Furtwängler: The Legend EMI CLASSICS 50999 9 08119 2 0 [RM]: Classical Music Reviews

This three-disc box set is issued in parallel with – and is, no doubt, intended to act as a taster for – a far larger EMI box set Wilhelm Furtwängler: the great recordings (14 CDs, EMI 9 08161-2). In this briefer survey, the first disc focuses on core symphonic repertoire while the other two feature a miscellany of overtures and orchestral favourites. The orchestra throughout is the Vienna Philharmonic and the recordings are all post-war – mostly set down on chilly winter days between December 1948 and January 1951, but with a final burst of creative activity in the first week or so of March 1954.

Almost all the recordings are well known. What is equally well known, though, is that Wilhelm Furtwängler (1886-1954) was a conductor who rarely felt comfortable in the studio. He seems, on the contrary, to have been inspired to his greatest levels of spontaneity and artistic imagination by the presence – and reactions - of a live audience and the absence of the technological restraints imposed by the recording process. As a result, many of his most compelling and individually characterised performances were given in concert halls and have, as a result, either been lost forever or else preserved in less than ideal sound.

The symphonies on CD 1 are very enjoyably done, though anyone used only to modern historically-informed performance practice will no doubt find them over-weighty and distinctly old-school. Lacking the “subjective” indiosyncracies that characterise many of Furtwängler’s live recordings – but that can become somewhat irritating on repeated listening – these are relatively straightforward accounts, though none is lacking in real distinction. A notably driven Mozart G minor is most enjoyable; the affectionate account of Haydn’s Surprise is especially warm and silky; while Schubert’s Unfinished, in contrast, is serious of purpose and darkly hued.

Of the overtures and miscellaneous orchestral works on CDs 2 and 3, none is less than expertly conceived and executed, though whether they amount to essential examples of Furtwängler’s artistry is at least open to question.

Furtwängler’s many admirers will, I imagine, be buying the big 14-disc set referred to above and, apart from them, I wonder whether there really is an audience for this smaller box’s pick’n’mix approach. After all, as concert programmes clearly demonstrate, from the 1950s onwards public taste has veered away from overtures and orchestral showpieces towards more substantial works, a development largely caused by the change from 78s – well suited to shorter pieces but not to longer ones – to LPs and then CDs. Thus, even as Furtwängler was recording the pieces on these discs, they were on the verge of falling out of favour.

By sheer coincidence, on the very day I completed this review (17 May 2011), The Times reprinted its 1935 report of the death of French composer Paul Dukas, in the course of which the writer had observed that “... M. Dukas is known chiefly by his popular orchestral scherzo L’Apprenti Sorcier without which a Promenade season would be incomplete” [my emphasis]. Could there be a more graphic illustration of how times – and concert programming practices – have changed in the past 76 years?

It is also worth noting that, although the sound on these studio recordings, further enhanced by digital remastering in 1998, is far better than we are used to on many discs of Furtwängler recorded live, it still remains rather opaque (though there is a marked improvement in the Rosamunde incidental music, recorded in Vienna’s Brahmssaal). Unfortunately, EMI’s technology at the time was just not up to the cutting edge standards being forged by the likes of Decca.

Such musical miscellanies can be of interest – and I have in the past given very warm welcomes on this site to similar Furtwängler potpourris released on the Naxos Historical label. But their primary value was in offering genuine and rare insights into the performance practice and orchestral styles and standards of the 1920s and 1930s. The 1950s Vienna Philharmonic, by contrast, is already well documented on disc and, as already mentioned, most studio accounts fail, in any case, to convey the genuine essence of this particular conductor.

Wilhelm Furtwängler was without doubt, as the title of this box set asserts, a musical legend, but I’m not sure that you’d necessarily deduce as much by listening to these newly-reissued recordings.

Rob Maynard

2023 Approaching 60,000 reviews and more.. and still writing ...	Search MusicWeb Here