Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
Ph. 020 8418 0616
Support us financially by purchasing this from
David BRAID (b. 1970) On Silver Trees, op. 34 for mezzo-soprano, archtop guitar and piano (2014) [3:26] Invocation and Continuum, op. 38, duo for flute and classical guitar (2014) [6:11]
Sonata for archtop guitar and piano, op. 19 (2013) [10:29] Invention and Fugue, op. 36, duo for clarinet and piano (2014) [4:33] Songs of Contrasting Subjects, mezzo soprano and archtop guitar, op. 47 (2015) [22:29] Four Intimate Pieces for electric archtop guitar, op. 21 (2013-14) [8:59]
First Piano Sonata, op. 14 (2012) [14:17] Two Solos for electric archtop guitar, op. 45 & op. 43 (2015) [6:09]
Emily Gray (mezzo-soprano), Claire Overbury (flute), Elena Zucchini (guitar), Peter Cigleris (clarinet), Sergei Podobedov (piano), Rossitza Stoycheva (piano), David Braid (archtop guitar)
rec. 2014-16, Master Chord Studio, London; Antenna Studios, London; Holy Trinity, Weston, UK MÉTIERMSV28575 [76:35]
I have not (consciously) heard any music by David Braid before reviewing this CD. It is an omission that I have been delighted to correct. For detailed information about the composer, I suggest a perusal of his excellent webpage. Four points may be of interest to the listener. Firstly, David Braid is a Welsh composer, born in Wrexham and growing up in the seaside resort of Colwyn Bay. He studied at the Royal College of Music and at the Cracow Academy of Music in Poland. Secondly, he is a hugely accomplished guitar player, as will be heard in this CD. Thirdly, Braid is an eclectic musician. He has written a Violin Concerto, played in rock bands and composed film music. It is not surprising that he has called for the guitar (electric or acoustic) in several of his compositions. Finally, Braid does have his own musical voice, but influences include Lutosławski, Sibelius, Per Nørgård and a hint of minimalism.
A definition. Everyone knows what an electric guitar is. The same applies to the classical Spanish guitar. I had to look up what an archtop guitar was. The Wikipedia definition is a good as any: “An archtop guitar is a hollow steel-stringed acoustic or semi-acoustic guitar with a full body and a distinctive arched top, whose sound is particularly popular with jazz, blues, rockabilly and psychobilly guitarists.” It certainly has a distinctive sound that David Braid exploits brilliantly.
Begin exploring this CD with the Four Intimate Pieces for electric archtop guitar, op. 21. This collection was composed during 2013-2014. It is a great way to introduce oneself to the sound of this beautiful instrument. The first movement Lirico was based on an improvisation that Braid did on the first seven notes of J. S. Bach’s first lute suite. This is followed by a bleak February’s Lament, which the composer suggests may refer to the “seemingly endless winter” nights. Braid uses the title of one of Sibelius’s most popular pieces, Valse Triste, for his third number. This thoughtful melody has little of the valse and much of the triste. It is quite lovely. The final piece, Tomorrow’s Daydream, has an impressionistic feel, no doubt generated by the whole-tone scale. It is magic and evocative.
I stayed with this instrument for the Two Solos for archtop guitar, op. 45 & op. 43 completed in 2015. The first, Wordless Song, is a swift rhapsodic piece using a wide variety of instrumental effects. The second, For Alex, is more classical in its bearing and is written in two contrapuntal parts. It is dedicated to Alex Anderson, the son of Martin, owner of the Toccata Classics record label.
For a different mood, I turned to the Invention and Fugue, op. 36, duo for clarinet and piano. The Invention is lyrical, slow-paced and lugubrious. On the other hand, the Fugue trips along with rhythmic drive, constantly shifting accents and having considerable melodic interest. This was composed in 2014.
The first vocal work, On Silver Trees, op. 34, is a gorgeous setting of Walter de la Mare’s delightfully descriptive poem, Silver. The soprano is well-accompanied by the archtop guitar and piano, enhancing the effect of the moon’s colouring of the landscape and trees. The vocal setting of the line “A harvest mouse goes scampering by…” is most felicitous.
Reflection is the keynote of the attractive Invocation and Continuum, op. 38, duo for flute and classical guitar. The quiet Invocation is characterised by a nocturnal mood, whereas the Continuum has much melodic and rhythmic diversity. Despite the vivacious Iberian mood of some of this movement, it is still retrospective, with a musical quotation from the Invocation providing an effective sense of closure. The work was written in 2014.
The first of the major works on this CD is the Sonata for archtop guitar and piano, op. 19. This splendid duo, for a combination that may be unique, was written in 2013 for Braid to perform with the present pianist, Sergei Podobedov. The work is in three movements: Invocation, Waltz and Fugue. I agree with the liner notes’ contention that the two instruments make an ideal contrapuntal team. Their timbres never intrude upon each other, but allow the listener to hear the musical development of each partner. After a quiet Invocation, the Waltz is gentle and occasionally a little wayward, whilst the fugal finale nods to Eastern-European folk dances. It is a most satisfying Sonata. One can only hope that David Braid will write another example soon.
The Songs of Contrasting Subjects, for mezzo-soprano and archtop guitar, op.47 (2015), are quite stunning. They set four poems by William Shakespeare and one by John Bunyan. The poems are She goes but softly (Bunyan), Fear no more (Cymbeline), Music to hear (Sonnet 8), How can I then return (Sonnet 28) and Is it thy will (Sonnet 61) (Shakespeare). The use of the archtop guitar as opposed to the more obvious resource of the piano is well-chosen. Braid points out that the “warm, mellow sound suits the mezzo voice perfectly…”
The final work I listened to was the First Piano Sonata, op. 14 (2012). The title correctly implies that there may be a Second, and there is. The present Sonata is conceived in three movements: Stabile con calma, Poco melancholia e tranquillo and Ossessivo. The composer explains the constructive principal behind this work: the musical material (harmony, themes, motifs etc.) is limited to each hand/part playing on only white or black notes. They can swap around. He cites Chopin’s black note study (op. 10 no. 5) and Ligeti’s White on White as possible exemplars. Whatever the technical devices used, the work is effective and satisfying. Naturally, there is significant dissonance in the development of each movement, but this is not problematic. The linear progression of each hand/part is quite conventional. The middle movement is in waltz time. I am not sure about the reference in the liner notes to “a slender android trying to dance” but the result is quite moving. Beaming back down to earth from Star Trek’s USS Enterprise, the concluding Ossessivo is really an exciting toccata or perpetuum mobile. An impressive conclusion to a fascinating work.
All the performers play brilliantly. The sound quality is superb. The CD insert includes programme notes for all the works, a two-page essay on the composer, biographical details of the performers and the song texts.
I enjoyed this CD. The music is interesting, often captivating, never too challenging, and always enjoyable. It has been a privilege to explore these eight works.