Sonar in Ottava
– Double Concertos for violin and violoncello piccolo
Antonio VIVALDI (1678-1741) Sinfonia in D, RV125, for strings (reconstructed by Olivier Fourés) [6:52]
Concerto in C, RV508, for violin and violoncello piccolo [10:44]
Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750) Concerto in d minor, BWV1043, for violin and violoncello piccolo [14:30]
Johann Gottlieb GOLDBERG (1727-1756) Sonata in c minor, DürG14 for strings [11:27]
Johann Sebastian BACH Concerto in d minor, BWV1060, for violin and violoncello piccolo [13:53]
Antonio VIVALDI Concerto in E-flat, RV515, for violin and violoncello piccolo [12:52]
Giuliano Carmignola (violin: Pietro Guarneri, Venice 1733); Mario Brunello
(four-string violoncello piccolo: Filippo Fasser, Brescia 2017, after
Antonio and Girolamo Amati, Cremona 1600-10)
Accademia dell’Annunciata/Riccardo Doni (harpsichord)
rec. 26-30 June 2018, Church of the Convento dell’Annunciata,
Abbiategrasso, Milan. DDD.
Reviewed as lossless (wav) press preview. ARCANA A472
First a slight disappointment: these double concertos for violin and
violoncello piccolo are not new discoveries but putative reconstructions of
how some of the music of Bach and Vivaldi, some of it known to be adapted
from earlier versions, might have sounded. In their published scoring:
Concertos RV508, RV515 and BWV1043 for two violins; Concerto BWV1060 for
two harpsichords in c minor (here transposed a tone higher).
First and foremost, this album offers an opportunity for two old friends,
originally teacher and student, who have both gone on to make some very
fine recordings, to get together. If that’s an excuse, I’m glad that they
made the experiment. Whatever the claimed ‘persuasive historical and
musicological evidence’1, the result is credible and, more to
the point, delightful.
I’m pleased, too, to hear the Goldberg sonata; we hear too little of this
composer whose theme inspired Bach to compose his Goldberg Variations.
There are two other current recordings of the sonata, including a Bridge
album with the title Beyond the Variations, which Dominy Clements
recommended purchasing post-haste (Bridge 9478 –
review). Here it makes a very fine central hinge in the Bach and Vivaldi
Giuliano Carmignola is not known for hanging around; whether it’s due to
his influence or not, the Bach and Vivaldi works are taken at quite a pace.
He’s also known for the respect he showed for the music, with nothing
scrambled, on his earlier
recordings for DG Archiv; Michael Cookson typified his album of five
Vivaldi concertos, all first recordings, as ‘beautifully performed and
I could easily say the same about this new release, especially as Arcana have accorded
him a recording quality to match the DG. My review copy came in lossless,
CD-quality, wav format – congratulations to the Outhere group for listening
to requests for review tracks in better than mp3 – and I presume that there
will be an even better 24-bit download, as well, of course, as the CD.
In fact, these recordings are notable for liveliness rather than speed per se. Comparison with Isabelle Faust, much lauded in these Bach
concertos, a recording which Simon Thompson thought ‘a real treat’, with
Bernhard Forck (second violin) and Xenia Loeffler (oboe) reveals that she
and her Berlin team are consistently a few seconds faster (Harmonia
HMM902335.36, 2 CDs for around £13 –
This is not all about Carmignola, however. Cellist Mario Brunello, though
less a baroque specialist than his erstwhile teacher, has recently recorded
Bach’s violin sonatas and partitas on the large violin/small cello, the
violoncello piccolo (Arcana A469, 2 CDs). I missed reviewing that when it
was released in October 2019.
The great thing about the music of Vivaldi, Bach and Handel is that it’s
very flexible; after all, they were constantly adapting and borrowing their
own music and one another’s, so that you think ‘Oh, that’s x, but
not as I know it’ – music from The Seasons as an opera aria, a
secular aria transposed into a movement in a sacred cantata or oratorio.
I’ve heard both the Bach violin sonatas and partitas and the cello sonatas
successfully played on the viola, and we know that BWV1060, though
published for two harpsichords, originated as for violin and oboe, while
BWV1043 transitioned into a double-harpsichord concerto, BWV1062. Even
transposing the music is not innovatory: BWV1043 in its guise as BWV1062 is
in g minor, while BWV1060 was probably still in c minor.
I think the violin sonatas and partitas on the violoncello piccolo on the
earlier recording may take rather longer to get used to than the adapted
concertos on the new album. I found hearing them on the deeper-throated
instrument a little unsettling, whereas I took to the concertos
immediately. Perhaps that’s because in their new guise the violin works –
which, as far as I know were never intended for another instrument, though
Bach did employ the violoncello piccolo in some cantatas – now sound more
intellectual and academic, less immediately approachable. But, then, I have
never loved the cello sonatas, even played by the likes of Casals, as much
as their violin cousins.
Much of the success of Carmignola’s DG and Sony recordings came from the
support of the Venice Baroque Orchestra and Andrea Marcon, and as soloist
and conductor with Concerto Köln. The Accademia dell’Annunciata and Riccardo
Doni are equally supportive. I’m not aware of having heard either before –
this is, I think, the Accademia’s first outing on record and only Doni’s second in the driver’s seat, having previously
recorded as a member of Il Giardino Armonico – but I’d like to hear more.
As well as making excellent accompanists, they get us off to a good start
under their own steam with the Vivaldi sinfonia.
If Brunello’s experiment with the Bach violin sonatas and partitas
is only partially successful, his partnership with Carmignola here gives
us a recording to equal the latter’s very successful solo recordings.
A very fine team of performers and recording engineers have co-operated
to produce a very enjoyable album. You don’t need to get involved
in any academic justification; because Bach and Vivaldi share an infinite
variety, it all works well.
This claim in the blurb is partially negated by a comment in the booklet
that ‘The custom of combining two different concertante instruments was …
not very common in the 18th century.’
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger