Pyotr Ilyich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893) The Nutcracker, Op. 71 (1891-1892, arr. for solo piano by Stewart Goodyear)
Stewart Goodyear (Steinway D)
rec. 25-27 February 2015, Sono Luminus Studios, Boyce, Virginia, USA
Reviewed as a 24/96 download from
Pdf booklet included
STEINWAY & SONS STNS 30040 SACD
I rarely pass up the opportunity to review a new recording of The Nutcracker, so I downloaded this one as soon as I was alerted to
its existence. I’m not sure how this album, released in 2015, escaped my
watchful eye, but then a belated review is better than none at all.
Unusually for Steinway this is a hybrid SACD recorded by Sono Luminus at
their studios in Boyce, Virginia. That was an enticement in itself, as SL’s
America Again, featuring pianist Lara Downes, was one of my Recordings of the Year for
2016. The programme is well chosen and the playing is splendid, but as I
pointed out at the time it’s the engineering that deserves special praise.
The Toronto-born composer and pianist Stewart Goodyear admits to a
long-term love affair with The Nutcracker. He transcribed the March, before deciding to tackle the complete ballet. Others have
restricted themselves to the suite, among them the composer Anton Arensky
and the pianist Nicolas Economou. In 1983 the latter recorded his two-piano
arrangement with Martha Argerich (Deutsche Grammophon). Then there’s
conductor-pianist Mikhail Pletnev’s reduction for piano solo, which dates
from 1978. I had the pleasure of hearing Alexandra Dariescu play a
selection from that as part of her recent all-Tchaikovsky recording for
From the well-turned Overture it’s clear that Goodyear’s Nutcracker is not only virtuosic, it’s also highly individual. One
could argue, for example, that The Christmas Tree is over-decorated;
the effect is not unpleasant, but the result is more Goodyear than
Tchaikovsky. That said, the crisply articulated March is splendid,
as is the Galop and Dance of the Parents. But despite Goodyear’s
penchant for embellishment I can’t fault his pianism, which is assured and
propulsive throughout. He also brings a weight to the music that’s lacking
in the light, rather ‘pretty’ Argerich/Economou recording.
The Grandfather Dance
is another of those sections where one is inclined to admire the musician
rather than the music. It’s a niggle rather than a no-no, and it doesn’t
really detract from the performance as a whole. Goodyear certainly has a
feel for overall pace and dramatic thrust; he’s particularly adept at
building tension, and he gives the score just enough ballast to suggest
orchestral weight and amplitude. There’s an element of fantasy too,
especially at the start of Clara and the Nutcracker, and that’s very
welcome. Perhaps even more remarkable is the sheer consistency and
coherence of this arrangement, which is generally free of flat-spots.
As a player he’s sensitive to shape and style, avoiding the self-indulgent
swooning that mars Argerich and Economou’s otherwise entertaining
performance. After a rousing battle Goodyear leads us into a truly wondrous
account of the Transformation Scene and The Pine Forest in Winter. Indeed, for the very first time in this
recording I was transported to the theatre, now firmly under the spell of
this charming tale. It’s epiphanies like this that make one forget earlier
caveats and criticisms; not only that, one is reminded of what an Olympian
task this is, and how this pianist is able to connect with the score
at these vital points.
Goodyear’s fondness for floridity may not be to everyone’s taste, but it
works a treat in the lovely Waltz of the Snowflakes. At times this
arrangement can seem a little too declamatory, but who could quibble with
the seamless line of The Magic Castle, which is so atmospherically
evoked? Even more impressive is the way that Goodyear segues so easily
between sections, the Divertissement slipping in almost unnoticed.
His flair for Tchaikovsky’s rhythms is undeniable, the distinctive
sonorities and character of the showpieces a special delight. Indeed, the Arabian Dance is simply spell-binding. And what about the spirited Trepak and Polchinelle? Worth encores on their own.
One of two things is happening here: either Goodyear – the pianist and the arranger – is improving as the piece progresses, or I’m just
getting to like the cut of his gybe. Actually, it’s probably a bit of both.
That sense of involvement is helped in no small measure by the astonishing
fidelity and focus of this fine recording, produced by Dan Merceruio and
engineered by Daniel Shores. The Waltz of the Flowers is elegantly
done – Goodyear’s trills and flourishes entirely apt in this context – and,
bizarre as it may seem, his rhythmic verve suddenly made me want to hear
him play Joplin.
What I miss in the Economou arrangement is a sense of excitement, of
inexorable build ups, and that’s precisely what Goodyear delivers in his
thrilling – and thoroughly orchestral – Intrada. As if that weren’t
enough, he artfully mimics the silvery tinkle of the celesta in The Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy. Goodyear brings the dream to an
end with playing that had me in goose-bumps all over. This is another of
those transfiguring moments, as much a soaring triumph for the
pianist-arranger as it is for the composer himself.
Goodyear is no stranger to Olympus, having already recorded all 32
Beethoven sonatas for Marquis. For Steinway he’s tackled the Grieg Piano
Concerto and Tchaikovsky’s First (STNS 30035), plus Rachmaninov’s Second
and Third (STNS 30047). And going back twenty years there’s some Gershwin
with Erich Kunzel and the Cincinnati Pops (Telarc 80445). He’s certainly a
pianist to watch, and I’d love it if he and Steinway/Sono Luminus could
record some Joplin and/or Gershwin. Incidentally, the SACD, derived from
the 24/192 master recordings, sounds every bit as good as this download. As
for the notes, they read more like a promotional brochure than a bona-fide booklet. For once, though, that hardly seems to matter.
Stewart Goodyear is a prodigious talent and, despite minor caveats, his Nutcracker arrangement must be counted a resounding success; factor
in superior sonics and this becomes a very desirable issue indeed.
We are currently
offering in excess of 51,000 reviews
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger