and more closely resemble the Talich quartet’s approach. Ultimately this is easier listening if less moving. The Groβe Fuge is included in its original place in Op.130, which is fair enough, and the finale which was written to replace it follows on. Oddly, having followed the published order all the way to the last two quartets, these are reversed when Op.135 could easily have fitted on the same disc as Op.132. These recordings on LP were my introduction to the Beethoven quartets and I enjoyed revisiting them.


The Piano trios included here are the six works in the regular canon plus the early trio in E flat (WoO38), two sets of variations (Kakadu and Op.44) and the single movement Allegretto, all played by the Hungarian Trio. The Op.11 trio is given in the clarinet version with André Boutard as the clarinettist. These recordings date from about 1960 and sound well for their age. The Hungarian Trio proves to be a reliable guide and in its hands the merits of the three works Beethoven published as Op.1 are readily appreciated. They are also very fine in the later works – the two Op.70 trios and the Archduke. In the latter they find fun in scherzo and plumb the depths of the slow movement most affectingly. Beethoven’s string trios are all early works – the opus numbers are 3, 8 and 9 with the latter being a set of three works, all in standard four movement format. The earliest work interpolates two extra minuets and Op. 8 has five movements and the title Serenade. These five works are effectively performed by the Trio à cordes Francais.

Miscellaneous chamber works

Tucked away in the middle of the set on CDs 33 and 34 are two discs of relatively rare music for small forces. The first of these starts with four works for mandolin and harpsichord. Marked Siciliano, Allegro, Adagio and Andante with variations respectively they form represent a charming suite without ever sounding like Beethoven. Apparently they were first performed in 1796 but I haven’t been able to find out anything else about them. The Op.25 flute Serenade is reasonably familiar and Michel Debost’s flute is a joy to hear. He also plays in the trio for flute, bassoon and piano WoO37 which follows. In this work bassoonist Amaury Wallez has no walk on part and the combination works well. The opener on disc 34 is a B flat flute sonata in four movements which is attributed to Beethoven although Grove online lists it in the "doubtful authenticity" category and it doesn’t even have a WoO number. There follows ten of the Airs variés for flute and piano, an assortment from Opp.105 and 107 in no particular order. These seem to be inspired by folk-songs from various places around Europe. Debost is partnered by pianist Christian Ivaldi throughout the disc, all of which is pleasant enough – the lighter side of the great man.

About ten discs later on the Melos Ensemble play the chamber works for larger forces – the Piano/Wind Quintet, Sextet with two horns, Septet and Wind Octet. These are all excellent performances decently recorded. The Quintet is a relatively early work modelled on Mozart’s K452 but by no means superior to it. The Septet is well-known but less deserving of it than the Sextet Op. 81b and Octet Op.103, both marvellously original works dating from 1810 and around 1792 respectively - the opus number of the latter is misleading.

Violin and cello sonatas

The ten violin sonatas are represented by the generally easy-going readings of Christian Ferras from the very end of the 1950s. His often sweet tone was well-captured by the recording and he had a sympathetic accompanist in Pierre Barbizet. There are few ups and downs although the A major sonata Op.30 No.1 isn’t totally convincing. Otherwise this is a cycle of increasing power, properly peaking with the last three sonatas. The Kreutzer is particularly fine and Op.96 has poise and restrained lyricism. This repertoire has been dominated by Perlman and Ashkenazy on Decca for many years; these readings do not reach their heights but are nevertheless a valid alternative.

Paul Tortelier features on two discs containing the five cello sonatas and three sets of variations – on themes from Judas Maccabeus and Die Zauberflöte. He is partnered by Eric Heidsieck who is sympathetic and much less erratic than in his recordings of the piano sonatas (see below). Tortelier’s approach is generally lyrical and slightly restrained although he does cut loose at the right moments, notably in the greatest of the sonatas – the A major Op.69. I enjoyed these readings immensely – definitely one of the jewels of this box although it is worth noting that they are available separately as a bargain twofer (569422-2).

