Anton EBERL (1765-1807)
Concerto for Two Pianos & Orchestra, op. 45 (1803) [27:05]
Sonata for Piano Four Hands, op. 7 No. 1 (1797) [12:19]
Sonata for Piano Four Hands, op. 7 No. 2 (1797) [18:55]
Paolo Giacometti, Riko Fukuda (fortepiano)
Kölner Akademie/Michael Alexander Willens
rec. 2008/11, Deutschlandfunk Kammermusiksaal, Köln, Germany CPO 777 733-2 [58:20]
Anton Eberl was a busy contributor to the musical life
of Viennese high classicism. His compositions were sometimes confused
with music written by his friend, Mozart. Eberl even posted a newspaper
notice correcting the mistaken idea that his deceased friend had written
Eberl’s C minor piano sonata. Eberl’s E flat major symphony
appeared on the same program in 1805 that saw the premiere of Beethoven’s
Eroica symphony, and was better received. Eberl died at 41, which may
be why he is not better known.
This concerto for two pianos is a splendid piece, here presented in
fine performances by Paolo Giacometti and Riko Fukuda. It is not so
glorious as Mozart’s 1779 Concerto for two pianos (K.365), but
is pretty darned good. The work reflects the militarist era of the Napoleonic
wars, replete with trumpet calls and march-like themes. But Eberl’s
sense of humor and his obvious joy in antiphonal play with runs and
trills keeps the work from being too serious. An extended cadenza in
the first movement is particularly exciting. Unusually, the middle movement
is a march, with only winds in accompaniment, creating a kind of ‘non
piu andrai’ militarism, just short of toy soldiers on parade.
In compensation for the missing andante, Eberl opens the final rondo
with a slow introduction before launching into a movement that is sometimes
frothy and sometimes fiery, including a Janissary episode before the
end. This confident and often humorous work is a little formulaic and
was a bit old-fashioned in its time, but the formula it follows is an
Michael Alexander Willens leads the Kölner Akademie (18 strings and
11 winds plus tympani) with energy and responsiveness to the soloists.
The performance features some wonderful sonorities, never harsh, but
not smoothed by romanticism. The pianos are well-matched, yet distinctive
(one is brighter, the other gentler). This recording follows an appealing
CPO disc of two Eberl solo piano concertos played by the same musicians.
Eberl composed the two sonatas in 1797 in St. Petersburg. They less
grand than the Double Concerto, but highly enjoyable. The music is busy
and eventful, but not military. Sonata 1 is vigorous and joyful, moving
assuredly through dramatic moments. A whisp of an andantino leads to
a bouncy rondo. In contrast, Sonata 2 seems a well-mannered
affair, but it is still playful, and with brilliant antiphony. In both
works, Giacometti and Fukuda sound as if they are enjoying the opportunities
for display in this music’s many flourishes. Their playing is
crisp and each pianist is highly responsive to the other.
This recording of Eberl’s Double Concerto should appeal if you
enjoy looking beyond the Haydn-Mozart-Beethoven trio of Viennese classicism.
The performances are both vibrant and technically self-assured, and
revel in the drama inherent in duo piano music.
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger