Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Alessandro SCARLATTI (1660-1725) O Penosa Lontananza -Cantate da Camera
Deborah Cachet (soprano)
Scherzi Musicali/Nicolas Achten (baritone, theorbo, triple harp, organ)
rec. 2018, Provinciaal Museum, Begijnhofkerk, Sint-Truiden, Belgium RICERCAR RIC396 [70:01]
For too long Alessandro Scarlatti’s star has been eclipsed by that of his son. Domenico’s wonderfully inventive keyboard sonatas are what people may think of first when they hear the name “Scarlatti”, but Alessandro was a more distinguished composer. He is said to have been the founder of the Neapolitan school of opera, and has over a hundred dramatic works for the theatre to his credit. There are also over six hundred chamber cantatas that date from every period of his career as a composer. Even if some cantatas are spurious or duplicated entries in his catalogue of works, this body of works far outweighs the younger Scarlatti’s opus.
Alessandro Scarlatti’s music in my collection includes six CDs that feature some of his cantatas. Nowhere near all were ever published. We should be grateful to those who chose to record a selection. Nicholas McGegan made a number of recordings, among them four on Conifer/DHM, and wonderful music it is. Of twenty-one cantatas on those six discs only two are repeated, and it is a real boon to have six new cantatas here. The different approaches are quite interesting. Marcello Di Lisa for CPO (777 748-2) and Robert King for Hyperion (CDA66875) prefer a bolder reading with a larger ensemble, whilst McGegan and Nicolas Achten on this disc employ only a handful of musicians – thus a more intimate approach.
The multi-talented Nicolas Achten sings, plays and directs. He explains in his excellent booklet notes just how his research into the performing practice of the time these six cantatas were written has coloured his decision about instrumentation in these wonderful performances. He splits his notes, after a short introduction, into four sections which among other thing explain how Scarlatti the opera composer became a composer of chamber cantatas. A couple of recordings of his operas I know can attest that his approach in the cantatas is quite different. Achten also discusses the ‘Arcadian cantatas’ and their place in history, and how the cantatas recorded here relate to love, or love from afar, love that is tempered by separation and even unrequited love.
The six cantatas recorded here are quite charming, even if they at times portray the angst and pain of separation. Nicolas Achten has a nice light baritone voice, and he is equally well partnered by the soprano Deborah Cachet. They both have a vocal delivery ideal for this music, a voice which is not affected by operatic displays and sensibilities. In the solo cantatas they are wonderful, but it is in the one cantata where they share the limelight, O penosa lontananza, that they really shine. There is an opening duet where she sings of a “painful separation” whilst he sings of a “blessed separation”. This sets the scene well for what can be seen as a humorous but tender cantata. This is followed by solos that set out each of their positions with some excellent singing.
Of the other cantatas, only Sovra carro stellate begins with an instrumental introduction. Here the musicianship is clearly evident. The two violins and continuo make a wonderful sound; there follows a recitativo in which Cachet’s character longs to be with her beloved during a sleepless night. All of these six cantatas (in fact every one that I know) have some beautiful music to offer the listener to enjoy. From beginning to end this disc is wonderful. Achten’s final aria Tu resti, o mio bel nume, in which he sings that “Departing and death are therefore the same,” is a wonderful conclusion and a perfect epitome of the musicality and storytelling of this disc.
The recorded sound is excellent. Like the music, it is quite intimate, capturing each of the performers in quite a natural acoustic. One gets the sense of a performance rather than a recording. It has a warm sound, not harsh and cold as sometimes on period recordings. This makes it perfect for this performance. The music presented here is performed excellently throughout, making this an ideal recording for those who want to explore the music of Scarlatti senior, or to add to their collection.
Contents Imagini d'orrore
1. I. Aria. Imagini d'orrore [3:40]
2. II. Recitativo. Se dubbioso il mio core [1:09]
3. III. Aria. Amo, si, ma sempre temo [3:29] O penosa lontananza, H.479
4. I. Duo. O penosa lontananza [4:37]
5. II. Recitativo. Se trà voi più soggiorno [1:07]
6. III. Aria. Vago augel che si lamenta [1:54]
7. IV. Recitativo. Io, trà queste de' boschi [0:39]
8. V. Aria. Rio che fugge [1:37]
9. VI. Duo. Così, lungi da Clori [2:02]
10. VII. Duo. O penosa lontananza [1:45] Sovra carro stellato, H.680
11. I. Sinfonia [2:54]
12. II. Recitativo. Sovra carro stellato [1:21]
13. III. Aria. Crudi sassi [3:48]
14. IV. Recitativo. Filli mio ben, oh Dio, che fai? [1:19]
15. V. Aria. Se il tuo bel che m'innamora [2:45]
16. VI. Recitativo. Ma già spunta l'aurora [1:10]
17. VII. Aria. Sì, sì, mi parto sì [4:02] Sotto l'ombra d'un faggio, H.678
18. I. Recitativo. Sotto l'ombra d'un faggio [1:25]
19. II. Aria. Filli mia, chi ha il cor piagato [3:03]
20. III. Recitativo. Che non fè, che non disse [0:25]
21. IV. Aria. Vieni, oh Tirsi, in questo seno [3:58] Fiero, acerbo destin, H.262
22. I. Recitativo. Fierbo, acerbo destin [1:13]
23. II. Aria. Fa men crudo il suo tormento [4:23]
24. III. Recitativo. Se palesar non posso all'idol moi [0:45]
25. IV. Aria. Vorrei scoprire il mio martire [4:08] Tu resti, o mio bel nume, H.742
26. I. Recitativo. Tu resti, o mio bel nume [1:15]
27. II. Aria. Se tu sol sei mio conforto [5:16]
28. III. Recitativo. Or dimmi qual ti sembra [1:17]
29. IV. Aria. L'istesso è il partire [4:30]