Piano music

Eric Heidsieck’s readings of the piano sonatas are frustratingly variable and, arguably, the principal Achilles heel of the set. In the early works in particular he is very free with variations in tempo. I was sometime left feeling that Beethoven was at the service of his considerable virtuosity rather than the reverse. In general, this is a cycle which improves as one goes through it but there are some significant disappointments in both early and late works – most notably Op.10 No.3 and the Hammerklavier, both of which have outer movements which sound quite mannered. The Pastorale is engaging in the outer movements but spoilt by perverse basic tempi in a very brisk Andante and turgid scherzo. Heidsieck certainly took Beethoven’s tempo marking of Presto seriously and had the technique to do so. Unfortunately though, the finales of the Moonlight and Appassionata only just avoid running away from him. There are some successes – notably Op.7, Op.22 and the Waldstein. Some of the smaller, more relaxed works such as Opp.54 and 78 also go rather well. Heidsieck turns the Rondo finale of Op.49 No.1 into a creation that sounds as the opus number might reflect when it was written. Since the work was probably the very first, this might not be considered an advantage. In the great final trilogy Heidsieck is at his very best in Op.111 which is a finely sustained reading. The recorded sound is perfectly acceptable – and consistent – but I don’t think this cycle would be a good choice as one’s only versions of the sonatas. I would rate it some way behind Daniel Barenboim’s EMI series which was made in same period.

Apart from the sonatas there are three other discs of piano music in the box – one with the Diabelli variations, one of the bagatelles and one of odds and ends with the Eroica variations being much the most important work. The first two and most of the third are played by Georges Solchany who was the pianist of the Hungarian Trio. The Diabelli variations are well-played technically but sound a bit literal at times and this is no match for the fantasy of Stephen Kovacevich (then Bishop) who made a recording for Philips at around the same time (1970). In the bagatelles Solchany plays all of the Opp.33, 119 and 126 sets and a couple of extras. He captures their frequent quirkiness well and I found this disc most enjoyable. The Eroica variations are good too although the rest of the items on disc 19 are among the least essential works in the set – for example the God save the King variations, here played by Georges Cziffra.

Choral Music

Beethoven’s sacred choral music is represented by three works on three discs – the Missa Solemnis, Mass in C and Oratorio Christ on the Mount of Olives. The latter is a rarity and its opus number of 85 does not reflect its composition in 1803. The performance comes from Bonn in 1970 and is directed by Volker Wangerheim. Nicolai Gedda is in good voice as Christ in a work which Beethoven seems to pay homage to Bach. Both masses are conducted by Carlo Maria Giulini with London-based forces recorded in the 1970s. Soloists are starry - Janet Baker is mezzo-soprano in both works – and the recorded sound is decent. Thirty-plus years on Giulini’s deliberate approach seems old-fashioned although the dedication shines through. The end results though, particularly in the Missa Solemnis, seem to me to suffer from the lack of momentum.


Karajan’s 1970 Fidelio doesn’t seem to be otherwise available at the moment. As one would expect, the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra plays superbly and it is well-recorded. Compared to the Klemperer recording made a few years earlier by EMI it is relatively light in feeling, both less dramatic and atmospheric. For example the opening scene of Act II doesn’t feel like it is set in a dungeon. Jon Vickers – also Florestan for Klemperer – is excellent and Helga Dernesch sings Leonore very well. There is a smattering of dialogue which often seems understated. The booklet credits Karl Ridderbusch as the villain Don Pizarro and fails to name Rocco. Two other sources I have checked indicate that Zoltan Keleman sings Pizarro and Ridderbusch sings Rocco.


On the final disc, Ah, perfido! comes off very well for Birgit Nilsson who is accompanied by the Philharmonia Orchestra under Heinz Wallberg. The late-1950s sound quality for the lieder which make up the rest of the disc is less sympathetic but Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau is in very fine voice. In the great cycle An die ferne Geliebte he is wonderfully accompanied by Gerald Moore making this is a most treasurable version.


This review comes with the caveat that, although in a few cases I knew the recording already, it is based on only one hearing of each disc during an intensive month of listening to Beethoven and almost nothing else. It has generally been a positive experience. Unsurprisingly there are some highs and lows but perhaps the general level of artistic and technical consistency throughout the box is worthy of some emphasis. There are just a few records I would not want to be without – Cluytens in the Pastoral symphony, Gilels in the fourth piano concerto, Tortelier in the third cello sonata and Fischer Dieskau in An die ferne Geliebte spring most readily to mind. There is probably just one piece that I will only play again if pressed – the Triple Concerto – and most of the rest fall into the worthy enough category.

