Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Antonio VIVALDI (1678-1741)
The New Four Seasons [61:01]
Orchestra of Life/Nigel Kennedy (violin and electric violin)
rec. Angel Studios and RAK Studios, 14-20 December 2011 and 26-28 January
2012. DDD SONY 88875076722 [61:01]
I suppose it matters not a jot that I think this is
truly awful and should come with the strongest possible health warning:
it will probably have sold a million by the time that you read this
review. You are alerted in the publicity blurb to the fact that ‘this
is the Four Seasons but not as we know them’. You can say that
again, but I suppose that Nigel’s intention was to upset ‘old geezers’
like myself and to enrage lovers of Vivaldi in general.
I’ve seen it described as ‘Kennedy versus Vivaldi’ and that’s about
right. If you thought that his earlier assaults on the Four Seasons
were OTT, the new recording comes with a few refinements – a heavy metal
accompaniment in places and various noises off, some electronic and
others like barking animals.
The blurb has it that ‘integral to the Kennedy approach is the drum
programming of Massive Attack’s Damon Reece, which adds a mesmerizing
rhythmic pulse underneath the crisply-articulated playing of Kennedy’s
Orchestra of Life’. That rhythmic pulse mostly approximates to the
kind of thumping bass that you often hear coming from several cars away
in the traffic jam.
There’s Vivaldi in there somewhere and just occasionally his music is
interpreted sensitively, but there’s far too little of that. One example
comes in the slow movement of Autumn, on track 13, where even
the added sound effects and the extemporisation on track 14 sound ethereal.
It’s almost superfluous to say that the recording is bright and brings
the music right into your lap. The booklet contains just a few Q and
A musings from Nigel, including the hope that the new recording brightens
your day – it didn’t – and the English texts of Vivaldi’s sonnets.
There are two new recordings of the Seasons which I’ve sampled
that seem much more promising, from La Serenissima and Adrian Chandler
on Avie (AV2344 – likely to challenge even my top period-instrument
recommendations) and James Ehnes, the Sydney Symphony and Andrew Armstrong
on Onyx (ONYX4134). Look out for reviews of these in a forthcoming
edition of Download News.
Normally a short review means that I strongly approve. It means exactly
the opposite in this case. I’d rather go back, if that were the only
alternative, to the rather stodgy Karl Münchinger Ace of Clubs LP on
which I first heard this music. Caveat emptor.
I’m only too pleased that I listened to the streamed version from Qobuz1:
it means that I don’t have to get rid of the CD. I can’t, however,
recommend downloading there, though it comes with the pdf booklet: at
£12.89 in 16-bit sound it’s more expensive than many dealers charge
for the CD, though 24-bit devotees may go for that at £15.19.
Note - The catalogue number 88644 339238 is also used in some
1 subscribers can stream here.
To purchase the download click here.