One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,514 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                     Editor in Chief: John Quinn              

Some items
to consider


paid for


100th birthday of Mieczyslaw Weinberg on December 8, 2019.
Renate Eggbrecht has recorded all 3 violin Sonatas

Mozart Brahms
Clarinet Quintets

Deaconoff; Stockhausen

Live at the Clifton Festival

Choir at Clifton Cathedral


New Releases

Naxos Classical

Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10

Nimbus Podcast

Obtain 10% discount

Special offer 50% off
15CDs £83 incl. postage

Musicweb sells the following labels

Altus 10% off
Atoll 10% off
CRD 10% off
Hallé 10% off
Lyrita 10% off
Nimbus 10% off
Nimbus Alliance
Prima voce 10% off
Red Priest 10% off
Retrospective 10% off
Saydisc 10% off
Sterling 10% off

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Seen & Heard
Editor Emeritus
   Bill Kenny
MusicWeb Webmaster
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


REVIEW Plain text for smartphones & printers

Support us financially by purchasing this from

The Fitzwilliam Virginal Book - Volume 4
Pieter-Jan Belder (harpsichord)
Gerhard Boogaard (harpsichord)*
rec. May 2014 (CD 1) & April 2015 (CD 2), Chapel of the Capuchin Monastery, Velp, Netherlands DDD
BRILLIANT CLASSICS 95254 [68:27 + 64:38]

This set of two discs is the fourth volume of Pieter-Jan Belder’s complete recording of the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book, one of the main sources of keyboard music by English virginalists. There are still many unanswered questions about the origin of this collection. The traditional view is that it was put together by Francis Tregian the Younger when he was in prison, being a recusant. However, recent reseach has cast doubt on this view. In the liner-notes to his recording of Farnaby's Fantasias (Naxos, 2006) Glen Wilson writes that "[the] recent researches of Ruby Reid Thompson seem to indicate that it was the work of a group of professional scribes, using paper of such rare quality as is only otherwise found in the vicinity of the royal establishments (...). This Fitzwilliam Virginal Book (...) seems to have been intended as a gift for a person of very high rank who desired a large collection of the best English keyboard music."

This is quite relevant with regard to Giles Farnaby, to whom the first disc is entirely devoted. If we believe that the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book was indeed compiled by Tregian there is reason to wonder why he included works by Farnaby. He seems to have had a special preference for Catholic composers, and Farnaby was not only a Protestant, but even a Puritan, which put him at the very other end of the religious spectrum. Moreover, it is traditionally assumed that Farnaby was an amateur composer.

That view is also challenged by Wilson. Farnaby’s father was a joiner and although Giles started his musical studies in 1580 he took up an apprenticeship with the Joiners' Company some years later. In 1592 he was awarded the degree of Bachelor in Music in Oxford. In 1598 he published a collection of canzonettas which was dedicated to an influential courtier and included commendatory verses by, among others, John Dowland and Anthony Holborne. It is also interesting that one of the verses was by the poet Hugh Holland, who was a recusant. Apparently religious differences didn’t matter that much in musical matters.

None of Farnaby's 53 keyboard works were printed during his lifetime. In fact, if they had not been included in the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book we wouldn't have known them, except for two pieces which are preserved in other sources. Most of the genres of keyboard music of the time are represented in Farnaby’s oeuvre. The Fantasias - to which Wilson devoted his recording - represent the most pure contrapuntal pieces. Wilson writes: “The virginalists (...) begin their fantasias by developing one or more themes through the voices, but add to their contrapuntal working a final toccata, a closing section of idiomatic keyboard pyrotechnics and polyrythms, which corresponds with the later idea of a fantasia.” A good example is the Fantasia No. 6 in which Farnaby makes use of the so-called stretto technique: the procedure of beginning a second statement of the subject before the preceding statement has finished, so that the two overlap. We don't find any In nomines - a very popular form at the time - in Farnaby’s oeuvre, probably because he was not active as an organist, unlike most other keyboard composers.

Other common genres were variations on popular tunes, dances and descriptive pieces. Among the best in the former category are ‘Wooddy-Cock’ and ‘Rosasolis’. The most common dances at the time were pavan and galliard, often linked together but not in Farnaby’s oeuvre. For Two Virginals is an alman; it is the very first known piece in music history for two keyboard instruments.

‘Farnabys Conceit’ and ‘A Toye’ are examples of descriptive pieces. ‘His Humour’ - referring not to wit but more generally to a state of mind - includes some striking dissonances. The transcription of vocal pieces was also very common at the time. They reflect the fame of the originals and/or their composers. One of the best-known is John Dowland’s ‘Lacrhymae Pavan’. The ‘Pavana’ (MB 14) is a transcription of a piece by Robert Johnson; another one is the ‘Fantasia’ (MB 3).

The second disc is devoted to John Bull. He was one of the Catholic composers included in the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book. In 1613 he fled England; he suggested that he had done so for religious reasons but in fact he wanted to escape other kinds of difficulty. Throughout his career he had been in conflict with the authorities for various forms of misbehaviour, among them adultery. He started his career as a chorister and later as organist at Hereford Cathedral. He then joined the Chapel Royal as Gentleman. In 1597 he was elected the first Public Reader in music at Gresham College, London. He held this post - with a one year break - until 1607 when he was sacked because of an extramarital affair.