To return to the question of who is this box for? The relative newcomer to collecting recorded classical music should really be discovering a range of composers before they cover one as broadly as is done here but, if they are set on acquiring a large dose of Beethoven cheaply, this would certainly fit the bill. People like myself who grew up with some of these recordings in LP days might want to revisit the era and plug some gaps in the collection, and it would make a good present for them. Perhaps it could be bought between a few friends and shared out or passed round on a timeshare basis? Of course it is always better to run horses for courses but the price gain here is very considerable. Two EMI budget boxes covering the symphonies, piano concertos and piano sonatas – Klemperer and Barenboim are the principal artists – occupy 19 CDs and currently cost almost exactly the same as these 50 discs. I have both these sets and, although they are generally preferable to the versions in this box, if forced to choose, I would now part with them before this box.

The final word should be about the composer whose marvellous music is real reason for considering this set - don’t roll over yet Beethoven. If you can agree with that perhaps you should be checking out this box.

Patrick C Waller

Full track-listing

CD 1
Symphonie n1 en ut majeur Op.21
Symphonie n3 en mi bémol majeur Op.55 Héroïque
Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens

CD 2
Symphonie n2 en ré majeur Op.36
Symphonie n4 en si bémol majeur Op.60
Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens

CD 3
Symphonie n5 en ut mineur Op.67
Symphonie n7 en la majeur Op.92
Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens

CD 4 71.29
Symphonie n6 en fa majeur Op.68 Pastorale
Symphonie n8 en fa majeur Op.93
Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens

CD 5
Symphonie n9 en ré mineur Op.125 avec chœurs
Gré Brouwenstijn soprano – Kerstin Meyer contralto / Nicolaï Gedda ténor – Frederike Guthrie basse
Chœurs de la Cathédrale Sainte-Hedwige de Berlin/Karl Forster / Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens

CD 6
1 Coriolan 8.39
2 Egmont 9.13
3 Prométhée 5.35
4 Les Ruines d’Athènes 5.03
5 Fidelio 7.08
6 Leonore n3 15.13
7 Romance pour violon & orchestre n1 en sol majeur Op.40* 7.15
8 Romance pour violon & orchestre n2 en fa majeur Op.50* 8.09
Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/André Cluytens / *Patrice Fontanarosa violon – Berliner Sinfonie-Orchester/Michael Sch?nwandt

CD 7 65.21
Concerto pour piano n1 en ut majeur Op.15
Concerto pour piano n2 en si bémol majeur Op.19
Emil Guilels piano – Orchestre de la Société des Concerts du Conservatoire/André Vandernoot

CD 8
Concerto pour piano n3 en ut mineur Op.37
Concerto pour piano n5 en mi bémol majeur Op.73 L’Empereur
Bruno Leonardo Gelber piano – New Philharmonia Orchestra/Ferdinand Leitner

CD 9
Concerto pour piano n4 en sol majeur Op.58
Triple Concerto pour piano, violon & violoncelle en ut majeur Op.56*
Emil Gilels piano / *Lev Oborine piano – David Oistrakh violon – Sviatoslav Knouchevitzky violoncelle
Philharmonia Orchestra/Leopold Ludwig 1-3/Sir Malcom Sargent 4-6

CD 10 65.33
Concerto pour violon en ré majeur Op.61
4 Fantaisie pour piano, chœur & orchestre en ut mineur Op.80* 19.48
David Oistrakh violon – Orchestre National de la Radiodiffusion Française/André Cluytens / *John Lill piano – Scottish National Orchestra/Sir Alexander Gibson

CD 11
Sonate pour piano n2 en la majeur Op.2 n2
Sonate pour piano n3 en ut majeur Op.2 n3
Sonate pour piano n4 en mi bémol majeur Op.7
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 12
Sonate pour piano n1 en fa mineur Op.2 n1
Sonate pour piano n5 en ut mineur Op.10 n1
Sonate pour piano n6 en fa majeur Op.10 n2
Sonate pour piano n7 en ré majeur Op.10 n3
Sonate pour piano n22 en fa majeur Op.54
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 13
Sonate pour piano n8 en ut mineur Op.13 Pathétique
Sonate pour piano n9 en mi majeur Op.14 n1
Sonate pour piano n10 en sol majeur Op.14 n2
Sonate pour piano n11 en si bémol majeur Op.22
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 14
Sonate pour piano n12 en la bémol majeur Op.26 Marche funèbre
Sonate pour piano n13 en mi bémol majeur Op.27 n1 Quasi una fantasia
Sonate pour piano n14 en ut dièse mineur Op.27 n2 Clair de lune
Sonate pour piano n15 en ré majeur Op.28 Pastorale
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 15
Sonate pour piano n16 en sol majeur Op.31 n1
Sonate pour piano n17 en ré mineur Op.31 n2 La Tempête
Sonate pour piano n18 en mi bémol majeur Op.31 n3
Sonate pour piano n20 en sol majeur Op.49 n2
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 16
Sonate pour piano n19 en sol mineur Op.49 n1
Sonate pour piano n21 en ut majeur Op.53 Waldstein
Sonate pour piano n23 en fa mineur Op.57 Appassionata
Sonate pour piano n25 en sol majeur Op.79
Sonate pour piano n26 en mi bémol majeur Op.81a Les Adieux
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 17
Sonate pour piano n27 en mi mineur Op.90
Sonate pour piano n28 en la majeur Op.101
Sonate pour piano n29 en si bémol majeur Op.106 Hammerklavier
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 18
Sonate pour piano n24 en fa dièse majeur Op.78 A Thérèse
Sonate pour piano n30 en mi majeur Op.109
Sonate pour piano n31 en la bémol majeur Op.110
Sonate pour piano n32 en ut mineur Op.111
Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 19
1 Pour Elise, bagatelle en la mineur WoO 59 2.57
2 Rondo a capriccio en sol majeur Op.129 ‘colère pour un sou perdu’ 6.29
3 Variations en ut majeur sur ‘God save the King’ WoO 78 8.36
Variations en mi bémol majeur Op.35 Eroica
4 Introduzione col basso del Tema – Tema 3.28
5 Var.1-15 16.45
6 Finale: alla fuga 5.09
7 6 Variations en fa majeur Op.34 13.51
8 6 Variations en ré majeur Op.76 6.37
9 8 Variations en fa majeur sur ‘Tandeln und scherzen’ de Süssmayr WoO 76 8.56
1, 2 Danielle Laval, 3 Georges Cziffra, 4-9 Georges Solchany piano

CD 20
33 Variations sur une valse de Diabelli Op.120
Georges Solchany piano

CD 21
Bagatelles pour piano
1 Bagatelle en ut mineur (1797) 3.36
Bagatelles Op.33
Bagatelles Op.119
Bagatelles Op.126
Georges Solchany piano

CD 22
Sonate pour violon & piano n1 en ré majeur Op.12 n1
Sonate pour violon & piano n2 en la majeur Op.12 n2 17.50
Sonate pour violon & piano n3 en mi bémol majeur Op.12 n3 16.40
Sonate pour violon & piano n4 en la mineur Op.23 16.58
Christian Ferras violon – Pierre Barbizet piano

CD 23
Sonate pour violon & piano n5 en fa majeur Op.24 Le Printemps
Sonate pour violon & piano n6 en la majeur Op.30 n1
Sonate pour violon & piano n7 en ut mineur Op.30 n2
Christian Ferras violon – Pierre Barbizet piano

CD 24
Sonate pour violon & piano n8 en sol majeur Op.30 n3
Sonate pour violon & piano n9 en la majeur Op.47 A Kreutzer
Sonate pour violon & piano n10 en sol majeur Op.96
Christian Ferras violon – Pierre Barbizet piano

CD 25
Sonate pour violoncelle & piano n1 en fa majeur Op.5 n1
Sonate pour violoncelle & piano n2 en sol mineur Op.5 n2
Sonate pour violoncelle & piano n3 en la majeur Op.69
Paul Tortelier violoncelle - Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 26
Sonate pour violoncelle & piano n4 en ut majeur Op.102 n1
Sonate pour violoncelle & piano n5 en ré majeur Op.102 n2
12 Variations sur un thème de Judas Macchabée WoO 45 11.43
7 Variations sur ‘Bei Männern’ (La Flûte enchantée) WoO 46 9.24
12 Variations sur ‘Ein Mädchen oder Weibchen’ (La Flûte enchantée) Op.66 9.34
Paul Tortelier violoncelle - Eric Heidsieck piano

