Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
Ph. 020 8418 0616
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Anton BRUCKNER (1824-1896) Symphony No. 9 In D minor - Dem Lieben Gott;
Concerto Budapest/András Keller
rec. 2017, Budapest TACET TACET245SACD [60:30]
This is the first Tacet release devoted to the music of Bruckner and also the
first for András Keller, violinist with the Keller Quartet, as a conductor.
The Tacet label’s “Real Surround Sound”, supposedly uses “the whole acoustic space” to replicate the experience of listening in a concert hall; I can only say that listening on conventional two-speaker equipment or headphones, I do not perceive the benefits they hope will proceed from their recording technique; to my ears, the orchestra in general sounds oddly distant, yet the timpani are too prominent and balances are wrong, but, as the “Audio System Requirements” note is at pains to point out, that should not be the case for those centrally placed to listen in SACD on more than two speakers. I am fully prepared to believe that the desired acoustic and perspective are obtained on the correct equipment, so reserve judgement in that regard.
However, for the Bruckner devotee, no matter how much we appreciate modern engineering, the sound must surely always yield in importance to the quality of the performance and that is where I have my reservations. Recorded over five days by distinguished musicians in top-flight sound, one would hope and even assume that the product would be exceptional, but I simply cannot hear anything special in the result. I hear too much of the kind of pulling about of tempo which I find uncongenial in much of Jochum’s Bruckner, yet others prize that conductor’s approach so, again, I can only plead my personal case and not presume to speak for others. I like my Bruckner strong and steady, without sudden accelerandi and ritardandi; for the most part the music here is erratically paced and perfunctorily phrased, losing the requisite pulse and flow. It often seems to be going nowhere in particular, but rather halting to deliver too obviously calculated effects, some of which border on the self-regarding, if not vulgar.
I first listened to this back-to-back with a new recording of the Ninth from Kenshiro Sakairi and the Tokyo Juventus Orchestra, and was struck by the disparity between them: tempi are overall very similar, yet in the very opening of the first movement, for example, Keller sounds sluggish rather suspenseful, the Scherzo is tame and under-energised, and the climax of the Adagio is a non-event compared with the grandeur of the Japanese performance. The Concerto Budapest – formerly the Hungarian Symphony Orchestra – is clearly a fine outfit but going through the motions.
It s hard to put one’s finger on how and why a recording over which the performers and engineers have evidently laboured should emerge as lacking Innigkeit, but that is my sad conclusion and leaves me wondering why anyone other than the curious audiophile would invest in this new issue; a competent run-through is not a substitute for those recordings which display real, in-depth engagement.
This review commissioned by The Bruckner Journal and reproduced here by their kind permission.