Bull was generally considered one of the greatest keyboard virtuosos of his time. He was the teacher of Elizabeth Stuart, and one of the three composers - the others being William Byrd and Orlando Gibbons - who contributed to Parthenia or The Maydenhead of the first musicke that ever was printed for the Virginalls. This was put together at the occasion of the wedding of Elizabeth Stuart and Frederick V, Count Palatinate of the Rhine, which took place in February 1613.

In Bull’s oeuvre we find a number of pavan and galliard pairs, often with a name of a certain person. The second disc opens with such a pair, called after Lord Lumley. ‘Piper’s Galliard’ is also part of a pavan-galliard pair which was recorded as such on Volume I of this series. The galliard is played here again but then followed by a variation. The last three items are comparable: ‘The Quadran Pavan’ is followed by a variation and the galliard.

The ‘Fantasia’ (MB 4) opens in the form of a bicinium; the number of voices is later extended to four. This piece includes a repeated chromatic motif. Also notable in regard to harmony is the fantasia ‘Ut re mi fa sol la’ in which the hexachord is used in all twelve tonalities. Belder writes: “The piece modulates into distant keys, which indicates that it might have been an experiment in equal-tempered tuning. For this recording, I tuned the instrument in a circular temperament so that all tonalities can be used.”

This recording of the complete Fitzwilliam Virginal Book - the first to date - is a major undertaking, and very important. This collection is often used as a source for recordings of English keyboard music but one usually hears the same pieces over and over again. When this project is finished all the pieces - among them some by rather obscure composers - will be available on disc. Pieter-Jan Belder is a trustworthy guide through this labyrinth. I have not heard the Volumes 2 and 3 yet, but I did review the first volume elsewhere and I was quite happy with Belder's performances. It is the same here. I especially enjoyed his performances of pieces by Farnaby who is one of my favourite composers of the Elizabethan era. I liked Belder's interpretations much better than the slowish performances I heard some years ago at the Utrecht Early Music Festival. The brilliance of Bull’s compositions is also convincingly conveyed. My only regret is that Belder does not use a virginal. In some pieces by Bull even a small organ may be an option.

I am looking forward to the next volume which has been released recently.

Johan van Veen
CD 1
Giles FARNABY (c1563-1640)
Farmers Pavan (CCLXXXVII) (MB 19) [5:41]
Galliarda (CCLXIX) (MB 20) [1:37]
Fantasia (CCXXXVI) (MB 3) [4:00]
Mal Sims (CCLXXXI) (MB 37) [1:33]
Pavana (Rob. Johnson, set by Giles Farnabie) (XXXIX) (MB 14) [4:27]
Meridian Alman (CCXCI) (MB 24) [1:40]
A Maske (CXCVIII) (MB 31) [2:31]
Quodlings Delight (CXIV) (MB 42) [2:37]
Fantasia (CCXXXII) (MB 8) [6:18]
A Maske (CCIX) (MB 33) [1:40]
Wooddy-Cock (CXLI) (MB 40) [6:16]
Fantasia (CCXXXVII) (MB 12) [3:59]
Giles Farnabys Dreame (CXCIV) (MB 50) [1:21]
His Rest Galiard (CXCV) (MB 51) [0:50]
Farnabyes Conceit (CCLXXIII) (MB 52) [0:52]
His Humour (CXCVI) (MB 53) [1:29]
Fantasia (CCXXXI) (MB 6) [3:12]
Rosasolis (CXLIII) (MB 47) [2:29]
Lachrimae Pavan (CCXC) (MB 16) [7:05]
A Toye (CCLXX) (MB 28) [1:10]
A Maske (CXCIX) (MB 32) [1:30]
Tell mee Daphne (CCLXXX) (MB 43) [1:25]
Loth to Depart (CCXXX) (MB 41) [2:23]
For Two Virginals (LV) (MB 25)* [1:09]

CD 2
John BULL (1562/63-1628)
Pavana of my L[ord] Lumley (XLI) (MB 129a) [4:13]
Galliarda to my L[ord] Lumley's Pavan (XI) (MB 129b) [2:21]
Praeludium (CCX) (MB 84) [0:42]
Fantasia (CVIII) (MB 10) [4:29]
Pavana (CXXXVI) (MB 66a) [4:21]
Galliarda (CXXXVII) (MB 66b) [1:58]
Pavana (Fantastic Pavan) (XXXIV) (MB 86a) [6:40]
Galiard to the Pavan (XXXV) (MB 86b) [1:50]
Prelude (CXCII) (MB 119) [0:51]
Ut re mi fa sol la (LI) (MB 17) [5:43]
St Thomas Wake (XXXVI) (MB 126) [3:27]
The Duke of Brunswick's Alman (CXLII) (MB 93) [1:32]
Pipers Galliard (CLXXXII) (MB 89a) [2:16]
Variatio Ejusdem (CLXXXIII) (MB 89b) [2:58]
The Quadran Pavan (XXXI) (MB 127a) [6:59]
Variation of the Quadran Pavan (XXXII) (MB 127b) [8:10]
Galiard to the Quadran Pavan (XXXIII) (MB 127) [5:56]



Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat



Recordings of the Month


Conner Riddle Songs

Rodzinski Sibelius

Of Innocence and Experience


Symphonies 1, 2, 3



Aho Symphony 5

Dowland - A Fancy


Rachmaninov_ Babayan