Antonio Maria MONTANARI (1676 – 1737)
Concerto in C, ‘Dresden’ [9:55]
Concerto in E-flat, Op.1/6 [14:12]
Concerto in A, Op.1/1 [10:10]
Concerto in C, Op.1/5 [6:05]
Concerto in E, Op.1/7 [9:44]
Concerto in A, Op.1/8 [9:41]
Ensemble Diderot/Johannes Pramsohler (violin)
World Premiere Recordings (except Op.1/8)
rec. 2015, Gustav-Mahler-Saal, Toblach. DDD
AUDAX RECORDS ADX13704 [59:47]
Reviewed as 24-bit download, with pdf booklet, from eclassical.com
(also available in mp3 and 16-bit lossless and from dealers on CD)
If you are looking for the Corelli-type concertos that
Arcangelo Corelli never got round to writing, you can listen to the
arrangements which his contemporaries made of his sonatas, such as Geminiani’s
Concerti Grossi based on Corelli’s Op.3 and Op.5. Or you could try
this new recording of six concertos by his recognised successor, Antonio
Maria Montanari, five of which are receiving their world premiere recordings
here. The debt to his great predecessor is apparent but that doesn’t
make them any less enjoyable when they are so well performed and recorded.
We have had a handful of Montanari’s works on record before – one of
the concertos on the new album, Op.1/8, appeared on a KuK recording
entitled Corelli’s Legacy (KuK110) and one of his violin sonatas
on a Passacaille recording with the same title (PAS962). The best of
these earlier recordings is that of his solo Violin Sonata in d minor
from Adrian Chandler and La Serenissima on Per Monsieur Pisendel
2 (Avie AV2308 – review).
The most onerous thing in reviewing that CD for me, in May 2015, was
typing in the details.
The title of that Avie recording reminds us that a number of Italian
composers, including Vivaldi, composed music for Johan Georg Pisendel,
court violinist at Dresden. The first work on the Audax recording is
one such and it’s not far behind Vivaldi’s concertos and sonatas written
for him: an inexpensive and generally stylish series of four recordings
of Dresden Concertos from Naxos would be a good place to explore
those (8.553792, 8.553793, 8.553860 and 8.554310). There’s also a Naïve
recording which Michael Cookson recommended – review
– and Johan van Veen made a similar album on Alpha Recording
of the Month.
With only one benchmark, for Op.1/8, recorded by the EU Baroque Orchestra
on that KuK CD, this new recording is unlikely to be surpassed in the
near future, though I hope that we shall have more attempts – perhaps
also some editions and recordings of works by Montanari as yet undiscovered.
The KuK performance of Op.1/8, though lasting almost exactly the same
time overall, adopts quite different tempi in individual movements from
those on Audax:
- EU Baroque Orchestra: 1:18 + 2:27 + 2:54 + 3:01
- Ensemble Diderot: 2:10 + 2:08 + 2:46 + 2:37
That suggests that the EU players take the opening adagio too
fast: I think they do, but the result is more enjoyable than I expected
and both approaches work well. Ensemble Diderot adopt what is much
more the general concept of adagio without allowing the music
to drag and the contrast with the second movement, allegro, taken
at much the same pace on both recordings, is all the more effective.
You can try both for yourself from Qobuz – subscribers can stream the
whole concerto and others can sample.
The other variation is in the vivace finale, taken noticeably
faster on the new recording. Jonathan Woolf found Pramsohler’s earlier
Audax recording of sonatas by Corelli, etc., rather explosive in places
– but there’s no sense of his overdoing things in this movement. In
fact, though he’s faster than Riccardo Minasi who directs the performance
on KuK, it’s the latter who makes the music ‘bulge’ rather more here.
It’s enough to knock you off your perch the first time but I suspect
that Pramsohler’s more level approach will be the more satisfying for
The performances overall are very satisfying indeed, with little or
no sense of the ‘ceaseless striving’ or ‘remorseless features’ which
MC found in the earlier recital, though perhaps some of the ‘exultant
dynamism’ has worn off in the process. Maybe his thinking on baroque
music has matured in the interim – what I hear on this recording sounds
more like the considered and beautiful playing of someone who was influenced
by Rachel Podger, whose own new recording of Biber’s Mystery
or Rosary Sonatas, just released on Channel Classics, offers
a most enjoyable half-way house between extremes of interpretation of
those works – review pending.
The excellent notes by Michael Talbot add to the appeal of this recording.
Himself the author of a long article on Montanari, he also refers to
two recent books on the baroque concerto which speak highly of the composer.
He is, nevertheless, more cautious than I am inclined to be in pressing
the claims of a neglected composer.
This recording has made me want to hear more of Montanari’s music, a
recommendation in itself. It has also made we want to hear more from
the period-instrument Ensemble Diderot – as I conclude this review I’m
in the process of downloading their earlier album of trio sonatas by
Handel, Fux, Fasch and Tuma, including three world premiere recordings,
(The Dresden Album, ADX13701). Look out for a future review,
perhaps in a forthcoming edition of Download News.