Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Giuseppe VERDI (1813 - 1901) Il trovatore
Robert Lloyd (bass) - Ferrando; Phyllis Cannan (soprano) - Ines; Katia
Ricciarelli (soprano) - Leonora; Yuri Masurok (baritone) - Count Di
Luna; Josť Carreras (tenor) - Manrico; Stefania Toczyska (mezzo-soprano)
- Azucena; Robin Leggate (tenor) – Ruiz; John Treleaven (tenor)
– Un messo; Roderick Earle (bass) – Un vecchio zingaro
Orchestra and Chorus of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden/Colin Davis
rec. July 1980, London PHILIPS 4461512 [2 CDs: 128 mins]
I note that whatever reason, this recording seems never to have been
reviewed here on this site, so almost forty years on, perhaps it’s
time it was.
I have fond memories of attending, around the same time as this recording
was made, a performance at Covent Garden with the identical cast, seeing
and hearing them from box seats, which added considerably to the impact
of the occasion. It was one of the best and most complete operatic occasions
of my life, so perhaps I may be excused for my nostalgic attachment
to this recording. Nonetheless, it is objectively very fine, presenting
every artist at his or her best, for better or worse, depending on whether
you think their vocal layout is suited to this, one of the ultimate
Big Sing opportunities in Grand Opera.
Every voice here is decidedly beautiful, if not necessarily either typical
of, or ideal for, the demands of the score. The emphasis is predominantly
upon lyricism but that does not mean that there is any strain or lack
of power in the delivery. Davis’ conducting is essentially non-interventionist
even if occasionally I find him a tad rushed as, for example, at the
start of Part 2, in the Gypsies’ Chorus. He eschews bombast without
sacrificing drive and energy, directing a swift, propulsive account.
The first voice we hear is that of resident Covent Garden bass for many
years, Robert Lloyd. His tone is almost too grand and noble for Ferrando
but he provides a fresh, alert reading of the role and deals very well
with the tricky gruppetti. Ricciarelli is in best voice, delicate poised
and plangent – she makes a languid but vulnerable and touching
Leonora, a few ungainly top notes, with too much beat, notwithstanding.
Carreras, too, is at his very considerable best, even if he is already
pushing a bit and reluctant to sing anything quietly. He does not sound
over-parted in “Di quella pira” even if he is no Corelli.
Mazurok’s splendid baritone is lean, incisive and steady, just
as I remember it in the theatre; I have read complaints regarding his
Italian but he sounds idiomatic enough to me. He has a kind of Gobbi-like
bite to his delivery. The under-rated Toczyska is also lighter and leaner
than most of the beefy mezzo-sopranos who undertake this role, but still
highly dramatic, with both vocal registers very well integrated and
developed. Her final scene with Carreras’ vibrant Manrico is both
beautifully vocalised and moving, with both artists scrupulously musical
but intensely passionate. The chorus is really first rate, too; this
is a recording with no weaknesses.
The recorded sound is fine, employing some atmospheric balancing and
distancing effects and generally belying its age.
Yes, I also want to be able to hear more typical Big Bow-Wow performances
of this most venerable of warhorses with more overtly dramatic voices
like Leontyne Price, Bonisolli or Corelli or Fiorenza Cossotto, but
I find this recording very satisfying. As I never tire of observing,
we’d be more than grateful to hear a cast of this calibre in the
opera house today.