Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Support us financially by purchasing
this through MusicWeb
for £11.75 postage paid world-wide.
Arnold BAX (1880-1953)
Concerto for Cello and Orchestra (1934) [37:56] Stanley BATE (1911-1959)
Concerto for Cello and Orchestra (1953) [22:18]
Lionel Handy (cello)
Royal Scottish National Orchestra/Martin Yates
rec. Henry Wood Hall, Glasgow, Scotland - no recording date given LYRITA SRCD.351 [60:23]
This welcome Lyrita release contains a pair of cello concertos
from two English composers who experienced differing fortunes throughout
their career. Arnold Bax is by far the most renowned of the two. Disappointingly
his considerable number of recordings has not translated into concert
and recital performances. Stanley Bate is not widely known although
in the last five or six years several of his works (Third
Concerto; Sinfonietta No. 1 and Second Piano Concerto on CDLX7282)
have been released on Dutton Epoch.
In the 1930s Bax was at the peak of his compositional powers. With his
tone poems some years behind him Bax’s Cello Concerto from 1934
was written between his Symphonies No.
5 and No.
6, a period during which he was writing some interesting chamber
scores including a String Quintet and an Octet for horn, piano and string
sextet. At the prompting of pianist Harriet Cohen, Bax wrote the Cello
Concerto for the Spanish virtuoso Gaspar Cassadó, a task he found extremely
challenging. Cassadó the dedicatee premièred the work the same year
at the Queen’s Hall, London with the London Symphony Orchestra
under Hamilton Harty. Cassadó soon became uninterested in the concerto,
however, it was taken up by renowned soloist Beatrice
Harrison who performed it on two occasions at the Proms. Music writer
Mark Morris in his book A
Guide to 20th Century Composers (1996) has expressed the view “The
Edwardian flavour of the Cello Concerto rambles too much to be of real
interest.” Rarely appearing on concert programmes today there
is, however, an excellent account played by soloist Raphael Wallfisch
with the London Philharmonic Orchestra under Bryden Thomson that he
recorded in 1986-87 at London for Chandos. The opening Allegro moderato
with its fresh, outdoor feel contrasted with a yearning intimacy reminds
me at times of the Delius Cello Concerto from over a decade earlier.
A nocturne, the central movement marked Lento has a wistful
rather illusive quality and the closing Allegro molto extrovert
on the surface contains an undertow of nervous tension.
As a pupil at the Royal College of Music, London Bate’s list of
teachers included Ralph Vaughan Williams, Arthur Benjamin, R.O. Morris
and Gordon Jacob; all of whom had studied with Stanford. Bate later
studied privately in Paris with Nadia Boulanger and also with Hindemith
in Berlin at the Hochschüle für Musik. Bate was one of a group of British
composers who stayed in the USA during the Second World War years; an
absence that undoubtedly harmed his career in Britain. Returning to
London in 1949 Bate’s music was for the most part ignored and
experiencing severe personal difficulties he committed suicide in 1959.
Bate’s entry in Grove Music Online ends with the rather pointed
comment, “Bate was highly prolific, but his music, with a few
exceptions, lacks enduring quality.” In 1949 Bate had returned
to England and lived in London writing his Cello Concerto in 1953. It
was introduced the following year at the Eastman School of Music, New
York. The booklet notes do not state the name of the soloist. Here Bate
uses the orchestra only sparingly helping to keep the focus of attention
on the soloist who plays virtually continuously. Marked Allegro
the first movement, evocative of an English coastal scene in winter,
has a squally, windswept quality combined with a nervous, rather agitated
character. Reminding me of the sound-world of Alan Rawsthorne the arresting
dark and intense central Andante has long lyrical lines for
the soloist. In the final movement Allegro vivace with its
powerful undercurrents and sense of imminent storm.
Compared to Raphael Wallfisch in the Bax (review),
Lionel Handy’s intonation is nowhere near as pinpoint but it feels
as if he is searching deeper into both scores, providing a greater sense
of engagement. I admire the wealth of tone colours which Handy produces
in a performance that feels unerringly spontaneous. With strong assurance
the Royal Scottish National Orchestra excels under Martin Yates and
provides sensitive accompaniment throughout. Recorded at Henry Wood
Hall, Glasgow the engineering team for Lyrita produces sound quality
which is relatively clear with an ideal balance between cello and orchestra.
Written by Paul Conway the essay in the booklet is to a high standard,
yet, curiously no recording date is given in the liner-notes.
Reviving two worthy English cello concertos Lyrita continues to do English
music a great service. Michael Cookson
Previous review: Nick