CD 27
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en mi bémol majeur Op.1 n1
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en sol majeur Op.1 n2
Trio Hongrois / Georges Solchany piano – Arpad Gerecz violon – Vilmos Palotai violoncelle

CD 28
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en ut mineur Op.1 n3
Trio pour piano, clarinette & violoncelle en si bémol majeur Op.11*
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en si bémol majeur WoO 39
Variations pour piano, violon & violoncelle sur ‘Ich bin des Schneider Kakadu’ extr. de l’opéra ‘Die Schwestern von Prag’ de Wenzel Müller Op.121a 17.08
Trio Hongrois
* avec André Boutard clarinette

CD 29
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en ré majeur Op.70 n1
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en mi bémol majeur Op.70 n2
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en mi bémol majeur WoO 38
Trio Hongrois

CD 30
Trio pour piano, violon & violoncelle en si bémol majeur Op.97 A l’Archiduc
Variations pour piano, violon & violoncelle sur un thème original en mi bémol majeur Op.44
Trio Hongrois

CD 31
Trio pour violon, alto & violoncelle en sol majeur Op.9 n1
Trio pour violon, alto & violoncelle en ré majeur Op.9 n2
Trio pour violon, alto & violoncelle en ut mineur Op.9 n3
Trio à cordes Français / Gérard Jarry violon – Serge Collot alto – Michel Tournus violoncelle

CD 32
Trio pour violon, alto & violoncelle en mi bémol majeur Op.3
Sérénade pour violon, alto & violoncelle en ré majeur Op.8
Trio à cordes Français

CD 33
Sonatine pour mandoline & clavecin en ut majeur WoO 44a
Sonatine pour mandoline & clavecin en ut mineur WoO 43a
Sérénade pour flûte, violon & alto en ré majeur Op.25
Trio pour flûte, basson & piano en sol mineur WoO 37
1-4 Maria Scivittaro mandoline – Robert Veyron-Lacroix clavecin / 5-10 Michel Debost flûte – Gérard Jarry violon - Serge Collot alto / 11-13 Michel Debost flûte – Amaury Wallez basson – Christian Ivaldi piano

CD 34
Sonate pour flûte & piano en si bémol majeur, Anhang 4 (Attribué à Beethoven)
Airs variés pour flûte & piano
Michel Debost flûte – Christian Ivaldi piano

CD 35
Quatuor à cordes n1 en fa majeur Op.18 n1
Quatuor à cordes n2 en sol majeur Op.18 n2
Quatuor à cordes n3 en ré majeur Op.18 n3
Quatuor Hongrois / Zoltan Szekely, Michael Kuttner violons – Denes Keromzay alto – Gabor Magyar violoncelle

CD 36
Quatuor à cordes n4 en ut mineur Op.18 n4
Quatuor à cordes n5 en la majeur Op.18 n5
Quatuor à cordes n6 en si bémol majeur Op.18 n6
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 37
Quatuor à cordes n7 en fa majeur Op.59 n1 Razoumovsky
Quatuor à cordes n8 en mi mineur Op.59 n2 Razoumovsky
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 38
Quatuor à cordes n9 en ut majeur Op.59 n3 Razoumovsky
Quatuor à cordes n10 en mi bémol majeur Op.74 Les Harpes
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 39
Quatuor à cordes n11 en fa mineur Op.95 Quartetto serioso
Quatuor à cordes n12 en mi bémol majeur Op.127
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 40
Quatuor à cordes n13 en si bémol majeur Op.130
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 41
Quatuor à cordes n14 en ut dièse mineur Op.131
Quatuor à cordes n16 en fa majeur Op.135
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 42
Quatuor à cordes n15 en la mineur Op.132
Quatuor Hongrois

CD 43
Quintette pour piano, hautbois, clarinette, cor & basson en mi bémol majeur Op.16
Sextuor pour 3 violons, 2 cors & violoncelle en mi bémol majeur Op.81b
Marche pour 2 clarinettes, 2 bassons & 2 cors en si bémol majeur WoO 29 1.15
Rondino pour 2 hautbois, 2 clarinettes, 2 cors & 2 bassons WoO 25 6.47
Duo pour clarinette & basson en ut majeur WoO27
Membres du Melos Ensemble / Lamar Crawson piano – Gervase de Peyer, Keith Puddy clarinette – Peter Graeme, Sarah Barringson hautbois – William Waterhouse, Edgar Williams basson – James Buck, Neill Sanders cor

CD 44
Septuor pour violon, alto, violoncelle, contrebasse, clarinette, cor & basson en mi bémol majeur Op.20
Octuor pour 2 hautbois, 2 clarinettes, 2 cors & 2 bassons en mi bémol majeur Op.103
Melos Ensemble / Emanuel Hurwitz violon – Cecil Aronowitz alto – Terence Weil violoncelle – Adrian Beers contrebasse – Gervase de Peyer, Keith Puddy clarinette – Peter Graeme, Sarah Barringson hautbois – William Waterhouse, Edgar Williams basson – James Buck, Neill Sanders cor

CD 45
Le Christ au Mont des Oliviers, oratorio op.85
1 Introduction (Grave –Adagio) 6.27
2 Jehova, du mein Vater! Jésus 3.57
3 Meine Seele ist erschüttert Jésus 4.42
4 Erzittre, Erde, Jehova’s Sohn liegt hier! Seraphin 1.45
5 Preist, preist des Erlösers Güte Seraphin 1.24
6 O Heil euch, ihr Erlösten Chœur/Seraphin 5.17
7 Doch weh ! Die frech entehren Chœur 1.54
8 Verkündet, Seraph, mir dein Mund Jésus/Seraphin 1.10
9 So ruhe denn mit ganzer Schwere Jésus/Seraphin 6.58
10 Willkommen, Tod Jésus 1.10
11 Wir haben ihn gesehen Chœur 2.13
12 Die mich zu fangen ausgezogen sind Jésus/Chœur 1.46
13 Hier ist er, der Verbannte Chœur 2.35
14 Nicht ungestraft soll der Verwegnen Schaar Pierre/Jésus 1.20
15 In meinen Adern wühlen gerechter Zorn und Wut Pierre/Jésus/Seraphin 4.58
16 Auf ! Auf ! Ergreifet den Varräther Jésus/Chœur 3.01
17 Welten singen Dank und Ehre… Preiset ihm Chœur 4.32
Christina Deutekom Seraphin – Nicolaï Gedda Jésus – Hans Sotin Pierre / Solistes, Chœur Philharmonique de la Ville de Bonn – Chœur du Théâtre Municipal de Bonn, Orchestre de la Beethoven Halle de Bonn/Volker Wangenheim

CD 46
Missa solemnis en ré majeur Op.123 (début)
Heather Harper soprano – Janet Baker mezzo-soprano – Robert Tear ténor – Hans Sotin basse
New Philharmonia Chorus & London Philharmonic Orchestra/Carlo Maria Giulini

CD 47
Missa solemnis en ré majeur Op.123 (fin)
Heather Harper soprano – Janet Baker mezzo-soprano
Robert Tear ténor – Hans Sotin basse
New Philharmonia Chorus & London Philharmonic Orchestra/Carlo Maria Giulini

Messe en ut majeur Op.86
Elly Ameling soprano – Janet Baker mezzo-soprano / Theo Altmeyer ténor – Marius Rintzler basse
New Philharmonia Chorus & Orchestra/Carlo Maria Giulini

CD 48
Fidelio opéra en 2 actes
Livret de Joseph Sonnleithner & Friedrich Treittschke, d’après Jean-Nicolas Bouilly
1 Ouverture 6.57
Acte I
2 Jetzt, Schätzchen, sind wir allen Jaquino/Marzelline 4.42
3 Der arme Jaquino dauert mich beinahe Marzelline 0.13
4 O wär’ ich schon mit dir vereint Marzelline 4.00
5 Ist Fidelio noch nicht zurück? Rocco/Marzelline/Leonore 0.35
6 Mir ist so wunderbar… Marzelline/Leonore/Rocco/Jaquino 4.41
7 Höre, Fidelio, wenn ich auch nicht weiß Rocco 0.26
8 …man braucht auch Rocco 2.40
9 Ihr könnt das leicht sagen, Meister Rocco Leonore/Rocco/Marzelline 2.08
10 Gut, Söhnchen, gut, hab’ immer Mut Rocco/Leonore/Marzelline 6.18
11 Marche 2.17
12 Depeschen? Pizarro/Rocco 0.34
13 Ha! Welche in Augenblick! Pizarro 2.58
14 Hauptmann, besteigen Sied en Turn Pizarro/Rocco 0.25
15 Jetzt, Alter, jetzt hat es Eile Pizarro/Rocco 4.38
16 Abscheulicher! Wo eilst du hin? Leonore 7.35
17 Vater Rocco, ich ersuchte Euch schon… Leonore/Marzelline/Rocco 0.36
18 n10 Finale : O welche Lust! Chœur/2 prisonniers 7.16
19 Nun sprecht, wie sie ging’s Leonore/Rocco 5.16
20 Ach! Vater, eilt! Marzelline/Rocco/Jaquino/Leonore/Pizarro/Chœur 6.18

CD 49
Fidelio – Acte II
1 n11 Introduction & air : Gott! Welch Dunkel hier! Florestan 11.23
2 n12 Melodrame & duo : Wie kalt ist es in diesem unterirdischen Gewölbe! Leonore/Rocco 1.25
3 Nur hurtig fort… Rocco/Leonore 4.13
4 Er erwacht! Leonore/Rocco/Florestan 1.23
5 n13 Trio : Euch werde Lohn in besser’n Welten Florestan/Rocco/Leonore 6.36
6 Ist alles bereit? Rocco/Leonore/Florestan/Pizarro 0.39
7 n14 Quatuor : Er sterbe! Doch er soll erst wissen… Pizarro/Florestan/Leonore/Rocco 3.41
8 Vater Rocco! Vater Rocco! Jaquino/Rocco 0.18
9 Es schlägt der Rache Stunde! Leonore/Florestan/Pizarro/Rocco 1.11
10 n15 Duo : O namenlose Freude! Leonore/Florestan 2.58
11 n16 Finale : Heil se idem Tag, heil sei der Stunde Chœur/Don Fernando/Rocco/Pizarro/Leonore/Marzelline 6.02
12 Du schlossest auf des Edlen Grab Don Fernando/Leonore/Florestan/Marzelline/Rocco/ Chœur/Jaquino 8.04
Helga Dernesch Leonore / Jon Vickers Florestan / Karl Ridderbusch Don Pizzaro / José van Dam Don Fernando
Helen Donath Marzelline / Horst Laubenthal Jaquino / Werner Hollweg 1er prisonnier / Siegfried Rudolf Frese 2ème prisonnier / Chœur de l’Opéra Allemand de Berlin – Orchestre Philharmonique de Berlin/Herbert von Karajan

CD 50
1 Ah, perfido! Op.65 13.14
2 An die ferne Geliebte (A la bien aimée lointaine) Op.98 Jeitteles
Auf dem Hügel sitz’ ich spähend – Wo die Berge so blau – Leichte Segler in der Höhen – Diese Wolken in den Höhen – Es kehret der Maien – Nimm sie hin den diese Lieder 14.14
7 Lieder de Goethe
3 Mailied Op.52 n4 2.04
4 Marmotte Op.52 n7 0.38
5 Neue Liebe, neues Lebe Op.75 n2 2.55
6 Aus Goethes Faust Op.75 n3 1.55
7 Wonne der Wehmut Op.83 n1 3.00
8 Sehnsucht Op.83 n2 2.03
9 Mit einem gemalten Bande Op.83 n3 1.43
10 Adelaïde Matthison 6.11
6 Lieder de Gellert Op.48
11 Bitten 1.49
12 Die Liebe des Nächsten 1.09
13 Vom Tode 2.15
14 Die Ehre Gottes aus der Natur 2.23
15 Gottes Macht und Vorsehung 0.40
16 Busslied 4.48
1 Birgit Nilsson soprano – Philharmonia Orchestra/Heinz Wallberg / 2-16 Dietrich Fischer Dieskau baryton – 2 Gerald Moore, 3-16 Hertha Klust piano



Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Chandos recordings
All Chandos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews

all Bridge reviews

all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All Eloquence reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews


Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing



Return to Review Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.