MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             




Alexander SCRIABIN (1872-1915)
The Composer as Pianist
The Welte Mignon Piano Rolls
Alexander Scriabin, rec. Moscow, 1910
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 1 [0:53]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 2 [1:47]
Poème, Op. 32 no. 1 [3:29]
Etude, Op. 8 no. 12 [2:04]
Désir, Op. 57 no. 1 [1:32]
Prélude, Op. 22 no. 1 [1:16]
Mazurka, Op. 40 no. 2 [0:49]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 13 [1:48]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 14 [0:47]
Josef Lhevinne, rec. Freiburg, 1906
Nocturne for the Left Hand, Op. 9 no. 2 [4:38]
Constantine Igumnoff, rec. Moscow, 1910
Sonate Fantasie, Op. 19 no. 2, 1st Movement [6:35]
Alexander Goldenweiser, rec. Moscow, 1910
Mazurka, Op. 40 no. 2 [1:02]
Austin Conradi, rec. New York, 1921-22
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 5 [1:50]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 3 [1:17]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 4 [2:04]
Prélude, Op. 11 no. 6 [0:51]
Album Leaf, Op. 45 no. 1 [1:47]
Etude, Op. 2 no. 1 [3:26]
Leff Pouishnoff, rec. New York, 1926
Désir, Op. 57 no. 1 [1:30]
Kresse Dansee, Op. 57 no. 2 [1:01]
Enigme, Op. 52 no. 2 [1:17]
Poème, Op. 32 no. 1 [3:33]
Magdeleine Brard, rec. New York, 1925
Nocturne for the Left Hand, Op. 9 no. 2 [5:16]
PIERIAN 0018 [50:33]


Error processing SSI file


I have a long-deleted Russian Season disc of Alexander Scriabin's piano music played by Samuel Feinberg, Vladimir Sofronitsky, Heinrich Neuhaus, Alexander Goldenweiser and Scriabin himself. Given the commanding line-up of artists, it is one of my most treasured recordings and has the complete taste of authenticity. Of course, the sound can be problematic, but to listen to these Russian titans of the keyboard is a privilege as well as a compelling listening experience.

When playing a disc such as The Russian Season one, I sometimes wonder how the early 20th century pianists would sound with up-to-date sonics. This is where the Welte-Mignon digital recording system enters the picture, for it represents the closest that we can get to hearing these historical performances in modern sound. Introduced in 1904, the Welte-Mignon system allows us to hear an exceptional level of detail without any trace of sound distortion. To this reviewer, the results are amazing in that a performance recorded in the early 1900s can sound as if it is being played this very day just a few feet away.

It all sounds too good to be true, and the fact is that Welte-Mignon is not perfect. Critics claim that this system does not accurately reproduce performances; my particular reservation is that it tends to smooth-out the musical edges and contours, and a prime example comes from a comparison of the Scriabin performances on the Russian Season and Pierian discs. Eight of the nine pieces on the Pierian are also on the Russian Season, and Scriabin's readings are more sharply etched on the latter. So, there is a trade-off that needs to be considered by prospective buyers.

Having said the above, the greatest difference between historical and piano roll recordings is one of orientation. With the Russian Season disc, the listener is transported back to Scriabin's era with all its sonic limitations; the Pierian disc transports Scriabin to the current-day listener's sound world. Frankly, I consider both orientations revelatory and essential for Scriabin enthusiasts.

Of course, the two discs give us much insight as to how Scriabin played his own music and why deviating significantly from his recorded examples diminishes his compositions. As wonderful as it is to hear Richter or Sofronitsky play Scriabin, there is a tremendous 'rush' when listening to the composer perform his own music: the intensity of his melancholy, the under-currents of tension that make the ensuing emotional outbursts logical and compelling, the prevalent cross-rhythms, and the playfulness of his interpretations.

Although the performers on the Pierian disc are not uniformly of the star-studded variety found on the Russian Season disc, I can assure readers that each is a superb advocate for Scriabin's music. The legendary Josef Lhevinne needs no introduction, and his performance of the Nocturne for the Left Hand is a stunning example of lush romanticism. The Nocturne is also played by Magdeleine Brard who gained entry to the Paris Conservatory in 1914 at the tender age of eleven; she became Alfred Cortot's favorite student and toured the United States with the Orchestra of the Paris Conservatory in 1919. Her reading of the Nocturne largely eschews Lhevinne's romantic approach for a more powerful presentation with very demonstrative accenting.

Born in 1873, Constantine Igumnoff studied under Taneyev, Arensky and Ippolitov-Ivanov at the Moscow Conservatory. Although best known as a professor at the Conservatory for almost fifty years, his playing of 1st Movement of the Sonate Fantasie reveals a deep connection for Scriabin's volatile nature, exquisite lyricism, and powerful cross-rhythms. This is definitely a performance not to be missed.

Alexander Goldenweiser's artistry is represented by his performance of Scriabin's Mazurka, Op. 40/2 that is also played by the composer. Goldenweiser was an important figure in promoting the Russian school of piano playing, being a professor and the eventual director of the Moscow Conservatory for many years. A comparison of his Mazurka performance with that of Scriabin's is quite illuminating. Scriabin is quick, impetuous and very playful, while Goldenweiser adopts a slower and more stately presentation. Although I have to give the nod to Scriabin, the Goldenweiser account has a cosmopolitan and mature nature that is alluring and glows with confidence.

Leff Pouishnoff, born into an aristocratic Russian family, was an exceptional Scriabinist. He graduated in 1910 from the Petrograd Conservatory after studying with Rimsky-Korsakov, Glazunov and Liadov. His first concert tour was as a partner for Leopold Auer, and highly successful tours in London and the United States followed in the 1920s. Of his four piano rolls on the disc, the Poème and Désir compare quite well with Scriabin's own performances. Actually, they are similar except that Scriabin is a little more playful and mysterious. Most important, both pianists splendidly bring out the harmonic adventure of the pieces.

Aside from the Scriabin piano rolls, it is the playing of Austin Conradi that I most treasure on the disc. An American, he was raised and lived most of his life in Baltimore, teaching at the Peabody Institute. This is my first acquaintance with Conradi's playing, and I am amazed with his affinity for Scriabin's sound world. The performances are steeped in rapture and sensuality, and the grief he conveys in the Prelude, Op. 11/4 and the Op. 2 Etude is overwhelming. As for determination, his granite strength in the Prelude, Op. 11/6 bespeaks a mighty edifice as well as primitive abandon.

In conclusion, the non-profit Pierian label has given us an enlightening and, dare I say, magical recording that every Scriabin enthusiast needs to have. Although it can be used as a reference and historical document, the best thing to do with this disc is simply listen to the wonderful music in utterly compelling performances. Personally, I consider myself most fortunate to own both the Pierian and Russian Season discs, feeling that I have knocked on the doors of Heaven and been afforded entry. Needless to say, the Pierian will be one of my MusicWeb Recordings of 2005.

Don Satz






Return to Index

Error processing SSI file